A threshold security is a US equity security that has had a large and persistent level of settlement failures and has therefore been placed on a published list under Regulation SHO, the short-selling rule of the Securities and Exchange Commission. Inclusion on the list subjects the security to stricter delivery requirements, which are meant to stop each fail to deliver from lingering and accumulating.
The concept was introduced when Regulation SHO took effect in January 2005, in response to concern about naked short selling, in which shares are sold short without being borrowed and are not delivered at settlement. Threshold lists are published each trading day by the self-regulatory organizations: exchanges such as the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq for the securities they list, and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority for over-the-counter equity securities.
The definition under Regulation SHO
Rule 203 of Regulation SHO defines a threshold security as an equity security of an issuer that is registered with, or files reports with, the SEC and that, for five consecutive settlement days, meets three conditions:
- There is an aggregate fail to deliver position at a registered clearing agency of 10,000 shares or more.
- That position equals at least 0.5 percent of the issuer's total shares outstanding.
- The security is included on a list published by a self-regulatory organization.
The clearing agency in practice is the National Securities Clearing Corporation, a subsidiary of the Depository Trust and Clearing Corporation, which nets most US equity trades through its Continuous Net Settlement system. The second condition can be written as:
For an issuer with 40 million shares outstanding, 0.5 percent is 200,000 shares. Fails of 150,000 shares would meet the first condition but not the second, since percent. For a company with 1 million shares outstanding, 0.5 percent is only 5,000 shares, so the 10,000-share floor is the binding test. A security comes off the list once it has not met the threshold for five consecutive settlement days.
What the listing requires
The main consequence is a close-out requirement. A clearing participant that has had a fail to deliver position in a threshold security for 13 consecutive settlement days must immediately close it out by purchasing securities of like kind and quantity, a forced purchase similar to a buy-in. Until it does, the participant, and any broker-dealer for which it clears, may not make further short sales in that security without first borrowing the shares or entering into a firm arrangement to borrow them. This pre-borrow standard is stricter than the ordinary requirement to locate shares before a short sale.
Two exceptions in the original rule were later removed. A grandfather provision, which exempted fails that predated a security's appearance on the list, was eliminated in 2007, and an exception for options market makers was eliminated in 2008.
Relationship to Rule 204
After the market turmoil of 2008 the SEC adopted Rule 204, first as a temporary rule and then permanently in 2009. It applies to all equity securities, not only threshold securities. A clearing participant must close out a fail arising from a short sale by the start of regular trading on the settlement day after the settlement date, with extra days allowed for fails from long sales and from bona fide market making.
Because that deadline arrives well before 13 days, Rule 204 now does most of the work, and the number of threshold securities fell sharply after it was adopted. The threshold list remains as a backstop and as a public disclosure. The move of US equities to T+1 settlement in May 2024 shortened the settlement cycle but left the structure of these rules unchanged.
How market participants read the list
The lists name the securities only. They do not show the size of the fails or who is responsible, although the SEC separately publishes fails-to-deliver data twice a month. Traders treat a listing as a sign that the shares are hard to borrow, that borrowing costs may be high and that brokers may refuse short sales or insist on a pre-borrow. Some read a listing combined with high short interest as a condition for a short squeeze, since close-outs force purchases.
The inference has limits. Fails to deliver arise from long sales as well as short sales, for example through processing delays, problems with paper certificates or the creation and redemption of shares in exchange-traded funds, which appear on threshold lists regularly. The SEC's own guidance states that a listing is not evidence of abusive or illegal short selling, and research on whether fails depress share prices has produced mixed results.
Criticism
Issuers and investors in heavily shorted companies have argued that the thresholds are set too high, that 13 settlement days is too long and that fails can persist outside central clearing, where the rule does not measure them. Market makers and some academics argue the opposite: that strict close-out rules raise the cost of providing liquidity in thinly traded shares, and that short selling contributes to accurate pricing. The lists themselves are sometimes criticised as uninformative, because they give no quantities.