Home / Wiki / N / Naked Short Selling

Naked Short Selling

Legal Law and EnforcementUpdated 16 Nov 2026

Naked short selling is the sale of shares that the seller neither owns nor has borrowed, and has not arranged to borrow, before the trade. In ordinary short selling the seller borrows the shares through securities lending, or at least confirms that they can be borrowed, so that they can be delivered to the buyer on the settlement date. A naked short seller skips that step. If no shares are found by settlement, the trade results in a fail to deliver, and the buyer holds a claim to shares that have not arrived.

The practice is not always deliberate abuse. Fails occur for operational reasons, and market makers have long been allowed to sell short without a prior borrow when meeting customer demand. What regulators target is naked shorting that is abusive: selling large amounts of stock that cannot be delivered in order to drive down the price. In the United States the rules are set by the Securities and Exchange Commission, and in the European Union by the Short Selling Regulation.

01

How a naked short arises

A standard short sale follows a sequence: the broker locates shares available to borrow, the client sells, and the borrowed shares are delivered at settlement. Brokers keep lists of easy-to-borrow stocks for which a locate can be assumed, and must make specific arrangements for hard-to-borrow ones. Some traders choose to pre-borrow scarce shares so that delivery is certain.

A sale becomes naked when the seller has no locate and no borrow and does not deliver on time. Within the US clearing system, a fail does not stop the buyer's trade from being recorded, and at the clearing agency the obligation is carried forward through continuous net settlement. This mechanism is the source of the claim, made by critics, that naked shorting can create phantom shares. The buyer is owed real stock, and the seller remains obliged to deliver it.

02

Regulation in the United States

The SEC's Regulation SHO, in force since January 2005, is the main body of US short-sale rules. Its key requirements are:

  • Locate. Before accepting a short sale in an equity security, a broker-dealer must have borrowed the shares, arranged to borrow them, or have reasonable grounds to believe they can be borrowed for delivery when due. Bona fide market making is exempt.
  • Close-out. Rule 204, made permanent in 2009 after a temporary version in 2008, requires a participant of a registered clearing agency with a fail from a short sale to close it out by buying or borrowing shares by the start of trading on the day after the settlement date.
  • Threshold securities. Stocks with large and persistent fails appear on published lists, and stricter delivery obligations apply to them.

In 2008 the SEC also adopted Rule 10b-21, which makes it fraud to deceive a broker or buyer about the intention or ability to deliver shares sold short. During the 2008 financial crisis it issued emergency orders restricting naked short sales in the shares of large financial firms. A broker that cannot deliver may be forced into a buy-in, purchasing shares on the seller's behalf.

03

Rules elsewhere

The European Union's Short Selling Regulation, which applied from November 2012, prohibits uncovered short sales in shares admitted to trading in the EU unless the seller has borrowed the shares, has an enforceable claim to them, or has a locate arrangement from a third party. It also restricts uncovered positions in sovereign credit default swaps and requires disclosure of large net short positions. The United Kingdom kept a similar regime after leaving the EU. Many other markets, including several in Asia, ban naked short selling outright.

04

Debate and criticism

Opponents of naked shorting argue that it allows sellers to flood the market with stock that does not exist, depressing prices and harming companies, and they treat persistent fails as evidence of market manipulation. Small companies have sometimes blamed falling share prices on naked shorting, though such claims are hard to prove.

Defenders of short selling, and many academic studies, point out that fails to deliver in most stocks are small and short-lived, that a locate requirement and close-out rules already limit abuse, and that restrictions on short selling tend to reduce liquidity and slow the incorporation of negative information into prices. Research on the 2008 restrictions generally found wider spreads and little evidence that they halted price declines. A rush by short sellers to buy back scarce shares can also produce a short squeeze, showing that shorting carries risk for the seller as well. The short interest reported for each stock includes only positions that brokers record, and so is not a direct measure of naked selling.

Last updated 16 Nov 2026