Continuous Net Settlement (CNS) is the core accounting and settlement system of the National Securities Clearing Corporation (NSCC), the clearing house for nearly all broker-to-broker trades in US shares, corporate bonds, municipal bonds and exchange-traded funds. The system adds up everything each member firm has bought and sold in a security and reduces it to a single net amount to deliver or receive each day, with one net payment of money covering all securities.
The NSCC is a subsidiary of the Depository Trust and Clearing Corporation and is supervised by the Securities and Exchange Commission. The system serves broker-dealers and banks that are members, including every large clearing broker, and through them the whole US securities market.
How netting works
After trades are executed and matched, the clearing house steps into the middle of each one, becoming the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer. It thereby acts as a central counterparty and guarantees completion of the trade even if the original counterparty fails. Because every obligation now runs to or from the same party, a member's purchases and sales in a security can be offset against each other. This is a form of multilateral netting.
The net position in each security is:
A positive result is a long position, meaning shares to be received from the clearing house, and a negative result is a short position, meaning shares to be delivered to it.
Suppose a member buys 1,000 shares of a company from firm A at 50 dollars, sells 700 to firm B at 51 and sells 200 to firm C at 51 on the same day. Its net position is shares long. Instead of one receipt and two deliveries totalling 1,900 shares, it receives 100 shares. On the money side it owes dollars and is owed , so it pays a net 4,100 dollars. That amount is combined with its net figures in every other security into a single payment or receipt for the day.
Settlement
Securities move by electronic book entry at the Depository Trust Company, the group's central securities depository. Members with short positions have shares taken from their depository accounts, and the system allocates those shares to members with long positions. Money is settled once at the end of the day through the Fedwire system, with each member paying or receiving one net sum through a settling bank. This arrangement is a type of deferred net settlement.
Since 28 May 2024 the standard settlement date for most US securities trades has been one business day after the trade, shortened from two.
The continuous feature
The word continuous refers to what happens when a delivery is not made. If a member with a short position does not have the shares on settlement day, the position does not stay attached to a particular trade. It remains open and is carried forward, where it is netted again with the member's new trades in the same security settling the next day. An unsettled obligation is called a fail, and the system marks open fails to the current market price each day so that the money owed stays in line with the value of the shares.
A member that is owed shares can press for delivery by submitting a notice through the system, which may lead to a buy-in at the expense of a member that has failed to deliver. Separately, federal rules on short selling require members to close out fails to deliver within set periods, and securities with persistent fails are placed on a published threshold list.
Benefits
Netting sharply reduces the number and value of movements needed. The clearing house reports that it cuts the value of obligations requiring settlement by around 98 percent on an average day. Fewer movements mean lower costs, less operational error and smaller demands for cash and securities during the day. The guarantee removes the need for each firm to assess the credit of every trading partner, which is essential in markets where buyers and sellers are matched anonymously. The combined effect is to lower settlement risk for the market as a whole.
Risk management and criticism
By guaranteeing trades the clearing house takes on the risk that a member defaults before settlement. It protects itself by requiring each member to deposit collateral in its clearing fund, sized to the member's unsettled positions and to market volatility, and it can demand more during the day. In January 2021, sharp price moves in a small number of heavily traded shares produced very large calls for extra deposits, which led some brokers to restrict customer buying and prompted debate about the rules. The episode was one of the arguments for shortening the settlement cycle, since fewer days of unsettled trades mean less exposure and lower deposits.
Other criticism concerns fails. Because fails are carried forward and netted, a specific failed delivery cannot be traced to a specific buyer, and critics have argued that this tolerates prolonged failures to deliver. Regulators responded with stricter close-out requirements after 2008. Concentrating the market's risk in one central body is also a concern in itself, and for that reason the clearing house is designated as systemically important and subject to heightened supervision.