The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) is a not-for-profit organization that regulates brokerage firms and their staff in the United States. It is not a government agency. It is a self-regulatory organization, a private body authorised by federal law to write and enforce rules for its members, and it works under the oversight of the Securities and Exchange Commission. Almost every broker-dealer that does business with the public in the United States must be a member.
FINRA writes conduct rules, licenses individuals, examines firms, monitors trading, brings disciplinary cases and runs the industry's main arbitration forum. It is funded by fees and assessments paid by member firms and by income from its services, not by taxpayers. Its head offices are in Washington and New York.
History
The legal basis for self-regulation dates from the 1930s. The Securities Exchange Act of 1934 placed the stock exchanges under federal supervision, and a 1938 amendment known as the Maloney Act allowed associations of dealers in the over-the-counter market to register and police their own members. The National Association of Securities Dealers (NASD) was formed under that law in 1939. In 1971 it launched the electronic quotation system that became Nasdaq, which it later sold.
FINRA was created in July 2007 by combining the NASD with the member regulation, enforcement and arbitration functions of the New York Stock Exchange. The merger was meant to end the duplication faced by firms that had been supervised by both bodies under two rulebooks.
Functions
- Rule-making. FINRA writes rules on sales practices, communications with the public, supervision, margin, trade reporting and financial responsibility. New rules and amendments must be approved by the commission.
- Registration and licensing. People who sell securities or supervise those who do must pass qualification examinations and register through the Central Registration Depository. The public can look up the record of a firm or individual through the free BrokerCheck service.
- Examinations. Staff inspect member firms on a regular cycle and after complaints, checking sales practices, capital, record-keeping and controls such as anti-money laundering programmes.
- Market oversight. FINRA carries out market surveillance across US share and options markets, partly under contract to exchanges, looking for manipulation, insider trading and breaches of trading rules.
- Market transparency. It operates the facilities to which off-exchange share trades are reported and the TRACE system, which since 2002 has collected and published prices of corporate bond trades. It also collects short interest reports from firms.
- Dispute resolution. It runs the largest securities arbitration and mediation forum in the country, used for disputes between customers and firms and between firms and their employees.
- Investor education. It publishes guidance and alerts for investors and funds research through an affiliated foundation.
Enforcement powers
FINRA can bring an enforcement action against a member firm or a registered person. Sanctions include fines, orders to repay customers, suspension, and a permanent bar from the industry. It cannot bring criminal charges or act against people outside its membership, and refers such matters to the commission or to prosecutors. A decision can be appealed within FINRA, then to the commission and then to a federal court of appeals.
Typical cases involve unsuitable recommendations, excessive trading in customer accounts, misleading sales material, failures of supervision, late or inaccurate trade reports and failures to obtain best execution for customer orders.
Limits of its remit
FINRA's authority covers broker-dealers. An investment adviser is regulated by the commission or by a state, although many firms and individuals are registered in both capacities. Futures firms answer to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the National Futures Association. Rules for the municipal bond market are written by the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board, and FINRA enforces them for its members. State securities regulators apply their own blue sky laws alongside the federal system.
Governance and criticism
FINRA is run by a board of governors on which members from outside the industry hold a majority of seats, with the remainder elected by firms of different sizes. The commission can review its rules, its disciplinary decisions and its operations.
Critics question whether a body funded by the industry can regulate it firmly, and point to frauds at member firms that went undetected for years. Investor advocates object that brokerage contracts usually require customers to use FINRA arbitration in place of the courts, and that unpaid arbitration awards are a recurring problem. Small firms complain about the cost of compliance. FINRA's position as a private organization exercising public regulatory power has also been challenged in court on constitutional grounds. Supporters reply that self-regulation brings industry knowledge and funding that a government agency would lack.