The Trust Indenture Act of 1939 is a United States federal law that governs the contracts under which most publicly offered debt securities are issued. It requires that bonds, notes and debentures registered for public sale be issued under an indenture that has been qualified with the Securities and Exchange Commission, and that the indenture name an eligible, independent trustee to protect the interests of the holders. The Act sets minimum standards for the trustee's qualifications, conflicts of interest and duties, and for the rights of investors.
The law sits alongside the Securities Act of 1933, which governs the registration and disclosure of new offerings, and is administered by the SEC. It was one of the securities statutes passed in the decade after the Great Depression. It applies to the indenture and trustee, not to the credit quality of the bonds, and it does not cover equity securities.
Background
Before 1939, corporate bond indentures commonly named a bank as trustee, but the role was often largely administrative. In the defaults of the early 1930s, many trustees did little to protect investors, and some had conflicts of interest, for example because they were also lenders to the issuer. An SEC study of reorganisations and protective committees, directed by William O. Douglas before he joined the Supreme Court, documented these problems and recommended federal standards. Congress responded with the Trust Indenture Act, which made an active, independent trustee a condition of selling debt to the public.
Key requirements
Before a registration statement for covered debt can become effective, the indenture must be qualified, and the trustee files a statement of eligibility. The main requirements are:
- Eligible trustee. At least one trustee must be a corporation, usually a bank or trust company, that is authorised to exercise trust powers, is subject to supervision and meets minimum capital requirements.
- Conflicts of interest. The Act lists relationships that create a conflict, such as acting as trustee under another indenture of the same issuer in certain cases or being a creditor or affiliate of the issuer. If the trustee has a conflict and the securities are in default, it must eliminate the conflict or resign within a set period.
- Duties before and after default. Before a default, the trustee need only perform the duties written into the indenture. After a default, it must use the same degree of care and skill as a prudent person would in managing their own affairs, which is the core investor protection of the Act.
- Reports and information. The issuer must provide the trustee with periodic reports and certificates of compliance, and the trustee must send reports to holders and keep lists of bondholders so that they can communicate with one another.
- Right to payment. Section 316(b) provides that the right of any holder to receive principal and interest when due, and to sue for it, cannot be impaired without that holder's consent.
Exemptions
The Act covers debt that must be registered under the Securities Act. It therefore does not apply to securities exempt from registration, including US government and municipal bonds, securities issued by banks, and debt sold in a private placement or to institutional buyers under Rule 144A. Small offerings below thresholds set in the statute and SEC rules, and certain offerings under Regulation A, are also exempt. In practice, many high-yield bonds first sold under Rule 144A are later swapped for registered notes, at which point the indenture must be qualified, so the Act's standards are widely followed even in private markets.
Amendment and debate
The Trust Indenture Reform Act of 1990 modernised the law. It made the Act's mandatory provisions apply automatically to qualified indentures, whether or not they are written out, and limited the conflict-of-interest rules so that they bite mainly once a default has occurred, reducing the burden on trustees while bonds are performing.
The most debated provision is Section 316(b). Because individual holders cannot lose their right to payment without consent, an issuer cannot cut principal or interest on registered bonds by a majority vote of holders, unlike under the collective action clauses common in sovereign and European bonds. Out-of-court debt restructuring therefore relies on voluntary exchange offers, often paired with changes to other covenants, or on a court process under bankruptcy law. In 2017 a federal appeals court, in a case involving Education Management Corporation, read the section narrowly as protecting only the formal legal right to payment, not the practical ability to collect. Critics argue that the provision encourages holdout behaviour and coercive restructuring tactics; supporters see it as a basic protection for small investors.