An exchange-traded fund (ETF) is a pooled investment fund whose shares are listed and traded on a stock exchange throughout the day, like ordinary company shares. Each share represents a slice of a portfolio that may hold equities, bonds, commodities or, more recently, crypto-assets. Most ETFs track an index at low cost, although a growing number are actively managed. US mutual funds may add a 12b-1 fee, and index funds are judged by their tracking error and R-squared.
ETFs sit between the traditional mutual fund and the direct purchase of securities. Like a mutual fund, an ETF has a net asset value (NAV) calculated from its holdings; unlike a mutual fund, investors buy and sell its shares on an exchange through a broker at market prices that move during the trading day. In the United States, most ETFs are registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940 and supervised by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC); in Europe most are UCITS funds.
Exchange-traded funds in plain terms
Imagine a basket that already contains a little of every fruit in the market. Instead of buying each fruit separately, you buy a ticket for a share of the basket. You can sell that ticket to someone else whenever the market is open, and its price follows the value of the fruit inside.
A small group of large wholesalers is allowed to swap fruit for new tickets, or hand tickets back for fruit. If the ticket price drifts above the fruit's value, they make new tickets and sell them; if it drifts below, they buy tickets and swap them back. That constant swapping keeps the ticket price close to what the basket is really worth.
How the creation and redemption mechanism works
The feature that sets ETFs apart is the primary market, where new shares are created and old ones cancelled. Only approved firms called authorized participants, usually large dealers, deal with the fund directly. They deliver a basket of securities (or cash) to the fund and receive a large block of ETF shares, called a creation unit; redemption runs the same process in reverse.
This process is a form of arbitrage. When the market price rises above NAV, authorized participants create shares and sell them; when it falls below, they buy shares on the exchange and redeem them. Independent market makers quote prices to everyone else in the secondary market. For funds holding assets that trade only occasionally, such as some corporate bonds, the price can still move away from NAV in stressed markets, as happened briefly in March 2020.
Because redemptions are usually paid in securities rather than cash, the fund does not always have to sell holdings to meet outflows. In the United States this in-kind process helps ETFs distribute fewer taxable capital gains than comparable mutual funds.
History
The Toronto Stock Exchange launched an early index product, Toronto 35 Index Participation units, in 1990. In the United States the SPDR S&P 500 Trust began trading in January 1993 and remains one of the most heavily traded securities in the world. Europe's first ETFs listed in 2000.
Growth accelerated after the 2008 financial crisis as investors moved toward low-cost index investing. In 2019 the SEC adopted Rule 6c-11, which let most plain ETFs launch without individual exemptive relief. On 10 January 2024 the SEC approved the listing of spot Bitcoin (BTC) exchange-traded products, followed by spot Ethereum (ETH) products later that year. Strictly, those crypto products are trusts registered under the Securities Act of 1933 rather than 1940 Act funds, so they are often called exchange-traded products (ETPs).
Types of ETFs
- Index ETFs. These track a published index such as a broad equity market, a sector or a government bond benchmark, and are periodically adjusted when the index changes (see ETF rebalancing).
- Bond ETFs. These hold portfolios of government or corporate debt, including short-dated Treasury bills, and give investors exchange-traded access to markets that are otherwise traded over the counter.
- Commodity ETFs and ETPs. Some hold physical metal in a vault, as with gold products backed by allocated gold, while others use a futures contract strategy.
- Active ETFs. A portfolio manager chooses the holdings rather than following an index. Active ETFs have been one of the fastest-growing segments in the US since 2020.
- Leveraged and inverse ETFs. These use derivatives to deliver a multiple, or the opposite, of an index's daily return. Because they reset daily, their returns over longer periods can differ sharply from the stated multiple.
ETFs are also a reference model for tokenized funds and tokenized money market funds, which issue fund shares as blockchain tokens rather than exchange-listed securities.
Costs, risks and oversight
The main cost is the expense ratio, an annual fee deducted from fund assets; broad index ETFs often charge less than 0.1% a year. Investors also pay the bid-ask spread when they trade, which is wider for small or specialised funds, and may pay broker commissions.
- Market risk. An ETF does not protect against falls in the assets it holds; an equity ETF falls with the stock market.
- Tracking error. Fees, cash drag and sampling mean an index ETF's return can differ slightly from its index.
- Liquidity risk. A fund's own trading volume can be low even when its holdings are liquid, and the reverse can also happen.
- Counterparty risk. Synthetic ETFs, more common in Europe, use swaps with a bank to deliver index returns and depend on that bank performing.
Most ETFs keep their assets with an independent custodian and use a fund administrator to calculate NAV. Regulators publish daily holdings and premium or discount disclosures for many funds so that investors can compare market price with underlying value. ETFs are distinct from hedge funds and private equity funds, which are generally open only to professional or wealthy investors and do not trade on an exchange.