What is Regulation SHO?
Definition: Regulation SHO is a set of rules of the US Securities and Exchange Commission that governs short selling of equities, requiring sellers to locate shares to borrow, requiring failures to deliver to be closed out, and restricting short sales in steeply falling stocks.
Regulation SHO is the framework adopted by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in 2004, with compliance beginning in January 2005, to regulate short selling of US-listed equity securities. It replaced older and patchier rules with a single regime under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, with the stated aims of preventing abusive failures to deliver, keeping short selling orderly and giving regulators a clear way to mark and monitor short sales.
It applies to broker-dealers and to the exchanges and clearing agencies through which short sales are executed, and is enforced by the SEC and by self-regulatory bodies including the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA). The regulation has been amended several times, most notably to add emergency anti-abuse measures in 2008 and the alternative uptick rule in 2010.
Background and the end of the original uptick rule
Until 2007, short sales in the United States were restricted by an uptick rule dating from 1938, which allowed a short sale only at a price above the previous trade, or at the same price after a rise. Regulation SHO opened with a pilot programme that began in 2005 and suspended price tests for a sample of stocks. After the SEC reviewed the results, it removed the price test altogether in 2007.
The regulation also introduced standard order marking. A broker-dealer must label every sell order as long, short or short exempt, so that short sales can be identified and the other rules applied. This marking is the foundation of the monitoring and surveillance used by regulators and exchanges.
Locate and delivery requirements
The core rule, Rule 203, forbids a broker-dealer from accepting a short sale order unless it has first borrowed the shares, has arranged to borrow them, or has reasonable grounds to believe they can be borrowed so that they can be delivered on the settlement date. This is the locate requirement. It was designed to curb naked short selling, in which shares are sold short without borrowing them, leaving a seller unable to deliver.
There are exceptions. Bona fide market makers may be exempt for activity connected with making a market, and a firm may rely on lists of securities that are easy to borrow.
Close-out of failures to deliver
A fail to deliver occurs when a seller does not deliver shares on the settlement date. Rule 204 requires the clearing participant to close out a fail that resulted from a short sale by buying or borrowing shares of like kind and quantity, by the start of trading on the business day after the settlement date. A participant that does not comply may not accept further short sales in that stock, for itself or for customers, unless the shares are first borrowed.
Separately, Regulation SHO has a longer-term device for persistent failures. A security is a threshold security if, at a registered clearing agency such as the Depository Trust and Clearing Corporation, it has fails of 10,000 shares or more that equal at least 0.5 per cent of the shares outstanding for five consecutive settlement days. Exchanges publish a list of such securities. Fails in a threshold security that stay open for 13 consecutive settlement days must be closed out, and until then the broker-dealer may not accept further short sales without pre-borrowing.
Rule 201 and the alternative uptick rule
After the financial crisis of 2008, the SEC adopted Rule 201 in 2010 as a form of circuit breaker, with compliance from 2011. It is triggered when a stock falls by 10 per cent or more from the prior day's closing price on its primary market. The restriction then applies for the rest of that day and the whole of the next, during which a short sale may be made only at a price above the national best bid. This is known as the alternative uptick rule.
The rule is meant to stop short sellers from adding to a price slide and to let long holders sell first. Some exemptions apply, such as for sales in a good-faith belief that the seller owns the shares.
Enforcement and criticism
The SEC and FINRA have taken action against firms that failed to meet locate and close-out duties, and settlements typically involve fines and undertakings to improve controls. Rules designed for settlement-date delivery have also had to be reviewed as settlement cycles shortened, as with T+1 settlement.
Critics have said that the rule is hard to police, since the locate requirement relies on firms' own judgment, and that persistent fails in some stocks remained high. Others argue short selling provides useful price discovery and liquidity, and that restrictions can increase volatility. High short interest that is followed by a short squeeze has revived debate about whether the rules deliver what they set out to do. Related rules on trade routing and quote quality are in Regulation NMS.
External links
Ref 1210000788