The uptick rule is a United States securities regulation that restricts short selling when prices are falling, by allowing a short sale only at a price above the most recent price or the current best bid. The term covers two different rules adopted by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): the original Rule 10a-1, in force from 1938 to 2007, and the "alternative uptick rule", Rule 201 of Regulation SHO, adopted in 2010 and still in force.
Both rules aim to stop short sellers from accelerating a decline by repeatedly selling at lower prices, a tactic associated with bear raids. The old rule applied at all times and was tested against the last sale price, while Rule 201 is a circuit breaker that applies only after a stock has dropped sharply and is tested against the national best bid. The rules sit alongside other short-selling controls, such as the locate requirement and the close-out rules aimed at naked short selling.
Rule 10a-1 and the tick test
The SEC adopted Rule 10a-1 in 1938, under its authority in the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 to regulate short sales. The market declines of the Great Depression and inquiries into bear raiding in the early 1930s had raised concerns that unrestricted short selling could drive prices down.
The rule used a "tick test" based on the price of the last reported trade. A short sale was permitted only:
- On a plus tick, meaning at a price higher than the last sale price (an uptick).
- On a zero-plus tick, meaning at the same price as the last sale, provided that price was itself higher than the last different price before it.
Short sales on a minus tick (a downtick) or a zero-minus tick were prohibited. For example, if trades printed at $20.00, $20.05 and then $20.05 again, a short sale at $20.05 was allowed, because the last change in price had been upward. If the sequence was $20.05, $20.00 and $20.00, a short sale at $20.00 was not allowed. Rule 10a-1 applied to exchange-listed securities; stocks traded on Nasdaq were long subject instead to a separate bid test set by the National Association of Securities Dealers. Brokers often handled the rule with tick-sensitive orders that could execute only when the tick condition was met.
Repeal in 2007
The SEC adopted Regulation SHO in 2004 to modernise short-sale rules. As part of it, the agency ran a pilot from 2005 that suspended the tick test for a sample of stocks and compared their trading with a control group. Studies of the pilot found little evidence that removing the test harmed market quality. Decimal pricing, introduced in 2001, had also reduced the size of a tick to one cent, making the test less meaningful. In 2007 the SEC eliminated Rule 10a-1 and barred exchanges from applying their own price tests; the repeal took effect in July 2007.
Rule 201: the alternative uptick rule
The repeal was followed within months by the 2008 financial crisis, during which the SEC temporarily banned short selling in many financial stocks. Calls to restore a price test followed, and in February 2010 the SEC adopted Rule 201, known as the alternative uptick rule, with compliance required from 2011.
Rule 201 is triggered when the price of a covered security falls by 10 per cent or more from its previous day's closing price. The trigger condition can be written as:
where is a trade price during the day and is the prior day's closing price. For a stock that closed at $50.00, the trigger price is , so a trade at $45.00 or below activates the rule. Once triggered, the restriction lasts for the rest of that day and the whole of the following trading day. During that period, trading centres must prevent short sales from being executed or displayed at or below the current national best bid, although orders marked "short exempt" under certain exceptions may proceed. The rule applies to equities listed on US national exchanges, and trading centres meet it through written policies and procedures rather than a trade-by-trade tick test.
Debate and effects
Supporters of price tests argue that they reduce the risk of manipulative bear raids and help restore confidence during sharp declines. Critics reply that short sellers supply liquidity and aid price discovery, that the tests make markets less efficient by delaying the incorporation of negative information, and that evidence for their stabilising effect is weak. Rule 201 was designed as a compromise: it leaves short selling unrestricted in normal conditions and applies only to stocks already in steep decline. It complements the market-wide and single-stock circuit breakers that halt or limit trading during extreme moves, and like them it is part of the broader framework against market manipulation.
External links
Ref 1210000717