What is seaworthiness?
Definition: The condition of a ship that is fit, in structure, crew, equipment and cargo spaces, to meet the normal risks of the voyage it is about to make.
Seaworthiness is the fitness of a ship to undertake a particular voyage with the cargo it is to carry. It is judged by reference to the ship's hull and machinery, the number and competence of the crew, the equipment, supplies and documents on board, and the readiness of the holds or tanks to receive the cargo. A ship may be fit for one voyage and not for another, so the test is tied to the voyage, the season and the cargo, and it is applied at a set time, normally the start of the voyage.
The concept sits at the centre of the law of carriage by sea and of marine insurance. A shipowner or carrier owes a duty about it to cargo owners and charterers, and a failure can decide who bears the loss when cargo is damaged. The duty appears in the Hague Rules and the Hague-Visby Rules, in the terms of a Charterparty, and in the cover given by Marine Insurance. The term used for a ship that fails the test is unseaworthiness.
Elements of seaworthiness
Courts and the rules treat seaworthiness as having several parts, each of which can be the cause of a claim:
- Structural and mechanical fitness. The hull, engines, steering and safety systems must be sound, and the ship should hold the certificates issued by its flag state and its classification society as evidence of this.
- Manning. The master and crew must be competent and in sufficient number for the voyage, and must hold the required qualifications.
- Equipment, stores and documents. The ship needs charts, navigation aids, fuel, water and provisions for the voyage, and the certificates required by international conventions.
- Cargoworthiness. The holds, tanks, refrigeration and other cargo spaces must be fit and safe to receive, carry and keep the particular cargo.
Fitness of this kind is distinct from the safety of a port, covered by Safe Port and Safe Berth, which concerns the place the ship goes to and not the ship itself.
The carrier's duty under the Hague and Hague-Visby Rules
Under Article III of the Hague Rules, which the Hague-Visby Rules keep, the carrier must exercise due diligence, before and at the beginning of the voyage, to make the ship seaworthy, to man, equip and supply her properly and to make the holds and other cargo spaces fit and safe for the cargo. This is a duty of due diligence and not an absolute guarantee.
Article IV provides that the carrier is not liable for loss or damage resulting from unseaworthiness unless it was caused by want of due diligence, and the carrier has the burden of proving that due diligence was exercised. English law treats the duty as one that cannot be delegated: in The Muncaster Castle (1961), the House of Lords held that the carrier was responsible for the lack of care of an independent ship repairer. The Hamburg Rules take a different approach, based on a presumption of fault by the carrier. The duty is normally recorded in the Bill of Lading, which incorporates the rules.
Seaworthiness in charterparties
Where the Hague or Hague-Visby Rules do not apply, a contract of carriage under English law has an implied term, in the absence of contrary wording, that the ship is seaworthy at the start of the voyage, and this implied term is absolute: the owner is liable for unseaworthiness even if it used all reasonable care. In a Voyage Charter it is therefore usually a strict obligation, so that the owner takes the risk of hidden defects.
The law applies the duty in stages: if a voyage is made in separate stages, such as with bunkering stops, the ship must be fit at the start of each stage. Time charters usually replace the strict duty with an express obligation to exercise due diligence to make the ship fit, together with clauses on the ship's condition and the right of the charterer to treat time as lost, as explained under Off Hire. Standard forms such as those listed in Charterparty Standard Forms set out the terms, and the owner is often protected by exceptions listed in Liability and Exception Clauses in Shipping Contracts.
Effect on insurance and claims
In marine insurance under English law, a voyage policy contains an implied warranty that the ship is seaworthy at the start of the voyage, under section 39 of the Marine Insurance Act 1906. In a time policy there is no implied warranty, but the insurer is not liable for a loss attributable to unseaworthiness if the assured knew of it. An unseaworthy ship can therefore put hull cover at risk, and the underwriters may refuse a claim, as discussed in Marine Insurance Losses.
Unseaworthiness also affects cargo claims, the right to claim in general average and the liability cover given by a P&I club. A cargo owner who shows that damage came from an unseaworthy ship may recover from the carrier, and the carrier's right to rely on the exceptions in the rules is lost where it did not exercise due diligence. Evidence of the ship's condition, such as survey reports and certificates, is therefore important in any later dispute.
External links
Ref 1060000356