What is Off Hire?
Definition: A clause in a time charter that stops the charterer paying hire for time when the ship cannot do the work required of it.
Off hire is a provision of a time charter under which the charterer's duty to pay hire is suspended for the time the vessel is not available to perform the service required, for reasons that fall within the clause. A time charter is a contract for the use of the ship for a period, and hire is paid at a daily or monthly rate for the vessel's availability, not for the work done. The off-hire clause marks the point where that availability is lacking.
The clause sits in the standard forms, such as the New York Produce Exchange (NYPE) form and the Baltime form published by BIMCO, and it is among the most litigated terms in ship chartering. It allocates risk: events inside the owner's sphere, such as machinery failure, cost the owner the hire, whereas events caused by the charterer's orders or cargo remain at the charterer's cost.
How the clause works
The NYPE 1946 form provides that, in the event of loss of time from deficiency of men or stores, fire, breakdown or damage to hull, machinery or equipment, grounding, detention by average accidents to the ship or cargo, drydocking for examination or painting the bottom, or any other cause preventing the full working of the vessel, the payment of hire ceases for the time thereby lost. Other forms use similar lists, and the closing general words are read in light of the specific events before them.
Two styles of wording exist. A period off-hire clause suspends hire for the whole period during which the vessel is unavailable. A net loss clause deducts only the time actually lost to the charterer, measured against the position the vessel would have reached without the event, so a ship that breaks down and makes up the time by increased speed may lose nothing. The wording and the facts decide which applies. Under English law the charterer relying on the clause generally has to show that the event falls within its words.
Typical off-hire events
- Breakdown or damage. Failure of the main engine, a generator or cargo gear that prevents the ship from working fully.
- Deficiency of crew or stores. Too few crew, or missing fuel and supplies that are the owner's responsibility.
- Drydocking and surveys. Time for planned inspections and repairs needed for class and statutory certificates, which are usually off hire.
- Detention. Arrest or detention of the ship by authorities for reasons connected with the owner or the vessel, such as a defect found at a port inspection.
- Deviation. Time lost when the ship diverts for the owner's purposes or to land a sick crew member.
Failures of seaworthiness may also lead to off hire, and may in addition amount to a breach of the charter. Delays caused by the charterer, such as cargo problems or waiting for orders, are not off hire.
Deductions from hire
Hire is paid in advance, so the charterer normally deducts the off-hire amount from the next instalment, or the owner credits it. The deduction is the daily rate for the time lost: at a hire of USD 18,000 per day, a breakdown of 36 hours costs 36 ÷ 24 × 18,000 = USD 27,000. The charterer may also deduct the value of bunkers used during the off-hire period, as the fuel is for the owner's account then, and other costs it incurred because of the stoppage. Details are set out in Time Charter Hire and Commissions, together with the rules at delivery and redelivery.
Charterers must keep a record of the time, because the vessel's logs and the voyage records are evidence of when the event started and ended. Owners often protect their income with loss-of-hire insurance bought on the marine insurance market, with a deductible period, while P&I clubs do not cover the loss.
Owner and charterer positions, and disputes
Owners argue that the vessel was still fully available, that the event was not covered by the list, or that the delay was caused by the charterer's orders. Charterers answer that the full working of the ship was prevented and that the cause was within the owner's sphere. Disputes often arise over unusual events, over partial loss of capacity, such as one crane out of four, and over whether the ship was efficient to proceed with the voyage.
Excessive or wrongful deductions can lead the owner to claim non-payment of hire, and a right to withdraw the vessel in the form's withdrawal clause may follow, which is the topic of Charterparty Enforcement and Protection Clauses. Most disputes go to arbitration, often in London under the rules of the London Maritime Arbitrators Association. The cost of off hire is part of the owner's daily outlay, which links it to Ship Operating Costs and Earnings.
Ref 1060000352