What is a safe port and safe berth?
Definition: A safe port or safe berth is a place that a chartered ship can reach, use and leave without danger that good navigation and seamanship cannot avoid. The charterer usually warrants this when nominating it.
A safe port and safe berth warranty is a promise by a charterer, under a Voyage Charter or time charter, to nominate for the ship only ports and berths that are safe for it. The ship is the one under the charter, with its draught and size, not a ship in general. Charters word the promise in different ways, such as an obligation to trade only between safe ports, or to name a port where the ship can lie always safely afloat. Under English law, where the clause is unqualified, the warranty is treated as a promise about the physical and political safety of the place.
The warranty matters because the owner has no say in the choice of port once the charter is signed, while the charterer chooses where the ship goes. It therefore places the risk of the port with the party who selects it. It is distinct from the owner's duty of Seaworthiness, and from rules that decide when a ship is ready to load, which are covered in Notice of Readiness (NOR). Berth wording in voyage charters is dealt with in Berth Conditions in Voyage Charters.
The legal test
The classic statement is in The Eastern City, decided by the English Court of Appeal in 1958. A port is not safe unless, in the relevant period of time, the particular ship can reach it, use it and return from it without, in the absence of some abnormal occurrence, being exposed to danger that cannot be avoided by good navigation and seamanship. Both the ship and the time matter. A port may be safe for a small ship but not for a large one, or safe in summer but not in winter.
In The Evia (No 2), the House of Lords treated the obligation as one about prospective safety at the time of nomination: the charterer must nominate a port that the ship can reach and leave safely, judged on what could be expected at the time. If a port later becomes unsafe through a new event, the charterer is generally not in breach, but must give fresh orders. The UK Supreme Court considered the abnormal occurrence qualification again in The Ocean Victory in 2017.
Physical and political safety
Safety has several aspects. Physical hazards include shallow water, silting, rocks, tidal range, swell and surge in a berth, poor holding ground in an anchorage and unsuitable fenders or mooring arrangements. Political and legal hazards include war, blockade, risk of seizure or detention, piracy, and sanctions that make it unlawful to call at a place. A port can be unsafe because it is closed by a Maritime Chokepoint, or because insurers will quote war risk cover only on special terms, as described in Marine Insurance Limits and War Risk Terms.
Temporary events are a common source of dispute. A short-lived storm or an unexpected, one-off event is typically an abnormal occurrence and does not make the port unsafe, whereas a recurring hazard such as a seasonal swell is a characteristic of the place and may make it unsafe. Some forms soften the warranty into a duty on the charterer to use due diligence to select safe ports, which shifts the risk back toward the owner.
Remedies and risk allocation
If a charterer nominates a port that is unsafe, the owner may refuse to go there and ask for another nomination. If the owner is wrong and the port is in fact safe, refusing may breach the charter. An owner who goes to the port and suffers damage can claim damages for breach of the warranty, covering repair costs, loss of time and consequential loss, subject to any defence that the master's own failure to use good navigation caused the loss. Under a time charter the owner may also have an indemnity claim for the consequences of obeying the charterer's orders, and whether time lost is off-hire is a separate question under the charter; see Off Hire.
Insurance sits behind the claim. Damage to the ship is a loss covered by hull insurance, and the insurer may then pursue the charterer by subrogation. Liabilities to third parties, such as wreck removal, fall to the owner's P&I cover. Demurrage and waiting time at an unsafe place depend on the charter terms in Demurrage and on how the Charterparty allocates delay.
Ref 1060000355