Marine insurance losses are the categories that marine insurance law uses to describe what has happened to an insured ship, cargo or freight and how much the insurer must pay. In English law the classification is set out in the Marine Insurance Act 1906, which many common-law countries copied and which still underpins most international marine insurance written in London. A loss is either total or partial, a total loss is either actual or constructive, and a partial loss of an insured interest is a particular average loss unless it is a general average loss shared by all parties to the voyage.
The labels matter because they decide whether the full sum insured is payable, whether the insured must give notice of abandonment, and whether policy limits such as franchises and deductibles apply. Shipowners, cargo traders, banks that lend against cargo or ships, brokers and adjusters all use them. The rules sit alongside the duty to prevent loss, the sue and labour duty, whose costs the insurer pays in addition to the claim.
Total Loss
A total loss is the loss of the whole of the subject matter insured, as opposed to a partial loss, which is any loss that is not total. The Marine Insurance Act 1906 divides total losses into two kinds: actual total loss, where the property is gone in fact, and constructive total loss, where it still exists but is treated as lost for practical reasons. Unless the policy says otherwise, insurance against total loss covers both kinds, and where the insured claims for a total loss but the evidence shows only a partial loss, a partial loss can still be recovered if the policy covers it.
A total loss normally entitles the insured to the full sum insured under a valued policy, or the insurable value under an unvalued one, with nothing deducted for wear and tear. Outside shipping the term is used loosely for any insured item that is destroyed or uneconomic to repair, such as a car declared a write-off after an accident. Some covers are written on a total loss only basis.
Actual Total Loss
Under the Marine Insurance Act 1906, an actual total loss occurs in three situations: the subject matter is destroyed, it is so damaged that it ceases to be a thing of the kind insured, or the insured is irretrievably deprived of it. A ship that sinks in deep water and cannot be raised is destroyed; a cargo of cement that sets solid after seawater floods the hold has ceased to be the thing insured even though material remains; a cargo seized and never returned may leave the owner irretrievably deprived.
The Act also treats a ship as an actual total loss when it is missing and no news has been received after a reasonable time. No notice of abandonment is needed for an actual total loss, because there is nothing to offer the insurer. Once the insurer pays, it may take over whatever remains of the property, such as wreck or salvage proceeds, and the insured's rights against third parties through subrogation.
Constructive Total Loss
A constructive total loss arises where the property has not been wholly destroyed but is reasonably abandoned because its actual total loss appears unavoidable, or because it could not be saved without spending more than it would be worth afterwards. Under the Marine Insurance Act 1906, a damaged ship is a constructive total loss when the cost of repairs would exceed its repaired value, and goods are a constructive total loss when the cost of repairing them and sending them on would exceed their value on arrival.
The insured then has a choice. It may treat the loss as partial and claim the cost of damage, or treat it as total and abandon the property to the insurer by giving a notice of abandonment promptly after receiving reliable information of the loss. If the insurer accepts the abandonment, it becomes entitled to whatever remains of the property. In practice hull policies often fix an agreed value for testing a constructive total loss, and insurers often decline the notice while agreeing to treat proceedings as begun, preserving the insured's position.
Particular Average
A particular average loss is a partial loss of the subject matter insured, caused by an insured peril, that is not a general average loss. The word "average" here means a partial loss; "particular" means that it falls on the owner of the damaged interest alone and is not shared by the other parties to the voyage. A cargo of coffee wetted by seawater entering a hold in heavy weather, or a hull dented in a collision, are typical examples.
The amount recoverable depends on the subject matter. For goods it is usually calculated by comparing their gross sound and damaged values at destination and applying that percentage of depreciation to the insured value. For a ship it is the reasonable cost of repairs, subject to policy terms. Older cargo policies were often written "free of particular average" (FPA), paying for partial losses only after named casualties, and some used a franchise, a minimum loss percentage below which nothing is paid. Modern covers use the Institute Cargo Clauses and a deductible instead.
Sue and Labour Clause
The sue and labour clause is the provision in a marine policy under which the insured, its employees and agents must take reasonable steps to avert or minimise a loss covered by the policy, and the insurer pays the reasonable costs of doing so. The Marine Insurance Act 1906 treats the clause as a supplementary contract, so sue and labour charges are recoverable in addition to a total loss payment, even where the claim already uses up the sum insured. The Act also imposes the duty to act reasonably whether or not the policy contains the clause.
Examples include moving cargo out of a flooded warehouse, hiring tugs to keep a disabled ship off rocks, or reconditioning wet goods to reduce their loss in value. Costs that belong in general average or salvage are excluded and recovered under those headings. Modern English forms, including the cargo clauses, express the same idea as a "duty of assured" clause, and the insurer's claim handling usually begins by checking whether it was met.
How the loss categories compare
| Category | What has happened | Notice of abandonment | Typical recovery |
|---|---|---|---|
| Actual total loss | Property destroyed, transformed or irretrievably lost | Not needed | Full insured value |
| Constructive total loss | Property survives but is uneconomic to save or repair | Needed to claim as total | Full insured value, or partial loss if not abandoned |
| Particular average | Partial loss falling on one interest | Not applicable | Repair cost or depreciation, less any deductible |
| Sue and labour | Costs spent to prevent or reduce a covered loss | Not applicable | Reasonable costs, on top of the claim |
The way a policy is written affects each category. The choice between a valued and an unvalued policy, and between voyage and time cover, is set out in Marine Insurance Policy Types. All marine claims also depend on the insurable interest of the claimant and on disclosure made under the principle of utmost good faith, which the Insurance Act 2015 reshaped as a duty of fair presentation for business insurance in the UK.
External links
Ref 1170000323