Liability and exception clauses in shipping contracts are provisions in bills of lading and charterparties that allocate loss between the carrier, the owners of cargo and, in collision cases, the other ship. They decide who bears the cost when cargo is lost or damaged, when a ship is at fault in navigation, when a fire breaks out, or when a general average sacrifice has to be shared. The clauses are found in the printed text of a Bill of Lading and of standard charter forms, and they work alongside the international carriage regimes: the Hague Rules, the Hague-Visby Rules and the Hamburg Rules.
The members of the family relate to one another in layers. The paramount clause brings a carriage regime into the contract. The exceptions and negligence clauses then define what the carrier is excused from, within the limits the regime allows. The both to blame and New Jason clauses deal with the knock-on consequences of collision and general average, topics covered more broadly in General Average and Voyage Risk Clauses. The scheme of the Carriage of Goods by Sea is the background to all of them.
Paramount Clause
A paramount clause is a clause in a bill of lading or charter party that applies the Hague Rules, the Hague-Visby Rules or another set of carriage rules to the contract. It is called paramount because the rules it adopts prevail over any inconsistent term. It is used where the rules would not otherwise apply by force of law, for example because the voyage falls outside the scope of a convention, or where the parties wish to apply the rules before loading and after discharge.
The effect on the carrier is to impose the minimum duties and the liability limits of the chosen regime. Under the Hague-Visby Rules the limit is 666.67 special drawing rights per package or unit, or 2 special drawing rights per kilogram of gross weight, whichever is higher. The original Hague Rules fixed a limit of 100 pounds sterling per package. A clause that tries to cut liability below the regime is generally void. Disputes over which regime a clause incorporates often turn on the wording of the incorporation.
Clause Paramount
Clause Paramount is the same clause as the Paramount Clause, the phrase being the form most used in older documents and in United States practice. It makes the Hague, the Hague-Visby or the United States Carriage of Goods by Sea Act (COGSA) apply to a bill of lading or charterparty regardless of the law that otherwise governs the contract. The words are often headed in the bill of lading, so that any dispute begins with the regime stated there.
COGSA of 1936 applies by statute to shipments to and from United States ports in foreign trade, and a clause paramount extends its terms by contract to other periods, such as the time before loading and after discharge. Under COGSA the limit is 500 US dollars per package or per customary freight unit, unless a higher value is declared. The clause therefore decides which limit applies, how long the carrier's responsibility lasts and which defences are open.
Exceptions Clause
An exceptions clause frees the carrier from liability for loss or damage arising from listed causes. The traditional causes include Perils of the Sea, fire, acts of God, war and the acts of public enemies, restraint of princes, strikes, saving or attempting to save life at sea, inherent vice of the goods, insufficient packing and latent defects in the ship that could not be found by due diligence. A general catch-all for any other cause not due to the actual fault of the carrier is also usual.
The Hague and Hague-Visby Rules contain their own list of exceptions, which bind the carrier and limit what a clause can add. A carrier who relies on an exception generally has to show that the cause falls within it, and the cargo owner can answer by showing that the ship was unseaworthy and that the carrier had not used due diligence to make it seaworthy; see Seaworthiness. The Hamburg Rules replaced the list with a general presumption of fault for loss while in the carrier's charge.
Negligence Clause
A negligence clause relieves the shipowner of liability for faults of the master and crew in the navigation or management of the ship. It reflects the old rule that carriers were excused for errors in sailing the ship, and it appears in United States law in the Harter Act of 1893. A clause of this kind in a contract of carriage that falls under the Hague or Hague-Visby Rules is overridden to the extent that it relieves the carrier from liability for negligence in the care of cargo, because the rules make such clauses void.
What remains is narrow. The Hague and Hague-Visby Rules themselves keep two exceptions, for neglect or default of the master or crew in the navigation or management of the ship, and for fire not caused by the carrier's actual fault or privity. A negligence clause therefore has most effect in contracts where no mandatory regime applies, and in periods outside the rules. The Hamburg and Rotterdam regimes do not keep the navigational fault defence. Liability for cargo is also affected by Marine Insurance and by the carrier's P&I cover.
Both to Blame Collision Clause
The both to blame collision clause, found in bills of lading and charterparties, requires cargo owners to indemnify the carrier if cargo claims arise from a collision caused by the fault of both ships. It originates in United States law. Under the rule of divided damages, where both ships are at fault each bears half of the total loss, and the cargo owner can recover its loss in full from the non-carrying ship. That ship can then claim from the carrying ship a share of what it paid, even though the carrying ship is excused from cargo claims by the navigational fault exception.
The clause is meant to close that circuit. It makes the cargo owner repay the carrying ship the amount that the carrying ship has had to pay to the other ship for the cargo loss, so that the carrier is not left with liability that the exception was supposed to remove. In practice the cargo owner's cargo insurers usually meet the claim. The effect of the clause depends on the governing law, and its enforceability has been questioned in some jurisdictions.
New Jason Clause
The New Jason clause makes cargo owners contribute to general average even when the loss resulted from negligence of the carrier's servants, as long as the carrier is not responsible for that negligence by statute, contract or otherwise. It developed from the Jason clause of the early twentieth century, which followed the United States Supreme Court decision in The Jason, where the carrier's right to claim a general average contribution was tested when the cause of loss was a fault in navigation.
The clause provides that, in any accident, danger, damage or disaster resulting from any cause whatsoever, whether due to negligence or not, for which the carrier is not responsible, goods and cargo owners shall contribute with the carrier in General Average and pay salvage and special charges. If a salvage ship belongs to the carrier, salvage is paid as if the ship were owned by strangers. Cargo owners often insure the risk, and the cargo insurer provides a guarantee to release the cargo.
Ref 1060000348