Public debt and fiscal balance measures are the indicators that government finance statistics (GFS) use to describe how much a government owes, what it owns and how sound its budget is. The definitions here follow the IMF's Government Finance Statistics Manual 2014 (GFSM 2014), which is harmonised with the System of National Accounts, together with the related OECD and European usage.
The members form a ladder. Gross debt counts debt liabilities; net debt subtracts matching financial assets; net financial worth compares all financial assets and liabilities. The structural balance corrects the budget for the economic cycle. Contingent assets, debt assumption and defeasance concern items that may or may not appear on the balance sheet, and quasi-fiscal operations are policy actions that move fiscal costs outside the budget altogether. Ministries of finance, debt offices, rating agencies and international bodies use these measures to judge fiscal risk and debt sustainability.
Gross Debt
Gross debt, in GFSM 2014, consists of all liabilities that are debt instruments, meaning those that require payments of interest or principal in the future. The instruments are special drawing rights, currency and deposits, debt securities, loans, insurance, pension and standardised guarantee schemes, and other accounts payable. Equity, investment fund shares and financial derivatives are not debt.
Debt can be valued in several ways. Nominal value is the amount owed at a point in time, including accrued interest. Face value is the undiscounted amount to be repaid at maturity. Market value uses current prices and so falls when interest rates rise, which can make a government's market-value debt look smaller in a period of rising rates. The European Union's Maastricht measure, used in the convergence criteria, is narrower: consolidated general government debt in currency and deposits, debt securities and loans only, valued at face value. Broader concepts are discussed under national debt.
Net Debt
Net debt is gross debt minus the financial assets that correspond to debt instruments, such as deposits held, loans made and debt securities owned. In government finance:
A government with gross debt of 900 billion that holds 150 billion in bank deposits and 100 billion in loans and bonds has net debt of 650 billion. The measure gives a fuller picture where governments hold large liquid assets, as in countries with big cash reserves or social security funds. Its weakness is that the definition of which assets count varies between countries and publications, so figures are not always comparable. In company finance, net debt usually means total borrowings minus cash and cash equivalents.
Net Financial Worth
Net financial worth is a unit's total financial assets minus its total liabilities. Unlike net debt, it counts all financial assets and liabilities, including equity holdings in companies, shares in investment funds and financial derivatives. For a government, it shows whether its financial claims cover its obligations, but it ignores non-financial assets such as roads, buildings and land.
Adding those non-financial assets gives net worth, the broadest balance-sheet measure in GFSM 2014. A government with financial assets of 400, liabilities of 1,000 and non-financial assets of 800 has net financial worth of minus 600 and net worth of plus 200. Net financial worth is often preferred over net worth for comparisons because non-financial assets are hard to value. Both are built from the government balance sheet, and changes between balance sheets reflect transactions as well as revaluations and other changes in volume.
Structural Budget Balance
The structural budget balance is the general government budget balance with the effects of the economic cycle and one-off measures removed. It estimates what the balance would be if output were at potential output. A common method is:
Here is the actual balance as a share of GDP, is the output gap in per cent, and is the budget's sensitivity to the cycle. With a deficit of 4 per cent of GDP, an output gap of minus 2 per cent, a sensitivity of 0.5 and one-off costs of 0.5 per cent, the cyclical part is minus 1 and the structural balance is minus 4 plus 1 plus 0.5, or minus 2.5 per cent. The measure was central to the medium-term objectives of the EU Stability and Growth Pact. Its weakness is that potential output cannot be observed, so estimates are often revised substantially.
Contingent Asset
A contingent asset is a possible asset whose existence depends on uncertain future events outside the holder's control. Examples include an undrawn line of credit or a guarantee that a government has received, a pending legal claim against another party, or a right to receive money if a condition is met. In financial accounting and in government statistics, contingent assets are not recognised on the balance sheet, because no asset yet exists; accounting standards allow them to be disclosed in notes when an inflow is probable.
They are the mirror image of a contingent liability, which is a possible obligation, such as a loan guarantee given. Government statistics pay much more attention to contingent liabilities because they can suddenly add to debt, but recording contingent assets helps show the full picture, for example where a government expects to recover money from a failed bank's estate after a rescue.
Debt Assumption
Debt assumption is a transaction in which one unit takes over responsibility for another unit's outstanding debt to a creditor. Governments often assume the debts of public corporations, local governments or failed banks, or take on a guaranteed loan when the original borrower defaults. The original debtor's liability is extinguished and a new one arises for the government.
GFSM 2014 records the assumption according to whether the government gains a real claim in return. If it expects nothing back, the assumption is recorded as a capital transfer to the original debtor, raising the deficit by the amount of debt taken over. If it obtains a genuine claim on the original debtor, it records the acquisition of a financial asset instead. For example, if a government assumes 100 million of loans owed by a loss-making railway company and receives nothing in return, its deficit and debt both rise by 100 million. Assumptions are one way in which contingent liabilities become actual debt.
Defeasance (Debt)
Defeasance is a technique for removing a debt from a borrower's balance sheet by setting aside financial assets, usually high-quality bonds, whose cash flows are enough to pay the debt's interest and principal. The assets are typically placed in a trust or with a separate entity that services the debt. Legal defeasance releases the borrower from the obligation; in-substance defeasance leaves the legal obligation in place but treats it as settled in practice. A similar idea is used in property lending, as described in defeasance in commercial mortgages.
Governments and companies have used defeasance to clean up their balance sheets or to move debt to a dedicated vehicle. Statistical manuals are cautious: unless the debt and assets have really been transferred to a separate institutional unit, both stay on the original debtor's balance sheet. This prevents a government from appearing to reduce its gross debt simply by ring-fencing some assets against it.
Quasi-Fiscal Operations
Quasi-fiscal operations are policy actions with fiscal effects that are carried out by a central bank or public corporation rather than through the government budget. Examples include lending at below-market interest rates to favoured sectors, selling electricity or fuel below cost, running dual or multiple exchange rates that subsidise some importers, and central bank bailouts of banks or state-owned enterprises.
These operations act like taxes or subsidies but do not appear as government spending or revenue, so the budget understates the true size of the public sector and its deficit. Their cost eventually shows up as losses at the central bank or public company, which may later need to be covered by the government. The IMF encourages countries to measure quasi-fiscal activities and report them alongside the budget, as part of its standards for fiscal transparency.
External links
Ref 1100001829