Defeasance of a commercial mortgage is a process in which a borrower releases its property from the lien of a fixed-rate loan by substituting a portfolio of government securities whose payments match the loan's remaining scheduled payments. The loan itself is not repaid. It stays outstanding, now secured by bonds instead of real estate, and continues to pay interest and principal on its original timetable until maturity.
The technique is closely associated with commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS), where loans usually cannot simply be prepaid. It is one of the main forms of commercial mortgage prepayment protection, alongside lockout periods and yield maintenance. The word comes from older legal usage meaning to render a claim void. In corporate bond markets it has related but distinct meanings, described below.
Why CMBS loans use defeasance
A CMBS trust issues bonds with a defined cash flow profile and is normally structured as a Real Estate Mortgage Investment Conduit (REMIC) for US tax purposes. An early payoff of a fixed-rate loan would hand the trust cash it could only reinvest at current rates and would disturb the payments promised to bondholders, a form of prepayment risk. Defeasance avoids that problem. The trust keeps receiving exactly the payments it expected, but from a highly rated government portfolio rather than from rents, so the credit quality of the collateral usually improves.
REMIC rules restrict when collateral can be substituted, and CMBS loan documents generally prohibit defeasance for an initial period after the securitisation closes. Loan agreements specify which securities are eligible, typically US Treasury obligations and sometimes certain agency securities.
How a defeasance works
A defeasance is a short, document-heavy transaction coordinated by a specialist consultant, the borrower's counsel and the loan servicer. The usual sequence is:
- The borrower gives notice to the servicer within the window set by the loan documents and appoints a defeasance consultant.
- A portfolio of Treasury securities is designed so that its coupons and maturities cover every remaining payment, including the balloon at maturity or the open prepayment date.
- An independent accountant verifies that the portfolio's cash flows are sufficient, and rating agencies may be asked to confirm that the substitution will not affect the bond ratings.
- A newly formed special purpose entity, the successor borrower, assumes the loan and pledges the securities, which are held by a securities intermediary.
- The mortgage on the property is released, and the original borrower can sell or refinance free of the loan.
Any surplus from the securities after the last loan payment usually belongs to the successor borrower, and it can be a source of value to the party that owns that entity.
Cost of defeasance
The main cost is the price of the securities portfolio, which equals the present value of the remaining loan payments discounted at government bond yields:
- is the scheduled loan payment in period , including the final balloon.
- is the government yield for that maturity.
- is the number of remaining periods.
Take a $10 million balance at a 5% annual coupon with three annual payments left: $500,000, $500,000 and $10.5 million. If Treasury yields are 4% across the curve, the portfolio costs about 480,769 + 462,278 + 9,334,462 = $10.28 million, roughly $278,000 more than the outstanding balance. If government yields were above the loan coupon, the portfolio would cost less than the balance. On top of the securities come fees for the consultant, servicer, accountant, legal counsel and the successor borrower.
Defeasance versus yield maintenance
Yield maintenance is the other common protection. The borrower actually repays the loan and pays a prepayment premium designed to compensate the lender for lost interest, usually calculated by discounting the excess of the loan rate over a Treasury yield. The two approaches tend to cost a similar amount in economic terms, but differ in practice:
- Loan status. Under yield maintenance the loan ends; under defeasance it survives with a new obligor and new collateral.
- Process. Yield maintenance is a cash payment and payoff; defeasance requires a securities purchase, verification and a successor entity.
- Lender outcome. A CMBS trust receives cash under yield maintenance but keeps a fully matched payment stream under defeasance.
Bond defeasance and other meanings
In corporate and municipal debt, defeasance refers to setting aside cash or government securities in a trust to meet a bond issue's payments. Legal defeasance, where the indenture allows it, discharges the issuer from the debt, while covenant defeasance releases the issuer only from most covenants. In public finance, an advance refunding often defeases old bonds by placing proceeds in an escrow. In-substance defeasance, an accounting practice of placing assets in an irrevocable trust without a legal release, no longer allows a company to remove the debt from its balance sheet under US accounting standards.
Ref 1180001855