A public corporation is a corporation that is controlled by government but operates as a market producer, selling most of its goods or services at prices that cover a substantial part of its costs. National railways, postal companies, state-owned banks, electricity and water utilities, and national airlines are typical examples. In everyday language such bodies are often called state-owned enterprises (SOEs), although statisticians use the narrower term with precise rules.
The term matters most in national accounts and government finance statistics (GFS). Under the System of National Accounts (SNA) and the IMF's GFSM 2014, public corporations belong to the corporations sectors, not to the general government sector. Together with general government they make up the public sector. Where a body is placed affects how big government spending, deficits and debt appear.
What makes a corporation public
A corporation is public when a government unit, another public corporation or a group of them controls it. Control means the ability to decide the corporation's general policy, not just to own shares. SNA 2008 and GFSM 2014 list indicators that statisticians weigh together:
- Ownership of the majority of the voting interest, the most common and usually decisive test.
- Control of the board or other governing body, including the right to appoint or remove a majority of directors.
- Control of the appointment and removal of key personnel, or of key committees.
- Golden shares and options that give government special powers, such as a veto over strategic decisions.
- Regulation and control so tight that government in effect dictates general policy, beyond ordinary regulation of an industry.
- Control by a dominant public sector customer, or control attached to government borrowing or guarantees.
One indicator may be enough, but often several are considered together. A corporation in which government holds a minority stake, without any of these powers, is a private corporation even if the stake is large. A government that takes a majority stake in a failing bank, as several did during the 2008 crisis, turns it into a public corporation for statistical purposes, which links the term to nationalization.
The market producer test
Control alone does not make a body a public corporation. It must also be a market producer, which means it sells most of its output at economically significant prices: prices that have a real effect on how much producers supply and buyers purchase. A state railway that charges commercial fares and covers most of its costs from ticket revenue passes; a government agency that provides free services funded by taxes does not, and is classified inside general government. The distinction is explained further under market and non-market production.
The European System of Accounts adds a quantitative guide, often called the 50% rule: a unit is treated as a market producer if its sales cover at least half of its production costs over a sustained multi-year period. Statisticians also look at whether the unit competes with private firms and whether most of its sales go to government. Bodies that fail the test are reclassified. A well-known case is Network Rail in the United Kingdom, which the Office for National Statistics moved into central government in 2014 after deciding it was controlled by government and largely funded by it.
Financial and nonfinancial public corporations
Public corporations are split between the non-financial corporations sector and the financial corporations sector, depending on what they do. Nonfinancial public corporations include utilities, transport operators, energy companies and state trading firms. Public financial corporations include state-owned commercial banks, development banks, postal savings banks, public insurers and, in most countries, the central bank itself, which SNA treats as a public financial corporation rather than part of government. The full set of sectors is described under institutional sectors and units.
Why the classification matters
Placing a body inside or outside general government changes headline fiscal figures. The debt and deficits of public corporations do not appear in general government debt, so governments sometimes have an incentive to move activities into corporations to keep them off the books. Statistical offices guard against this by applying the control and market tests strictly and by publishing data for the wider public sector. GFSM 2014 encourages countries to compile accounts for public corporations and to show the public sector balance sheet as a whole, which gives a fuller picture of fiscal risk.
Flows between government and its corporations also need careful recording. Payments by government to cover a corporation's operating losses are subsidies or capital transfers rather than investment, while profits paid to government are dividends, discussed under state-owned enterprise dividend. Unusually large payments out of reserves are treated as withdrawals of equity rather than income, which stops governments from boosting revenue by draining their corporations. When a public corporation is sold, the process is privatization, and the proceeds are a financial transaction that does not reduce the deficit.
External links
Ref 1100001828