A state-owned enterprise (SOE) is a business that is owned or controlled by government and that sells goods or services to the public at market prices. Such businesses are also called public enterprises, government enterprises or, in statistical manuals, public corporations. Familiar examples include national railways, postal services, electricity and water utilities, oil companies, airlines and state banks.
SOEs sit between the private sector and government itself. They operate like companies, with their own accounts, managers and often outside creditors, but their owner is the state, which may expect them to pursue policy goals as well as profit. Their weight varies widely: in some economies they dominate energy, finance and transport, while in others they have been largely sold off. How they are defined, recorded and governed affects public debt figures, competition in markets and the quality of public services.
Ownership and control tests
A firm does not need to be wholly owned by government to be an SOE. The national accounts and government finance statistics (GFS) manuals use control, defined as the ability to determine the firm's general corporate policy. Indicators include:
- Ownership of a majority of the voting shares, directly or through other public bodies.
- The right to appoint or remove a majority of the board or key managers.
- Special rights, such as a golden share that can block takeovers or major decisions.
- Control through regulation, contracts or heavy dependence on government as the main customer or lender.
A minority stake alone usually does not make a firm public, but a combination of indicators can. The same tests apply to firms owned by regional and local governments, and to subsidiaries of other SOEs.
Treatment in the national accounts
The key statistical question is whether an SOE is a market producer, selling at economically significant prices, or a non-market producer. The test is explained under market and non-market production (national accounts). Market SOEs are classified in the non-financial or financial corporations sectors, outside the general government (sector). Their debt is therefore excluded from general government debt, though it is included in wider measures of the public sector.
This boundary can be contentious. A loss-making enterprise that relies on regular subsidies may fail the market test and be reclassified into government, which raises the reported deficit and debt. Statisticians in many countries have reclassified bodies such as railway operators and development agencies for this reason. Dividends paid by SOEs to their owner appear as government property income, as discussed under state-owned enterprise dividend, and transfers to cover losses appear as subsidies or capital injections. Assets and liabilities of SOEs feature in the full public sector balance sheet.
Purposes and governance
Governments create or keep SOEs for several reasons. Some industries are natural monopolies, where a single network is cheapest, and public ownership is one alternative to private ownership with regulation, as covered under natural monopoly and its regulation. Others are judged strategic, such as defense, energy or national airlines. SOEs may be used to provide universal service in remote areas, to support development, or to direct credit, as with a state bank. Some states hold commercial stakes through investment vehicles, which may overlap with a sovereign wealth fund (SWF).
Governance is the central challenge. Mixed objectives make performance hard to judge, political influence can affect appointments and pricing, and implicit state backing can let SOEs borrow cheaply, which may distort competition with private firms. The OECD Guidelines on Corporate Governance of State-Owned Enterprises, first issued in 2005 and revised since, recommend separating the state's ownership role from its regulatory role, setting clear objectives, appointing professional boards and disclosing results to the same standard as listed companies. These principles adapt general corporate governance practice to public owners.
Privatization and nationalization
The balance between public and private ownership has shifted over time. Many countries expanded state ownership in the mid-twentieth century through nationalization of industries such as coal, steel, rail and banking. From the 1980s, a wave of privatization in the United Kingdom and later in Europe, Latin America, the former communist economies and elsewhere sold many SOEs to private investors, often through share offerings.
Supporters of privatization argue that private owners face stronger incentives to cut costs and invest, and that sales raise revenue and reduce political interference. Critics point to cases where privatized monopolies raised prices or underinvested, and to the loss of public control over essential services. Governments have also taken firms back into public ownership, for example banks during the 2007 to 2009 financial crisis and some railway franchises. Research suggests that the effects depend heavily on competition and regulation in the market, not only on who owns the firm. Related hybrids include the government-sponsored enterprise (GSE) in the United States, which is privately owned but publicly chartered.
External links
Ref 1100001840