Long-term credit rating grades are the letter categories that credit rating agencies assign to issuers and to debt with an original maturity of more than about a year, to show their opinion of the relative likelihood of default and, in some cases, of expected recovery. The scales used by S&P Global Ratings and Fitch Ratings run from AAA, covered under AAA credit rating, through AA, A, BBB, BB, B, CCC, CC and C, to D for default. Moody's uses a parallel scale from Aaa to C.
From AA to CCC, S&P and Fitch add a plus or minus to show relative standing within a category, and Moody's adds the numbers 1, 2 and 3, so that A+ corresponds to A1 and A- to A3. Each step is called a notch. Grades of BBB- or Baa3 and above are investment grade; grades below are speculative grade. Each agency publishes its own definitions, which differ in wording, so the descriptions below are general. Ratings on short-term debt use a separate scale, described under short-term credit rating grades.
AA
AA is the second-highest long-term grade on the S&P and Fitch scales, equivalent to Aa1, Aa2 and Aa3 at Moody's. It signals very strong capacity to meet financial commitments, differing from AAA only to a small degree. The grade is divided into AA+, AA and AA-.
Issuers in this band typically include financially strong sovereigns, supranational institutions, some large regional governments, a small number of highly capitalised companies and many covered bonds and senior securitisation tranches. Because so few corporations hold AAA, AA is often the top of the realistic range for private-sector borrowers. Debt in this band trades at narrow credit spreads over government bonds, and investors treat it as close to risk-free for most purposes, though defaults from this level, while rare, are not impossible over long horizons.
A
A is the third long-term grade, divided into A+, A and A- at S&P and Fitch and corresponding to A1, A2 and A3 at Moody's. It signals strong capacity to meet financial commitments, but somewhat more susceptibility to adverse changes in economic conditions and circumstances than the two higher categories. Moody's describes the equivalent band as upper-medium grade.
Many large banks, utilities, insurers and established industrial companies are rated in the A band, as are a number of sovereigns. For corporate issuers it represents a comfortable investment-grade position, with access to bond and commercial paper markets in most conditions. A sustained weakening, for example after a debt-funded acquisition, typically leads to a downgrade of one or more notches into the BBB band rather than a sudden fall.
BBB
BBB is the lowest investment-grade category, equivalent to Baa1, Baa2 and Baa3 at Moody's. S&P describes it as adequate capacity to meet financial commitments, with adverse economic conditions or changing circumstances more likely to weaken that capacity. Moody's calls the Baa band medium grade, with some speculative characteristics.
BBB- is the cliff edge of the rating scale. Many investment mandates, insurance and pension rules and bond indices are limited to investment-grade bonds, so an issuer cut from BBB- to BB+ can face forced selling and a jump in borrowing costs. Such issuers are called fallen angels. The BBB band has grown to make up a large share of the investment-grade corporate bond market, which concerns some observers because a broad wave of downgrades would push large volumes of debt across the line at once.
BB
BB is the highest speculative-grade category, equivalent to Ba1, Ba2 and Ba3 at Moody's. S&P describes BB obligations as less vulnerable to non-payment in the near term than lower speculative grades, but facing major ongoing uncertainties or exposure to adverse business, financial or economic conditions that could leave the issuer unable to pay. Moody's calls the Ba band speculative and subject to substantial credit risk.
BB+ is the crossover point, one notch below investment grade. Issuers there, sometimes called crossover credits, may be rising stars heading upward or fallen angels heading down, and their bonds attract both investment-grade and high-yield buyers. Debt rated BB and below is classed as non-investment-grade, or high-yield or junk, which restricts which investors can hold it and raises its cost.
B
B is the middle speculative-grade category, used by S&P and Fitch with plus and minus modifiers and equivalent to B1, B2 and B3 at Moody's. S&P describes a B obligation as more vulnerable to non-payment than BB, although the issuer currently has the capacity to meet its commitments; adverse conditions are likely to impair that capacity. Moody's describes the band as speculative and subject to high credit risk.
The B band is the core of the leveraged loan and high-yield bond markets: many companies owned by private equity after a leveraged buyout are rated B or B-. Historical default rates rise sharply as ratings fall through the speculative grades, and the B category has seen markedly higher default rates than BB over economic cycles, especially in recessions. Small changes in earnings can move a B-rated issuer to CCC.
CCC
CCC is the category for obligations currently vulnerable to non-payment, where repayment depends on favourable business, financial and economic conditions. It corresponds broadly to Caa1, Caa2 and Caa3 at Moody's and is divided into CCC+, CCC and CCC- at S&P and Fitch. Moody's describes Caa as of poor standing and subject to very high credit risk.
Issuers in this band often have unsustainable capital structures, weak liquidity or imminent maturities, and their bonds and loans tend to trade at deep discounts as distressed debt pursued by distressed investors. In collateralised loan obligations, the share of assets rated CCC+ or below is capped, often at around 7.5 per cent; assets above the cap are carried at market value in the overcollateralisation tests, so a wave of downgrades to CCC can divert cash away from junior noteholders.
CC
CC is the grade for obligations that are highly vulnerable to non-payment. S&P uses it when a default has not yet occurred but is expected to be a virtual certainty, whatever the expected timing. Fitch describes CC as very high levels of credit risk where default of some kind appears probable. Moody's nearest equivalent is Ca, which it describes as highly speculative and likely in, or very near, default, with some prospect of recovery.
The grade sits between CCC, where repayment is still possible in favourable conditions, and C, where default is imminent or a restructuring is under way. Issuers rated CC are often negotiating with creditors or have announced plans that are likely to amount to a default. Expected recoveries are generally low, particularly for unsecured creditors, and agencies do not usually apply plus or minus modifiers at this level.
C
C is the lowest grade before default at S&P and Fitch and the lowest grade of all at Moody's. Its use differs by agency. S&P assigns C to obligations that are currently highly vulnerable to non-payment and are expected to have lower relative seniority or lower ultimate recovery than higher-rated obligations, for example when a distressed exchange offer has been announced but not completed. Fitch uses C when a default or default-like process has begun, such as a standstill or bankruptcy filing, while the issuer is still paying.
At Moody's, which has no D grade, C is the lowest rating and is typically applied to debt that is in default, with little prospect for recovery of principal or interest. This difference means that a Moody's C does not translate one-for-one to C at the other agencies, and analysts compare agency definitions before treating the grades as equivalent.
D
D is the grade S&P and Fitch use when an issuer or obligation has defaulted. Under S&P's definitions, D applies when a payment is not made on its due date and is not cured within any applicable grace period, on the filing of a bankruptcy petition or similar action where payments are jeopardised, and on completion of a distressed exchange. Fitch uses D for an issuer that has entered bankruptcy, administration, liquidation or another formal winding-up procedure, or has otherwise ceased business.
The rating describes a fact rather than a forecast, so it does not show how much creditors will recover; agencies publish separate recovery ratings for that purpose, as discussed under specialised credit rating scales. Fitch once used DDD, DD and D to signal different recovery prospects within default, a system since retired. After emerging from a debt restructuring or bankruptcy, an issuer receives a new rating reflecting its new capital structure.
Selective Default (SD)
Selective default (SD) is the rating S&P assigns to an issuer that has defaulted on a specific obligation or class of obligations, often through a distressed exchange, but continues to pay its other debt on time. The defaulted issue itself is rated D, while the issuer carries SD. Fitch uses the comparable restricted default (RD) grade.
The distinction matters because an issuer in selective default is not in general default and may be paying most of its creditors. SD is common in sovereign debt restructurings, where a government exchanges some bonds for new ones with lower value but keeps servicing others, and in corporate liability management exercises that impose losses on one group of creditors. Once the exchange is complete, the agency usually re-rates the issuer, often back into the CCC or B categories, based on its new debt profile and the sovereign credit rating or corporate outlook.
Equivalents across the agencies
| S&P and Fitch | Moody's | Band |
|---|---|---|
| AA+, AA, AA- | Aa1, Aa2, Aa3 | Investment grade |
| A+, A, A- | A1, A2, A3 | Investment grade |
| BBB+, BBB, BBB- | Baa1, Baa2, Baa3 | Investment grade |
| BB+, BB, BB- | Ba1, Ba2, Ba3 | Speculative grade |
| B+, B, B- | B1, B2, B3 | Speculative grade |
| CCC+, CCC, CCC- | Caa1, Caa2, Caa3 | Speculative grade |
| CC | Ca | Speculative grade |
| C | C | Speculative grade |
| SD or RD, D | No separate grade | Default |
Ref 1180001862