A make-whole redemption is an early repayment of a bond at a price designed to compensate holders for the interest they lose when the bond is retired before maturity. The redemption price is the greater of the bond's principal amount and the present value of its remaining scheduled payments, discounted at the yield on a comparable government bond plus a fixed spread set in the bond documents. Accrued interest is paid on top.
The provision appears in most investment-grade corporate bonds in the United States and is common in Europe and other markets. It gives the issuer the flexibility to retire debt at any time, for example to complete an acquisition, a refinancing or a sale of the business, while making the option expensive enough that it is rarely used simply to profit from lower rates. It differs from the fixed call schedule of a traditional callable bond, where the bond call price steps down over time and the issuer gains when rates fall.
How the price is calculated
The make-whole amount is:
- is the principal (face) amount being redeemed.
- is each remaining coupon payment, excluding interest already accrued at the redemption date.
- is the number of remaining payment periods to maturity, or to a par call date where one exists.
- is the yield on the reference government security with a similar remaining maturity, per period.
- is the make-whole spread fixed in the indenture, per period.
Take a bond with a face amount of 1,000, an annual coupon of 6 per cent and exactly three years to maturity. The reference Treasury yield is 3 per cent and the make-whole spread is 50 basis points, so the discount rate is 3.5 per cent:
Because 1,070.04 is greater than 1,000, the issuer pays 1,070.04 per bond plus accrued interest. If the reference yield had risen to 6 per cent, the discounted value would fall below par and the issuer would pay 1,000. Real indentures usually discount semi-annually using the payment dates of the bond and specify exactly how the reference yield is fixed, often a few business days before redemption.
Why the spread matters
The spread is the key negotiated term. A spread close to the issuer's credit spread at issue roughly compensates holders for the market value of their bonds. A small spread, such as 15 to 50 basis points over Treasuries for investment-grade issuers, sets a high redemption price because the cash flows are discounted at nearly a risk-free rate, well below the yield the bonds would trade at. That is why make-whole calls usually cost the issuer more than buying the bonds in the market, and why they are used mainly when an issuer must remove the bonds and their covenants entirely.
The present value approach also explains the protection for investors: when government yields fall, the make-whole price rises, so the issuer cannot capture the benefit of lower rates at holders' expense.
Make-whole calls in different bond markets
In investment-grade bonds the make-whole call is usually available for most of the bond's life and is followed by a par call, often one to six months before maturity, at which point the bond can be repaid at face value. In high-yield bonds the structure is different: a non-call period, during which redemption is only possible at a make-whole price, is followed by a schedule of fixed call prices that start at a premium and step down to par. Make-whole provisions in high-yield bonds tend to use a discount rate of the Treasury yield plus about 50 basis points and measure payments to the first call date and price.
The redemption price affects analytics such as yield to call and yield to worst less than a fixed call does, because a make-whole call is rarely economic for the issuer. Bonds with only a make-whole call are therefore often priced much like a non-callable bond.
Disputes and legal issues
Make-whole amounts have been contested in insolvency. When a borrower files for bankruptcy, the question arises whether acceleration of the debt triggers the make-whole and whether the claim should be allowed or treated as unmatured interest. US courts have reached different results depending on the drafting of the indenture, which led investors to seek clauses stating that the premium is payable on acceleration. Disputes also arise over how the reference yield is chosen, the treatment of a par call date and whether a redemption notice can be conditional on a financing.
The make-whole is one of several ways bonds can be retired before maturity, alongside a sinking fund, a tender offer or a change of control put exercised by holders. Each has different economics, and an issuer planning an early bond redemption compares their cost.