A credit rating agency (CRA) is a company that assesses the ability and willingness of a borrower to repay its debts on time and publishes its opinion as a credit rating. Ratings cover corporations, banks, insurers, governments and municipalities, and individual debt instruments such as bonds, commercial paper and structured finance securities. Investors use ratings to compare credit risk quickly, and issuers use them to reach a wider market at lower cost.
The market is dominated by three firms: Standard & Poor's (S&P), Moody's and Fitch Ratings, which together issue the large majority of ratings worldwide. Smaller and regional agencies operate in many countries. Agencies that rate securities sold to investors are regulated, in the United States by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and in the European Union by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA).
History
Credit reporting began in the nineteenth century with mercantile agencies that assessed the standing of traders, and with publishers of data on US railroad securities. John Moody published letter ratings for railroad bonds in 1909, and the forerunners of S&P and Fitch followed within a few years. Ratings gained official importance in the 1930s, when US bank regulators began to restrict banks' holdings of bonds below a certain grade. In 1975 the SEC created the designation "nationally recognized statistical rating organization" (NRSRO) to identify agencies whose ratings could be used in its net capital rules for broker-dealers, and the label spread into many other regulations.
Rating scales
Each agency uses its own letter scale, but they are broadly comparable. S&P and Fitch run from AAA, the highest quality, through AA, A, BBB, BB, B and CCC down to D for default, with plus and minus modifiers; Moody's uses Aaa, Aa, A, Baa, Ba, B and lower grades, with numerical modifiers 1 to 3. The key dividing line is between investment grade, BBB- (Baa3 at Moody's) and above, and speculative grade below it, often called junk or high-yield. Many investment mandates allow only investment-grade holdings, so a downgrade across that line can force selling and widen the issuer's credit spread.
Agencies distinguish long-term from short-term ratings, issuer ratings from ratings of particular debt issues, and local-currency from foreign-currency ratings for governments. They also publish outlooks and watch placements that signal the likely direction of a rating. A rating is an opinion of relative default risk, not a recommendation to buy or sell and not a guarantee.
The business model and conflicts of interest
Until the 1970s agencies earned most of their income from selling publications to investors. The major firms then shifted to an issuer-pays model, in which the borrower pays for its own rating. This model is cheaper for investors and gives agencies access to non-public information, but it creates a conflict of interest: an agency may be tempted to give favourable ratings to win or keep business, and issuers can "shop" among agencies for the best result. Some smaller agencies use a subscriber-pays model instead.
Criticism and the 2008 crisis
The agencies came under heavy criticism in the 2008 financial crisis. They had given top ratings to large volumes of residential mortgage-backed securities and collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) that later suffered mass downgrades and heavy losses. Investigations pointed to flawed models, reliance on historical data from a period of rising house prices and the pressures of the issuer-pays model. Earlier failures to warn of the collapses of Enron and other companies, and the timing of downgrades during the euro area sovereign debt crisis, added to concerns that ratings lag rather than lead markets and can amplify stress through "cliff effects".
Regulation
In the United States, the Credit Rating Agency Reform Act of 2006 set up a formal SEC registration regime for NRSROs, and the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 created an SEC Office of Credit Ratings, required more disclosure and asked federal agencies to remove references to credit ratings from their rules where possible. In the European Union, the CRA Regulation adopted in 2009 requires agencies to register, and a 2011 amendment gave ESMA direct supervision of them; the United Kingdom kept a similar regime after leaving the EU. Internationally, IOSCO's code of conduct for CRAs sets common standards. Bank capital rules under Basel III still allow external ratings in the standardised approach to credit risk, so ratings continue to influence how much capital banks hold.
External links
Ref 1180001455