Specialised credit rating scales are rating systems that a credit rating agency uses alongside its ordinary long-term and short-term scales to answer narrower questions: how much creditors would recover after a default, how sound the holdings of a bond fund are, how stable a money market fund's share price is, how sensitive a fund is to market movements, or how a borrower ranks within a single country. They help investors, treasurers and regulators who need a measure the main credit rating does not give.
Each agency uses its own symbols, so the same letters may mean different things at different agencies. The examples below follow the scales used by S&P Global Ratings; other agencies have comparable scales with different suffixes and definitions. The ordinary issuer scales are covered in long-term credit rating grades and short-term credit rating grades. On the global scale, ratings of BBB- (Baa3 at Moody's) and above are investment grade.
Recovery Rating
A recovery rating is an assessment of how much of its principal and interest a holder of a debt instrument can expect to recover if the issuer defaults. S&P uses a scale from 1+ to 6, each step tied to a band of expected recovery: 1+ indicates full recovery expected, 1 very high recovery of roughly 90 to 100 percent, and the scale descends through 2, 3, 4 and 5 to 6, which indicates negligible recovery of roughly 0 to 10 percent. Recovery ratings are most used for speculative-grade issuers, where the chance of default is meaningful and recovery is a large part of the investment case. They feed into the rating of each individual debt issue through notching: a secured loan with a strong recovery rating may be rated one or more notches above the issuer's rating, while unsecured or subordinated debt with weak expected recovery is rated below it. Recovery prospects are closely related to loss given default.
Fund Credit Quality Rating
A fund credit quality rating is an opinion on the overall credit quality of the securities held in a fixed income fund, such as a bond fund. S&P's scale uses the ordinary rating letters with an "f" suffix, from AAAf downward, so that a fund rated AAAf holds a portfolio with credit risk consistent with the highest rating category. The rating is based on the credit ratings of the fund's holdings, weighted by size and adjusted for maturity, with attention to counterparty exposure and the manager's credit policies. It does not measure the fund's returns, its share price stability or its sensitivity to interest rates, and it is not a rating of the fund's ability to meet redemptions. It also differs from an issuer rating, which measures the likelihood that a single borrower will pay its own debts. Some funds hold both a credit quality rating and a volatility rating, so that investors see both aspects of risk.
Principal Stability Fund Rating
A principal stability fund rating is an opinion on a fund's ability to maintain the value of its principal and limit exposure to losses, used mainly for money market funds and similar short-term cash funds. S&P's scale uses an "m" suffix, from AAAm, the strongest, down to Dm. A fund rated AAAm is judged to have an extremely strong capacity to maintain principal stability and to limit losses from credit, market and liquidity risks. Agencies look at the credit quality and maturity of holdings, the weighted average maturity, diversification, liquidity and the manager's experience and controls. These ratings matter greatly to corporate treasurers, insurers and other institutional cash investors, many of whose investment policies allow them to use only AAAm-rated or equivalently rated funds. The rating does not guarantee that the fund will never lose value, and it is not a recommendation to buy or redeem shares.
Fund Volatility Rating
A fund volatility rating is an opinion on how sensitive a bond fund's returns and net asset value are to changing market conditions, such as movements in interest rates, credit spreads and liquidity. S&P's scale runs from S1, the lowest sensitivity, to S6, the highest, with intermediate grades between them. A fund with a short duration, high credit quality and little leverage would fall near the top of the scale, while a fund holding long-dated, lower-rated or less liquid bonds, or using derivatives to increase exposure, would fall lower. The rating is forward-looking and based on the fund's investment guidelines and portfolio as well as its past performance. It is distinct from a fund credit quality rating: a fund can hold only top-rated government bonds and still be volatile if their maturities are long, because their prices respond strongly to interest rate risk.
National Scale Credit Rating
A national scale credit rating ranks the creditworthiness of issuers and debt only against others in the same country, rather than on the global scale used for international comparison. It is useful in markets where most borrowers would cluster in a few speculative-grade categories on the global scale, often because the sovereign rating caps them, so the global scale gives little way to distinguish stronger from weaker local credits. S&P marks national scale ratings with a country prefix, such as "il" for Israel or "tw" for Taiwan, followed by the rating letters, so that ilA is a rating of A relative to other Israeli issuers. Other agencies use suffixes or prefixes of their own. The best local credits, often the government itself, sit at the top of the national scale. National scale ratings cannot be compared with global-scale ratings, or between countries, because each scale is relative to its own market.
How the scales compare
| Scale | Example symbols | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
| Recovery rating | 1+ to 6 | Expected recovery after default |
| Fund credit quality rating | AAAf and lower | Credit quality of a fund's holdings |
| Principal stability fund rating | AAAm to Dm | Ability to keep principal stable |
| Fund volatility rating | S1 to S6 | Sensitivity of returns to market changes |
| National scale rating | ilA, twAA | Credit standing within one country |
Ref 1180001870