Exclusionary conduct in competition law is behaviour by a firm with substantial market power that weakens competition by excluding rivals, or by stopping new ones from entering, rather than by winning customers with lower prices or better products. It is the main concern of the rules on single-firm conduct: monopolization under section 2 of the US Sherman Act, and abuse of a dominant position under Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union and similar national laws.
The family of terms starts with the idea of a dominant firm, because the rules apply only to firms with that kind of power. Abuse of dominance and monopolization are the legal offences. Refusal to deal, limit pricing, non-price predation, fighting brands, tied selling and loss-leader selling are forms the conduct can take. Excessive pricing is a related abuse that exploits customers directly. The hard task for enforcers such as the European Commission, the Federal Trade Commission and the Department of Justice is telling exclusion apart from tough but legitimate competition, and US and EU tests often differ.
Dominant Firm
A dominant firm is one whose market position lets it act to a large extent independently of competitors, customers and consumers. In practice this usually means a large and lasting market share, well ahead of the next rivals, protected by barriers to entry. Economists describe a dominant-firm price leadership model in which one large firm sets the price and a fringe of small rivals takes it as given.
In law, dominance is a threshold rather than an offence. Being dominant is not unlawful, but it brings a special responsibility not to distort competition. In EU practice a share above 50 per cent can create a presumption of dominance, while a share below about 40 per cent makes dominance unlikely, although market definition, entry conditions and buyer power all count. A firm that is the only supplier is a monopoly; dominance can also exist in an oligopoly where one firm is far larger than the others.
Abuse of Dominant Position
Abuse of a dominant position is conduct by a dominant firm that harms competition or consumers. Article 102 TFEU lists examples: imposing unfair prices or trading conditions, limiting production or technical development, applying dissimilar conditions to equivalent transactions, and making contracts conditional on unrelated obligations. Abuses are commonly grouped as exclusionary, such as predatory pricing, exclusive dealing, loyalty rebates, refusal to supply and tying, or exploitative, such as excessive prices.
The European Commission and national authorities can impose fines of up to 10 per cent of a company's worldwide annual turnover and order the conduct to stop. In the United Kingdom the equivalent prohibition is enforced by the Competition and Markets Authority. EU law is generally seen as more willing than US law to intervene against dominant firms, and it reaches exploitative conduct that US antitrust leaves alone.
Monopolization
Monopolization is the US offence under section 2 of the Sherman Act of 1890. Courts require two elements: possession of monopoly power in a relevant market, and the wilful acquisition or maintenance of that power through exclusionary conduct, as distinguished from growth or development as a consequence of a superior product, business acumen or historic accident. Attempted monopolization, where a firm has a dangerous probability of gaining monopoly power, is also prohibited.
The US approach focuses on the process, not the outcome. Holding a monopoly, and charging the high prices that come with it, is not itself unlawful; the Supreme Court has described the chance to charge monopoly prices as part of what attracts business acumen. What is unlawful is conduct with no business justification other than excluding rivals. Section 2 cases can be brought by the Department of Justice, by the FTC under its own statute, and by private plaintiffs, who can recover triple damages.
Refusal to Deal
A refusal to deal, or refusal to supply, occurs when a firm declines to sell to a customer, or to give a rival access to an input, a network or intellectual property. In general firms are free to choose their trading partners, so a refusal is unlawful only in limited circumstances.
The essential facilities idea holds that a dominant firm controlling something rivals cannot duplicate, such as a port, a pipeline or a payment network, may have to grant access on reasonable terms. US courts have become sceptical of the doctrine and treat most refusals as lawful, especially where no previous dealing existed. EU law sets a high but real bar: the input must be indispensable, the refusal must be likely to eliminate competition in a downstream market and it must lack objective justification. Some sectors, such as telecommunications and payment systems, have specific access rules that go further than general competition law.
Limit Pricing
Limit pricing is a strategy in which an established firm sets its price below the level that would maximise its short-run profit, so that entry looks unprofitable to potential rivals. The price is chosen to sit just below the point at which an entrant, with its own costs and smaller scale, could cover its costs.
The strategy works only under certain conditions: the incumbent must have a cost or scale advantage, and the low price must say something credible about the profits an entrant could expect after entry. Game theory shows that if the incumbent would simply accommodate an entrant, a low price before entry is an empty threat. Limit pricing differs from predatory pricing, which cuts price to drive out a rival already in the market, often below cost. Because limit pricing keeps prices low for customers, competition authorities rarely treat it as unlawful on its own.
Non-Price Predation
Non-price predation covers exclusionary tactics that do not depend on low prices. A common theme is raising rivals' costs: making it more expensive for competitors to reach customers or obtain inputs, rather than becoming more efficient. Examples include exclusive contracts that lock up distributors or suppliers, misuse of regulatory or standard-setting processes, misleading statements to authorities, product design changes made only to break compatibility, and sham litigation brought to burden a rival rather than to win.
Authorities assess such conduct by asking whether it makes economic sense apart from its tendency to harm competitors, and whether it is likely to foreclose a significant part of the market. The analysis is case by case, since many of the same practices, such as exclusive deals or litigation, are normally legitimate. Patent and regulatory abuses have been prominent in pharmaceuticals, where delaying generic entry can be very valuable to an incumbent.
Fighting Brand
A fighting brand is a low-priced product launched by an established firm to compete with a cheaper rival, without cutting the price of its main brand. The firm protects the margin on its flagship product while denying the challenger customers at the low end of the market. Examples are common in consumer goods, airlines and telecoms, where a budget line or sub-brand targets price-sensitive buyers.
Most fighting brands are lawful competition and benefit consumers with lower prices. Concern arises when a dominant firm prices the fighting brand below cost, or aims it narrowly at a specific entrant with the aim of driving it out and then withdrawing it. In such cases the conduct is analysed as selective predatory pricing. A known EU example involved shipping lines that operated "fighting ships" timed to undercut an independent competitor.
Tied Selling
Tied selling, or tying, means selling one product, the tying product, only on condition that the buyer also takes a second, the tied product. Bundling, a close relative, offers products together as a package, sometimes alongside separate sale at higher prices; see product bundling.
Tying can be efficient, for instance when products work better together or are cheaper to supply jointly. It becomes an antitrust concern when a firm with power over the tying product uses it to foreclose competition in the tied market. Competition authorities typically look for distinct products, coercion, market power in the tying product and likely harm to competition. Banking has its own rules: in the United States, the anti-tying rules for banks generally stop them from making credit conditional on the customer buying other products, outside traditional banking services.
Loss Leader
A loss leader is a product sold below cost, or at very low margin, to attract customers who then buy other, more profitable items. Supermarkets often price staples such as milk, bread or bananas this way, and electronics retailers sometimes sell consoles cheaply to drive sales of games and accessories.
Loss leading is usually lawful and is a normal part of retail pricing strategy. It can raise competition concerns when used by a dominant retailer to squeeze smaller competitors that cannot cross-subsidise, at which point it may be assessed as predatory pricing. Some countries go further: France, for example, has long prohibited resale at a loss, and other jurisdictions restrict below-cost selling of particular goods such as groceries or alcohol. Supporters say such bans protect small shops; critics say they keep prices high.
Excessive Pricing
Excessive pricing is charging prices well above the competitive level, exploiting customers directly rather than excluding rivals. It is an abuse under Article 102, which prohibits "unfair" prices. The leading EU test asks whether the price is excessive compared with the costs of supply and, if so, whether it is unfair in itself or compared with competing products.
Excessive pricing cases are rare and hard to prove, because there is no clear benchmark for a fair price and intervention can deter investment. Authorities have pursued them mainly where entry is blocked, for example in some off-patent pharmaceuticals, collecting societies and essential services. In the United States, charging high prices alone does not breach the Sherman Act, so the issue is left to sector regulators. Price controls on a natural monopoly address the same problem by regulation instead.
US and EU approaches compared
| Issue | United States (Sherman Act section 2) | European Union (Article 102 TFEU) |
|---|---|---|
| Threshold | Monopoly power, usually a very high share | Dominance, which can arise at lower shares |
| Refusal to deal | Rarely unlawful | Unlawful in exceptional circumstances |
| Excessive prices | Not an antitrust offence | Can be an abuse |
| Main remedies | Injunctions, private treble damages | Fines up to 10 per cent of turnover, orders |
External links
Ref 1210000691