Government price controls are legal limits on what can be charged for goods, services or labour. They come in two forms: a ceiling sets a maximum price, and a floor sets a minimum price. Governments use them to protect buyers from high prices, as with rent control or caps on fuel and food, or to protect sellers, as with a minimum wage or farm price supports. Interest rate caps such as usury laws are a financial example.
The family of terms below describes how controls work and what follows from them. A control only changes outcomes when it binds, that is when it holds the price away from the equilibrium price set by supply and demand. A binding ceiling creates a shortage and leads to rationing by other means; a binding floor creates a surplus. Both usually cause a deadweight loss, as covered under shortages, surpluses and market disequilibrium.
Price Control
A price control is any government rule that fixes a price, or a limit on it, instead of letting the market set it. Controls may apply to a single product, such as bread, electricity or medicines, or to a whole economy during an emergency. In the United States, the Office of Price Administration controlled many prices during the Second World War, and on 15 August 1971 President Richard Nixon announced a 90-day freeze on wages and prices as part of a package to fight inflation. Later phases of that programme ran into 1974.
Economists generally find that broad controls can suppress measured inflation for a time but do not remove its causes, and that they distort production, investment and quality. Narrow controls remain common, often where a seller has market power, such as regulated utility tariffs or caps on certain card fees. Where controls are set close to market prices, their effect may be small.
Price Ceiling
A price ceiling is a legal maximum price. It is binding when set below the equilibrium price; a ceiling above equilibrium has no effect, because the market price is already lower. At a binding ceiling, buyers want to purchase more than sellers are willing to supply, so a shortage appears. On a supply and demand diagram, the ceiling is a horizontal line below the point where the curves cross, and the shortage is the horizontal distance between the demand and supply curves at that price.
Since price can no longer ration the good, other mechanisms take over. Queues form, sellers favour regular customers, quality falls as sellers cut costs, and black markets develop in which the good is resold above the ceiling. Fuel price caps have produced queues at filling stations, and caps on interest rates, such as an interest rate ceiling, can lead lenders to refuse riskier borrowers rather than lend at the capped rate.
Price Floor
A price floor is a legal minimum price. It is binding when set above the equilibrium price; a floor below equilibrium has no effect. At a binding floor, sellers want to supply more than buyers want to purchase, so a surplus appears. On a diagram, the floor is a horizontal line above the crossing point, and the surplus is the gap between the supply and demand curves at that price.
The best-known example is a minimum wage, a floor on the price of labour; if it is set well above the market wage, the surplus shows up as fewer jobs than people seeking them, although the size of any job loss is debated. Agricultural price supports are another example: when governments guarantee farmers a minimum price for an agricultural commodity, they often have to buy and store the surplus or pay farmers to produce less. Floors transfer income to sellers who still find buyers while leaving some trades unmade.
Rent Control
Rent control is a legal limit on the rent landlords can charge for housing. A rent ceiling caps the rent itself; other schemes cap how much rent can rise each year. Economists often distinguish first-generation controls, which freeze rents in money terms, as many cities did during wartime, from second-generation controls, which allow increases linked to inflation or costs and may exempt new buildings or reset rents between tenants.
The standard analysis treats a binding rent ceiling as a price ceiling in the housing market. In the short run the supply of housing is fixed, so tenants in controlled homes gain at landlords' expense. Over time, landlords may spend less on upkeep, convert units to other uses or build fewer new rental homes, and tenants may stay in homes that no longer suit them to keep a low rent. Supporters argue that controls give security to existing tenants and slow displacement in fast-rising markets.
Rationing
Rationing is the allocation of scarce goods by means other than price. When a price ceiling or a sudden shortage stops price from balancing supply and demand, something else must decide who gets what. Common methods include queues, in which buyers pay with their time; coupons or ration books that entitle each person to a fixed amount; quotas for firms; and lotteries, a form of lottery allocation.
Wartime rationing is the classic case. The United Kingdom rationed food, clothing and fuel during and after the Second World War, and food rationing did not end fully until 1954. Rationing can share a scarce good more equally than an unrestricted price would, but it brings administrative costs and invites resale, forgery and favouritism. Economists also note that markets ration by price all the time; the question is which method of allocation a society prefers when goods are scarce.
How the controls compare
| Measure | Set relative to equilibrium | Main result when binding |
|---|---|---|
| Price ceiling | Below | Shortage, queues, black markets |
| Price floor | Above | Surplus, unsold output or unemployment |
| Rent control | Below (a ceiling on rents) | Fewer rental homes over time, low mobility |
| Rationing | Used with a ceiling or a shortage | Non-price allocation by coupon, queue or lottery |
Ref 1100001680