An exempt offering is an offer and sale of securities that is not registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission because it qualifies for an exemption from the registration requirement of the Securities Act of 1933. That Act requires every offer or sale of a security in the United States to be registered unless an exemption applies. Registration involves filing a detailed disclosure document and a prospectus, a process that is costly and slow.
Exemptions exist where Congress and the regulator have judged that full registration is unnecessary or disproportionate, typically because the amount raised is small, the buyers are able to look after themselves, or the offering is confined to one state or takes place abroad. Exempt offerings raise more capital each year in the United States than registered public offerings do. They are the normal way in which startups, private companies and investment funds obtain money.
Offerings and securities
The law distinguishes between two kinds of exemption. A transaction exemption, the subject of this entry, covers a particular sale. The securities sold remain unregistered, and a later resale needs its own exemption. An exempt security, by contrast, is exempt because of what it is or who issued it, as with government bonds, and can be sold repeatedly without registration.
In either case only registration is excused. The anti-fraud provisions of the securities laws apply in full, so an issuer that makes false or misleading statements in an exempt offering is liable to investors and to the regulator.
Main exemptions
The principal routes are these:
- Private offerings. The Act exempts transactions by an issuer not involving any public offering. This is the legal basis of the private placement.
- Regulation D. This set of rules provides safe harbors for private and small offerings. Rule 506(b) allows an unlimited amount to be raised from accredited investors and a small number of other sophisticated buyers, without public advertising. Rule 506(c) allows advertising, provided every buyer is accredited and the issuer takes reasonable steps to verify it. Rule 504 covers small offerings up to a fixed amount in a year.
- Regulation A. A lighter form of public offering, in two tiers with different ceilings, which requires an offering document reviewed by the regulator but not full registration.
- Regulation Crowdfunding. Small amounts may be raised from the general public through a registered online intermediary, the regulated form of equity crowdfunding.
- Intrastate offerings. Sales confined to residents of the state in which the issuer does business.
- Offshore offerings. Regulation S covers sales made outside the United States.
- Resales to institutions. Rule 144A permits resales of unregistered securities to large institutional buyers, the mechanism behind much of the corporate bond market.
The money limits under these rules are set by the regulator and revised from time to time. As amended with effect from 2021, the ceilings were $10 million a year under Rule 504, $75 million under the upper tier of Regulation A and $5 million under Regulation Crowdfunding.
Conditions that commonly apply
Each exemption has its own conditions, and an issuer must satisfy all of them to rely on it. The most common concern who may buy. Many exemptions turn on whether purchasers are an accredited investor, a category defined by income, net worth, professional qualification or institutional status. The theory is that such buyers can obtain information and bear losses without the protection of registration.
Other conditions limit how the offering is made. Some exemptions forbid general solicitation, meaning public advertising. Issuers relying on Regulation D must file a short notice, Form D, after the first sale. Offerings to buyers who are not accredited usually carry disclosure requirements. So-called bad actor rules bar issuers whose principals have relevant convictions or regulatory orders from using the main exemptions.
Securities bought in most exempt offerings are restricted. The buyer cannot freely sell them on the secondary market and must hold them for a minimum period or find another exemption, which is why private company shares are illiquid.
State law
Each state has its own securities statute, known collectively as blue sky laws, with separate registration requirements. Federal law overrides state registration for offerings under Rule 506 and certain other exemptions, leaving states able to require a notice filing and a fee and to pursue fraud. For other exemptions, an issuer must comply with the law of each state in which it sells.
Use and criticism
Exempt offerings fund the early life of most companies. Money from an angel investor, venture capital rounds, private equity funds and hedge funds is raised almost entirely under Regulation D. The growth of these markets has allowed companies to stay private far longer than in the past, postponing or avoiding an initial public offering.
That shift is the source of the main criticisms. Private markets disclose much less than public ones, so prices are harder to verify and fraud harder to detect. The wealth tests for accredited investors are a rough proxy for sophistication, and because the thresholds were long left unadjusted for inflation, the number of households that qualify has grown greatly. Ordinary investors, meanwhile, are largely shut out of the stage at which fast-growing companies gain most of their value. Proposals to widen or narrow access recur regularly, and the rules are amended often.