Barriers to entry are the costs, rules and other obstacles that make it difficult for a new firm to enter a market and compete with the businesses already in it. Where barriers are high, established firms can charge more or earn higher profits than they could if rivals were free to come in. Where barriers are low, any unusual profit attracts newcomers until it is competed away.
The concept is central to the study of market structure. It explains why some industries are served by a single firm or a few, as in a monopoly or an oligopoly, while others approach perfect competition. It is used by competition authorities reviewing mergers, by business strategists assessing an industry and by investors judging whether a company's profits are likely to last.
Definitions
Economists have not agreed on a single definition. Joe Bain, who introduced the term in the 1950s, defined a barrier as anything that lets established firms keep prices above the competitive level without attracting entry. George Stigler proposed a narrower test: a barrier is a cost that an entrant must bear but that incumbents did not have to bear. On Stigler's view, large scale alone is not a barrier if the incumbent once had to build it too. Competition authorities mostly take a practical approach, asking whether entry would be timely, likely and sufficient to restrain prices.
Structural barriers
- Scale. Where unit costs fall with volume, an entrant must come in large or accept a cost disadvantage. This is the effect of economies of scale.
- Capital needs. Industries that require heavy spending before any revenue is earned are open only to those who can raise the funds and bear the risk.
- Network effects. When a service is worth more the more people use it, a network effect favors the largest provider. Payment card networks and trading venues are examples.
- Switching costs. Customers who face expense or inconvenience in changing supplier are hard to win.
- Control of inputs and know-how. Ownership of scarce resources, distribution channels, data or experience can give incumbents lower costs that an entrant cannot match.
A cost that cannot be recovered on leaving the market, a sunk cost, is the most deterrent kind, since it turns entry into an irreversible bet. The theory of contestable markets holds that where entry and exit are free of sunk costs, even a single supplier must price competitively.
Legal and regulatory barriers
Governments create barriers deliberately. A patent or other intellectual property right grants temporary exclusivity as a reward for invention. Licensing restricts who may practice a trade or operate in a sector. A tariff or quota shields domestic producers from foreign entrants.
Financial services are among the most heavily protected sectors. A bank needs a bank charter, must meet a minimum capital requirement and must satisfy supervisors of its management and controls before taking a deposit. Payment firms need licenses in each jurisdiction where they operate. These rules exist to protect customers and the stability of the system, but they also raise the cost of entry. Arrangements such as banking-as-a-service, in which a licensed bank lets other companies offer products under its authorization, have lowered the barrier for technology firms.
Strategic barriers
Incumbents can also act to discourage entry. Tactics described in the literature include holding spare capacity as a threat to flood the market, pricing low enough to make entry unprofitable, signing customers or distributors to exclusive long-term contracts, and heavy advertising that raises the spending an entrant needs to be noticed. Some of these practices are lawful competition; others can breach antitrust law when carried out by a dominant firm.
Use in strategy and investing
In Michael Porter's framework for analyzing industries, the threat of new entrants is one of five forces that set the level of profit an industry can sustain. Investors apply the same reasoning to individual companies. A business protected by durable barriers, sometimes described as having an economic moat, can earn returns above its cost of capital for long periods, and analysts look for evidence of this in stable margins and market shares.
Barriers are not permanent. New technology can make an incumbent's assets irrelevant, a process associated with creative destruction, and deregulation can open a protected sector quickly.
Policy debate
High barriers are generally regarded as harmful to consumers, since they weaken the discipline of a competitive market. The difficulty lies in separating barriers that serve a purpose, such as safety rules or rewards for innovation, from those that mainly protect existing firms. Established businesses often support regulation that newcomers find harder to meet, a pattern linked to regulatory capture. Regulators in finance have responded with lighter regimes for small entrants, such as phased authorization and regulatory sandboxes.