Defensive stocks are shares of companies whose sales and profits change little as the economy expands and contracts. The companies sell goods and services that people continue to buy in hard times: food, household products, electricity, water, medicines and basic communications. Because earnings are steady, the shares tend to fall less than the market in a downturn and to rise less in a boom. They are also called non-cyclical stocks.
The category is defined in contrast to the cyclical stock, whose results follow the business cycle closely. It is unrelated to defense stocks, the shares of military contractors, despite the similar name.
Typical defensive sectors
- Consumer staples. Makers and sellers of food, drink, tobacco and household goods, described under consumer staples.
- Utilities. Suppliers of electricity, gas and water, usually with regulated prices and returns.
- Health care. Pharmaceutical companies, medical suppliers and health insurers, whose demand depends on illness and age, not on income.
- Telecommunications. Providers of phone and internet service paid for by monthly subscription.
Classification is by behavior and not by label. A luxury food brand may be cyclical, and a discount retailer may be defensive because shoppers trade down to it in a slump.
Characteristics
The common thread is inelastic demand: the quantity bought barely responds to changes in income or price. This gives stable revenue and cash flow, which in turn supports regular dividends. Defensive shares therefore often offer an above-average dividend yield and modest growth.
In statistical terms these shares have a low beta, the measure of how much a share moves when the market moves. A share with a beta of 0.6 would be expected to fall about percent when the market falls 10 percent, and to gain about 6 percent when it rises 10 percent. Lower volatility and smaller peak-to-trough losses, measured by maximum drawdown, are the main reasons investors hold them.
Role in a portfolio
Investors raise the share of defensive stocks when they expect a recession or a bear market, and reduce it when they expect recovery, since cyclical shares usually lead as growth returns. The shift between the two groups is the basis of sector rotation strategies. Defensive shares are also a core holding for investors who put capital preservation and income ahead of growth, such as retirees.
They are part of the wider group of risk-off assets that attract money when investors turn cautious, though as shares they remain riskier than government bonds or cash.
The low-volatility effect
Standard theory holds that lower risk should bring lower return. Research on many markets has found that, over long periods, low-beta and low-volatility shares have earned returns close to or above those of riskier shares, and clearly better returns per unit of risk. The finding underlies strategies such as betting against beta and funds that select for minimum volatility, which hold many defensive names.
Suggested explanations include limits on borrowing, which lead investors who want high returns to bid up risky shares instead, and a general preference for shares with lottery-like prospects. The effect is not constant, and it weakens when low-volatility shares become popular and expensive.
Risks and limitations
Defensive does not mean safe. The shares still fall in a general market decline, only by less on average. In a strong rising market they tend to lag, so holding them carries a cost in lost gains. Over a full cycle the outcome depends on how much time the market spends rising, which historically has been most of it.
They are sensitive to interest rates. Because investors buy them for steady income, they compete with bonds, and when a bond yield rises their dividends look less attractive and their prices can fall. In 2022, when rates rose quickly, several defensive sectors declined along with the wider market. Utilities also carry heavy debt, which raises their financing costs when rates go up.
Other risks are specific to the industries. Regulators can cut the returns allowed to utilities, governments can press down drug prices, and consumer goods companies can lose share to cheaper store brands when costs rise. Finally, popularity itself is a risk: when many investors seek safety at once, defensive shares can reach a high price-to-earnings ratio, which leaves less protection than their history suggests.