Commercial mortgage prepayment protection is the group of loan terms that either forbid a borrower from repaying a fixed-rate commercial mortgage early or require it to compensate the lender when it does. Lenders and bond investors rely on the expected stream of interest from a loan; if the borrower refinances when rates fall, that income is lost and must be reinvested at lower yields. Protection shifts this prepayment risk back to the borrower.
The tools are usually combined in sequence over the life of a loan. A typical fixed-rate loan in commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) starts with a lock-out period, then allows release only through defeasance or on payment of yield maintenance, and ends with a short open period before maturity. Balance-sheet lenders often use simpler prepayment penalties, such as a fee that steps down each year. The detailed terms sit among the wider commercial mortgage loan provisions.
Lock-Out Period
A lock-out period is the early part of a commercial mortgage term during which the borrower may not prepay at all, whatever it is willing to pay. Any attempt to repay is a breach of the loan agreement rather than an option with a price. Lock-outs give investors certainty over the first years of cash flow, when a loan is most likely to be refinanced if rates move.
In CMBS the lock-out commonly runs for at least the first two years after the securitisation closes. That length is linked to US tax rules for a real estate mortgage investment conduit (REMIC), which in general prevent a loan from being defeased within two years of the REMIC's start-up date without risking the trust's tax status. After the lock-out ends, the loan usually moves into a defeasance or yield maintenance window. This lending sense of "lock-out" is unrelated to the lockout convention used when calculating risk-free reference rates.
Yield Maintenance
Yield maintenance is a prepayment charge designed to make the lender whole for the interest it loses when a loan is repaid early. The charge is the present value of the difference between the loan's interest rate and the yield on a Treasury security of matching remaining term, applied to the outstanding balance for the rest of the term. A simplified form with annual periods is:
Here is the loan coupon, the reinvestment Treasury yield, often an interpolated Treasury yield, the balance and the years remaining. For a $10,000,000 loan at 6 per cent with five years left and a 4 per cent Treasury yield, the yearly shortfall is $200,000, and its present value is about $890,364. Many loans also set a minimum charge, commonly 1 per cent of the balance. The idea mirrors a make-whole redemption on a bond.
Open Prepayment Period
An open prepayment period is a window near the end of a commercial mortgage, commonly the last three to six months before maturity, when the borrower may repay without any penalty, defeasance or yield maintenance. It exists because most commercial mortgages are not fully amortising and end with a large balloon payment that the borrower usually meets by refinancing or selling the property.
Without an open window, a borrower would have to time a refinancing to the exact maturity date or pay a charge for closing a few weeks early. The open period gives time to arrange new finance, and by then the remaining interest at stake is small, so lenders lose little. It also reduces refinance risk at maturity. In a CMBS loan the open period is the last stage of the typical sequence that runs from lock-out, through defeasance or yield maintenance, to open.
Comparing the protections
| Feature | Prepayment allowed | Cost to borrower | Typical position in term |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lock-out period | No | Not available at any price | Start of the loan |
| Yield maintenance | Yes | Present value of lost interest; rises as Treasury yields fall | Middle of the term |
| Defeasance | Collateral released, loan stays outstanding | Cost of a Treasury portfolio replicating payments, plus fees | Middle of the term, alternative to yield maintenance |
| Open period | Yes | None | Final months before maturity |
Ref 1180001853