A defined benefit pension transfer in the United Kingdom is the process by which a member gives up the guaranteed income promised by a defined benefit pension plan, such as a final salary or career average scheme, in exchange for a lump sum that is paid into another arrangement, usually a defined contribution pension. The same rules apply to some other pensions that carry valuable guarantees. Members consider transfers to gain flexibility over how and when they draw money, to pass more on at death, or because of doubts about the sponsoring employer.
Transfers are regulated closely because the guarantees given up are hard to replace. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) requires advisers to start from the assumption that a transfer is unsuitable, and law requires regulated advice for larger transfers. The three terms below cover the value offered, which benefits the rules protect, and the cheaper first stage of advice.
Transfer Value
A transfer value, formally the cash equivalent transfer value (CETV), is the amount a pension scheme offers a member who wants to leave it and move their rights elsewhere. For a defined benefit scheme, it is calculated by the trustees, with actuarial advice, as the present value of the pension the member has built up, using assumptions about investment returns, inflation and life expectancy. Values tend to rise when long-term interest rates fall and fall when rates rise, which is why figures quoted in the late 2010s were often very high.
Once a member receives a guaranteed statement of entitlement, the value is fixed for three months, and the member must normally ask for the transfer within that period. If the value of safeguarded benefits is more than £30,000, the trustees must check that the member has taken appropriate independent advice before paying. A high transfer value does not by itself mean a transfer is in the member's interests, since the replacement fund carries investment and longevity risk that the scheme previously bore.
Safeguarded Pension Benefits
Safeguarded benefits is the legal term for pension rights that include some form of guarantee about the level of income, as opposed to flexible benefits whose value depends only on the size of a pot. The Pension Schemes Act 2015 introduced the term when pension freedoms began. Defined benefit pensions are the main example, but the category also covers defined contribution policies with a guaranteed annuity rate, a guaranteed minimum pension or another promise about the income that will be paid.
Converting or transferring safeguarded benefits worth more than £30,000 into flexible benefits requires the member to obtain advice from an FCA-authorised adviser with the relevant permission, and the scheme must check this has happened. Guarantees such as a guaranteed annuity rate can be worth far more than their headline pot value suggests, particularly when market annuity rates are low, so the rule aims to make sure members understand what they would give up before they move.
Abridged Advice
Abridged advice is a shorter, cheaper first stage of advice on a defined benefit transfer, introduced by the FCA in October 2020 as part of reforms that also banned contingent charging, where the adviser is paid only if the transfer goes ahead. It is designed to filter out clients for whom a transfer is clearly unsuitable without the cost of a full analysis of the scheme and alternatives.
An abridged advice process can reach only two outcomes: a personal recommendation not to transfer, or a statement that it is unclear whether a transfer would be suitable and full advice would be needed. It cannot recommend a transfer. Because abridged advice does not count as the advice required to pass the £30,000 check, a member who wants to proceed must go on to full advice. The reforms followed FCA reviews that found a high proportion of unsuitable transfer advice, including cases involving members of the British Steel Pension Scheme that led to a consumer redress scheme. The wider categories of advice are described under types of financial advice.
Protection when things go wrong
Members who believe they received unsuitable transfer advice can complain to the adviser and then to the Financial Ombudsman Service. If the advice firm has failed, claims may go to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme, subject to its limits. Checking a firm's permissions on the FCA register, described under FCA authorisation, is a basic safeguard, since transfer advice requires a specific permission and a qualified pension transfer specialist.
External links
Ref 1180001826