CMBS servicing roles and agreements are the contracts and parties that manage the mortgage loans held in a commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) trust after the bonds are sold. Because a CMBS trust is a passive legal vehicle, usually structured as a REMIC for US tax purposes, it cannot collect payments, deal with borrowers or foreclose by itself. Those tasks are given to specialist servicers under a pooling and servicing agreement, with a trustee holding the loans for bondholders.
The roles divide by loan performance. A master servicer handles performing loans, often through sub-servicers; when a loan defaults or is about to, a servicing transfer event moves it to the special servicer, which works it out or liquidates it. The controlling party, usually the holder of the most junior bonds, can direct or approve many special servicer decisions. Fees, including the workout fee, are set in the agreement and vary from deal to deal. How the structure itself is put together is covered in CMBS issuance structure.
Pooling and Servicing Agreement (PSA)
The pooling and servicing agreement (PSA) is the main contract of a CMBS trust. It records the transfer of the mortgage loans from the depositor into the trust, appoints the trustee, the certificate administrator, the master servicer and the special servicer, and sets out each party's duties, fees and standard of care. The PSA governs how payments from borrowers are collected and passed to bondholders through the payment waterfall, when servicers must make advances of missed payments, how loans are modified or foreclosed, and how servicers can be replaced. It also sets the rights of the controlling class and, in post-crisis deals, of an operating advisor that reviews special servicer conduct. A similar document is used for residential mortgage-backed securities. Where a large loan is split into notes held by several trusts, a co-lender agreement decides which trust's PSA controls servicing of the whole loan.
Master Servicer
The master servicer is responsible for the routine servicing of performing loans in a CMBS trust. Its tasks include collecting monthly payments, managing tax and insurance escrows and reserve accounts, processing routine borrower requests, gathering property financial statements and producing the monthly reports that investors use. A central duty is advancing: if a borrower misses a payment, the master servicer normally advances the scheduled principal and interest to bondholders, and pays property taxes or insurance to protect the collateral, unless it judges that the advance would not be recoverable from the loan. Its fee is usually a small annual percentage of the outstanding loan balance, paid from interest collections. When a loan suffers a servicing transfer event, the master servicer passes it to the special servicer but often continues to collect payments and make advances on it. Advances and their limits are covered in CMBS advances and appraisal reductions.
Special Servicer
The special servicer takes over loans that have defaulted or are at serious risk of default. Its job is to maximise recovery for the trust as a whole, choosing between options such as a forbearance agreement, a loan modification, a discounted payoff, a note sale, foreclosure or the sale of foreclosed property. It must act under the servicing standard in the PSA, generally that of a prudent lender acting for all bondholders. The special servicer earns three kinds of fee: a special servicing fee, charged as an annual percentage of the balance of each loan it handles; a workout fee on collections from loans it returns to performing status; and a liquidation fee on proceeds from loans it resolves by sale or foreclosure. Because the controlling class can usually replace the special servicer, special servicers are often affiliated with investors that buy the junior bonds, a potential conflict that post-crisis rules on operating advisors aim to manage.
Sub-Servicer
A sub-servicer is a firm hired by the master servicer, and sometimes by the special servicer, to carry out part of its duties on some of the loans. The most common case is a loan originator, such as an insurance company or regional lender, that wants to keep its relationship with the borrower after selling the loan into a securitisation. The sub-servicer then collects payments, handles routine requests and inspects properties, while the master servicer keeps responsibility under the PSA. Sub-servicing agreements usually limit what the sub-servicer may do without approval, such as agreeing to a modification, waiving a default or releasing collateral, and they require it to pass collections to the master servicer promptly. The master servicer remains liable to the trust for the sub-servicer's performance and pays its fee out of the master servicing fee. In some deals a primary servicer plays a similar role for a group of loans.
Servicing Transfer Event
A servicing transfer event is a trigger defined in the PSA that moves a loan from the master servicer to the special servicer. Typical triggers include a payment default lasting a set period, often 60 days; a balloon payment not made at maturity; the borrower's bankruptcy or insolvency; a master servicer's judgment that payment default is imminent or reasonably foreseeable; and a non-monetary default that materially harms the trust's interest. Once transferred, the loan is a specially serviced loan. If the special servicer cures the problem, for example through a modification after which the borrower makes a set number of consecutive monthly payments (commonly three), the loan becomes a corrected loan and returns to the master servicer. The special servicer can then earn a workout fee on it. The share of loans that have suffered a transfer, often called the special servicing rate, is widely watched as a measure of stress in commercial real estate.
Controlling Party
The controlling party in a CMBS deal is the investor, or its representative, entitled to direct or approve key decisions of the special servicer. It is usually the controlling class, the most junior class of bonds outstanding with enough value left, often held by a so-called B-piece buyer that bought the riskiest securities after reviewing every loan. Its rights typically include approving major decisions such as modifications, foreclosures and property sales, and replacing the special servicer without cause. Control is linked to value: if losses or appraisal reductions cut the junior class's notional balance below a stated share of its original balance, control passes to the next senior class, a test sometimes called a control appraisal period. In deals issued after the financial crisis, an operating advisor reviews the special servicer's decisions and can recommend its replacement once the controlling class's interest has fallen away.
Workout Fee
A workout fee is the fee a special servicer earns on collections from a loan that it has restructured and returned to performing status as a corrected loan. It is charged as a percentage of each later payment of principal and interest, and of the final payoff, for as long as the loan stays corrected. The fee rewards the special servicer for a successful loan workout that restores a loan to health instead of selling or foreclosing on it. It differs from the special servicing fee, which is earned on the balance of a loan while it is in special servicing whatever the outcome, and from the liquidation fee, earned on proceeds when the loan is resolved through a sale, a discounted payoff or foreclosure. The exact rates are negotiated deal by deal and set out in the PSA, often with caps or minimums. Because workout and liquidation fees can push special servicers towards different outcomes, investors watch how they are set.
How the roles compare
| Role | Loans handled | Main tasks | Paid by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Master servicer | Performing loans | Collections, reporting, advances | Servicing fee on balance |
| Sub-servicer | Selected loans | Borrower contact, collections | Share of master fee |
| Special servicer | Defaulted or at-risk loans | Workouts, foreclosures, sales | Special servicing, workout and liquidation fees |
| Controlling party | All specially serviced loans | Approvals and servicer replacement | Owns the junior bonds |
Ref 1180001850