What is trade finance fraud?
Definition: Deception aimed at obtaining payment or credit in trade transactions by misrepresenting the goods, the documents, the parties or the collateral behind a financing.
Trade finance fraud is the use of false or manipulated information to obtain payment, credit or collateral value in connection with the sale of goods. It targets the instruments of trade finance, such as documentary credits, documentary collections, invoice financing and loans secured on stock. Victims are banks, commodity traders and finance houses, and sometimes honest buyers and sellers whose names are misused.
The weakness lies in how trade finance works. Banks pay against papers and rarely see the goods, so an attacker who controls the papers can create the appearance of a shipment, a debt or a stock of goods that does not exist, or exists elsewhere. The schemes are closely tied to trade-based money laundering techniques, which also use false invoicing, and to wider bank fraud offences.
Document Forgery
Document forgery in trade finance is the creation or alteration of shipping and commercial papers, such as the bill of lading, the invoice, the certificate of origin and inspection or quality certificates, to obtain payment for a shipment that never happened or that differs from what the papers state. A bill of lading is the key target because it evidences shipment and, in many forms, title to the goods.
Banks look for red flags such as signatures, stamps or fonts that do not match known samples, vessel names and voyage dates that do not match shipping records, quantities that exceed the capacity of the vessel, round-number weights, errors in the shipper's details and documents issued by an unfamiliar inspection company. Checks include confirming the bill of lading with the carrier, verifying a vessel's position and cargo with shipping databases, and contacting the issuer of any certificate directly. The International Chamber of Commerce's International Maritime Bureau tracks documentary and shipping fraud and supports banks in such checks.
Documentary Credit Fraud (Letter of Credit Fraud)
Documentary credit fraud, or letter of credit fraud, is the use of a false documentary credit or of false documents presented under a genuine one to trigger payment. Examples include a fictitious or forged credit sent to a seller to induce shipment, a credit from a bank that does not exist or is unlicensed, a fictitious beneficiary set up to collect, and presentations of forged papers that appear to comply.
The risk arises from the principle in the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600) that banks deal with documents and not with goods, so a compliant-looking set must normally be paid even if the cargo is worthless. Courts in many jurisdictions recognise a fraud exception which can allow a court to block payment where fraud is clear, as in the 1941 New York case of Sztejn and in section 5-109 of the US Uniform Commercial Code, but the standard of proof is high. Banks reduce exposure by authenticating the issuing bank through trusted channels, checking discrepancies carefully, confirming unfamiliar credits and screening parties under their business due diligence procedures.
Invoice Fraud
Invoice fraud in trade finance is the use of fake, inflated or altered invoices to obtain payment or financing. In a financing setting a company may submit invoices for sales that never occurred, or sell the same invoice to several financiers, in order to draw money under invoice financing or factoring. In a payment setting a criminal may impersonate a supplier and ask a buyer to pay a genuine invoice to a new bank account, a pattern linked to business email compromise.
Red flags include invoices from debtors that cannot be confirmed, customers who are related to the seller, sudden growth in volumes, unusual payment patterns where the financier is paid from unrelated accounts and changes in bank details by email. Controls include verifying invoices directly with the debtor, checking delivery and acceptance, collecting payments into an account the financier controls, call-back checks on any change of bank details and matching invoices with purchase orders and shipping records. The commercial invoice is also compared with customs and transport records.
Multiple Pledging
Multiple pledging is the pledging of the same goods, receivables or warehouse receipts to more than one lender at the same time, so that each lender believes it holds exclusive security. It is a risk in commodity finance, where metals, grain and similar stock can be financed repeatedly against the same inventory. In a widely reported 2014 case at the Chinese port of Qingdao, the same stocks of metal were alleged to have been pledged to several lenders, which led many banks to review their exposure to commodity financing.
Lenders limit this risk by registering their security where a registry exists, such as filing a financing statement in the United States, by using independent collateral managers to control warehouses, by verifying stock through inspections and by requiring negotiable warehouse receipts to be delivered and checked. Digital registries and electronic bills of lading are also being adopted to show who holds a document at any time. Related financing structures are described under warehouse receipt financing and structured trade finance.
Common controls
Across all four schemes, banks combine documentary examination by trained staff with independent verification of facts. Typical measures are screening and due diligence on every party and vessel, checking prices against market norms, cross-checking documents against shipping and customs data, limits on repeat financing against the same goods and escalation of suspicious cases through a suspicious activity report.
Detection is difficult because the same features that make trade finance efficient also hide fraud. Transactions cross borders and legal systems, involve several banks that each see only part of the chain, and rest on documents that can be produced cheaply. Fraudsters often run schemes through networks of related companies that trade with each other and so supply convincing paper trails. Losses are usually discovered only when a payment fails or when a lender asks to inspect goods. For that reason, banks stress staff training, the sharing of alerts between institutions and regular independent audits of collateral, rather than reliance on any single check.
External links
Ref 1310000588