Structured trade finance (STF) is a family of bespoke financing techniques in which a lender funds the production, storage, processing or sale of goods, usually commodities, and relies for repayment mainly on the goods themselves and on the cash they generate rather than on the borrower's general creditworthiness. Typical borrowers are producers and exporters of oil, metals, minerals and agricultural products in emerging markets, and the trading houses that buy and move those goods.
Where conventional trade finance rests on the credit of the buyer, the seller or their banks, structured deals are built around a controlled chain of assets: goods in a warehouse, a sales contract with a creditworthy buyer, a collection account that receives the sale proceeds. The lender's security follows the goods from one form to the next, which allows finance to reach borrowers that could not raise unsecured credit, or to be raised in larger amounts and for longer than their balance sheets alone would support. Banks often group the activity with commodity finance, and the two terms are frequently used interchangeably, although structured techniques are also applied to manufactured goods and services exports.
Main structures
The main structures are defined by the stage of the trade cycle being financed:
- Pre-export finance. A loan to a producer repaid from future export sales under offtake contracts with named buyers; see pre-export finance (PXF).
- Prepayment finance. A buyer, often a trader, pays the producer in advance for future deliveries, funded by banks that take an assignment of the buyer's rights; see commodity prepayment facility.
- Tolling finance. Finance for the owner of raw material that pays a processor, such as a refinery or smelter, a fee to convert it, with the lender keeping security over the material throughout; see tolling finance.
- Warehouse and inventory finance. Loans against goods in storage, often evidenced by warehouse receipts.
- Borrowing base facilities. Revolving lines for traders where available credit is recalculated regularly from the value of eligible stock, receivables and hedged positions, less haircuts; see borrowing base.
Security and controls
Lenders protect themselves by controlling the assets and the cash. The borrower assigns its rights under the sales or offtake agreement to the lender and instructs the buyer to pay into a collection account controlled by the lender, so that sales proceeds repay the loan before any surplus reaches the borrower. Goods in storage are monitored by independent collateral managers, which check quantity and quality and release goods only on the lender's instructions. Lenders also take pledges over stock, assignments of insurance policies and, where the goods are shipped under documentary terms, control of the bill of lading.
Price risk is usually hedged with exchange-traded futures or swaps, and borrowing bases apply haircuts so that a fall in price does not leave the loan under-collateralised. Cover from export credit agencies, multilateral development banks or private insurers is often added for political risk, such as export bans or currency transfer restrictions in the producer's country.
Risks and failures
The structures turn credit risk into a mix of performance, legal and operational risk. A producer may fail to deliver because of a strike, drought or mine accident; local courts may not enforce assignments or pledges as expected; and the security is only as good as the controls over the goods. Fraud is the most damaging failure. In 2014, investigations at the Chinese port of Qingdao found that metal stocks had been pledged to several lenders at once, and in 2020 the collapse of the Singapore oil trader Hin Leong revealed large losses that lenders said had been hidden from them. Such cases of double financing and missing stock led banks to tighten warehouse checks, cut lending to smaller traders and push for digital records of title.
Market and regulation
Structured trade finance is provided by specialist commodity banks, trade desks at large international banks, development finance institutions and, increasingly, non-bank funds that buy participations. Deals are frequently shared among lenders through club deals or syndication. Under the Basel capital framework, commodities finance is one of the sub-classes of specialised lending, which reflects the dependence of repayment on the financed asset rather than on the borrower. Typical documentation combines a facility agreement, security over goods and receivables, collateral management agreements and assignments of contracts, often with a credit risk mitigation layer of insurance.
External links
Ref 1310000303