What is bank fraud?
Definition: Deliberate deception aimed at a bank, or at money and property in a bank's custody, made a specific federal offence in the United States by 18 U.S.C. 1344.
Bank fraud is the use of false statements, forged documents, stolen identities or other deception to obtain money or property from a bank, or from funds that a bank holds for its customers. The term is often used loosely for any fraud that touches a bank, but in the United States it is also the name of a particular federal crime, created by the Bank Fraud Act of 1984 and now found in 18 U.S.C. 1344. The victim may be the bank itself, as with a loan obtained on invented figures, or a customer whose account is raided through account takeover.
Banks attract fraud because they hold large balances, move money quickly and rely on paperwork and identity checks that can be falsified. Prosecutors in the United States often pair the bank fraud statute with wire fraud and mail fraud counts, because the same scheme usually relies on electronic messages or the postal system. Other countries prosecute the same conduct under general fraud, forgery and theft laws, such as the Fraud Act 2006 in England and Wales.
The federal offence
Section 1344 punishes anyone who knowingly executes, or attempts to execute, a scheme either to defraud a financial institution or to obtain money, funds, credits, assets or other property owned by or in the custody of a financial institution by means of false or fraudulent pretences, representations or promises. The first limb is aimed at deceiving the institution itself. The second reaches schemes that use deception to get at a bank's property, including deposits, and the Supreme Court held in Loughrin v. United States (2014) that it does not separately require proof of an intent to defraud the bank. In Shaw v. United States (2016) the Court confirmed that a scheme to take money from a customer's account can defraud the bank, even if the bank suffers no final loss.
The statute covers attempts as well as completed schemes, so the offence is committed by carrying out the scheme, not by the bank losing money. The maximum penalty is 30 years in prison and a fine of up to $1,000,000, and prosecutions may generally be brought within ten years. The term “financial institution” is defined in 18 U.S.C. 20 and takes in federally insured banks and credit unions, Federal Reserve banks, Farm Credit System institutions and the US branches of foreign banks, among others.
Common forms of bank fraud
Bank fraud takes many shapes, and the same offender may combine several of them.
- Loan fraud. A borrower or a broker supplies false income, inflated collateral values or a straw borrower to obtain credit that would otherwise be refused; the property-based variants are covered under mortgage fraud and the fraudulent loan application.
- Account and identity fraud. Accounts are opened with stolen or invented identities, as in synthetic identity fraud and identity theft, and later used to receive proceeds or to draw credit.
- Check schemes. Check fraud includes forged and altered items and kiting, in which uncollected funds are shuffled between accounts to create a false balance.
- Payment redirection. Customers or staff are deceived into sending transfers to accounts controlled by the offender, a pattern seen in business email compromise.
Insider fraud
Staff and officers can commit bank fraud from within, by making loans to associates on false terms, concealing bad assets or diverting funds. Insider fraud was a significant factor in many of the savings and loan failures of the 1980s, and the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989 raised the penalties for offences affecting financial institutions in response. Insider abuse also carries a lower reporting threshold for banks than outside fraud, and bank examiners look closely at lending to insiders and related parties.
Detection, reporting and enforcement
Banks use verification checks, transaction monitoring and internal controls to detect fraud, and in the United States they must report suspected criminal activity under the Bank Secrecy Act. A bank files a suspicious activity report where it detects a known or suspected violation involving insider abuse in any amount, or a transaction of at least $5,000 where a suspect can be identified, or $25,000 even where none can.
Investigations are carried out by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the United States Secret Service, together with the inspectors general of bank regulators such as the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, and cases are prosecuted by United States attorneys under the supervision of the Department of Justice. Convictions commonly carry orders for restitution to victims and forfeiture of proceeds, and defendants frequently face related conspiracy and money laundering charges as well.
External links
Ref 1140000215