Market and non-market production, in national accounts, are the concepts that decide what counts as production in gross domestic product (GDP) and how each kind of output is valued. They are set out in the System of National Accounts (SNA) and its regional versions, and are applied by every statistics office that compiles GDP.
The concepts build on one another. The production boundary sets the outer limit of what is counted. Within it, producers are classed as market or non-market by the economically significant prices test. Market output is valued at its sale price, non-market output at its cost, and output kept for own use at equivalent market prices. Imputations fill in values where no transaction takes place, and the treatment of illegal production shows how far the boundary reaches. The broader approach to measuring output is covered under measuring national output.
Production Boundary
The production boundary is the line that separates activities counted as production in the national accounts from those that are not. Inside it are all goods and services produced for sale, all goods produced by households for their own use, such as crops grown and eaten on a family farm, own-account construction, and the housing services that owner-occupiers provide to themselves. Outside it are most services that households produce for themselves, such as cooking, cleaning and caring for children, when done by unpaid family members. Natural processes without human management, like the growth of wild fish stocks, are also excluded.
The boundary matters because it affects the level of GDP and comparisons across countries and over time. When paid childcare replaces care at home, measured output rises even if the total amount of care is unchanged. Statisticians draw the line where values are reliable and the activity links to markets, and they measure unpaid household work separately in satellite accounts.
Market Producer
A market producer is an institutional unit that sells most or all of its output at prices that are economically significant. Most corporations, from manufacturers to banks, are market producers, as are unincorporated businesses run by households. Public corporations owned by government are also market producers if they sell at such prices, which is why they are classified in the corporations sectors and not in general government.
The classification matters for sector boundaries. Deciding whether a state-owned railway or hospital trust is a market or non-market producer determines whether its debt and deficit are counted in government accounts. It also affects how its output is valued: a market producer's output is measured by its sales plus changes in inventories, so its value added reflects market prices and the profit or loss it makes. The split between market and non-market producers is one of the first tests applied when building the institutional sectors and units of the accounts.
Non-Market Producer
A non-market producer is a unit that provides most of its output free of charge or at prices that are not economically significant. The two main types are government units, covered under general government (sector), and non-profit institutions serving households (NPISH), such as charities, churches and many clubs. State schools, public hospitals, police and defense are typical examples.
Because their output has no meaningful market price, it is valued at the sum of production costs: compensation of employees, intermediate consumption, consumption of fixed capital and other taxes less subsidies on production. A non-market producer therefore normally shows no net operating surplus. Its output is mostly recorded as final consumption expenditure of government or of NPISHs on behalf of households. Some non-market producers also have small market sales, such as museum entry fees, which are recorded as part of their output.
Economically Significant Prices
Economically significant prices are prices that have a substantial influence on the amounts producers are willing to supply and on the amounts buyers wish to purchase. They are the test used to decide whether a producer is a market or a non-market producer. A firm charging prices that cover its costs and respond to demand is a market producer; an agency charging a nominal fee that does not affect how much is used is not.
Because the definition is qualitative, statisticians apply supporting rules. The best known, used in the European System of Accounts, is the 50 per cent criterion: a unit is a market producer if its sales cover at least half of its production costs over a sustained multi-year period. Other factors include whether the unit competes with private firms and whether its sales are to government only. The test can change a unit's sector when its pricing or funding changes, which in turn moves its debt into or out of government statistics.
Non-Market Output
Non-market output is the goods and services that government units and NPISHs supply to others free or at prices that are not economically significant. Examples include public education, health care provided free at the point of use, policing and the services of charities. It contrasts with market output, which is sold at economically significant prices, and with output for own final use.
Non-market output is valued at the cost of producing it, since no market price exists. Its volume is harder to measure. For many years statisticians assumed that the volume of output moved with the volume of inputs, such as hours worked, which implied zero productivity growth. Many countries now use direct output indicators, such as the number of pupils taught or treatments delivered, sometimes adjusted for quality. The choice can make a noticeable difference to measured real GDP growth and to estimates of public sector productivity.
Output for Own Final Use
Output for own final use is goods and services that a producer keeps for its own final consumption or capital formation, rather than selling them. For households, the main examples are farm produce eaten by the family that grew it, own-account construction of dwellings, and the housing services that owner-occupiers produce for themselves. For businesses, examples include machinery, software or buildings produced by a firm's own staff for its own use, which count as gross fixed capital formation.
Such output is valued at the basic prices of similar products sold in the market, or at cost when no market price is available. In the case of housing, the value is the rent that would be paid for an equivalent property, which is why statisticians impute rents for owner-occupied property. Recording output for own final use keeps GDP comparable between economies where housing is mainly rented and those where it is mainly owned, and between farm economies with large subsistence output and industrial ones.
Imputation
An imputation is a value that national accountants assign to a flow or activity for which there is no actual market transaction, so that GDP is complete and comparable. The largest is usually the imputed rental value of owner-occupied housing. Another is financial intermediation services indirectly measured (FISIM), the value of banking services paid for through interest margins rather than explicit fees. Others include food grown for own consumption, wages paid in kind and the consumption of fixed capital of government.
Without imputations, GDP would change simply because of shifts in how activities are paid for, such as a move from renting to owning homes. Imputations also have limits. They rely on models and assumptions, add no cash income that households can spend, and can be large: imputed rent alone typically makes up a significant share of household consumption in countries with high home ownership. Statistics offices therefore publish them clearly so that users can separate them from observed transactions.
Illegal Production
Illegal production covers the production of goods and services whose sale, distribution or possession is forbidden by law, such as illicit drugs, and the unauthorized production of otherwise legal goods, such as unlicensed medical practice or untaxed alcohol. In principle the SNA treats such activities as production when they involve willing buyers and sellers, so they fall inside the production boundary. Theft and extortion, which are not mutually agreed transactions, are not production.
Including illegal output makes GDP comparable between countries with different laws, since an activity legal in one country may be banned in another. Practice varies because measurement is difficult. Following the European System of Accounts 2010, EU member states added estimates for illegal drugs, prostitution and smuggling to their national accounts in 2014, which raised measured GDP in several countries. Illegal production overlaps with, but is not the same as, the shadow economy, which also includes legal activities hidden from tax authorities, and the informal economy of small unregistered businesses.
How the concepts compare
| Type of output | Typical producer | Valuation |
|---|---|---|
| Market output | Corporations and businesses | Sale prices |
| Non-market output | Government and NPISHs | Sum of costs |
| Output for own final use | Households and firms | Equivalent market prices |
Ref 1100001812