What is Mortgage Fraud?
Definition: A deliberate lie or omission about a borrower, property or transaction, on which a lender, buyer or insurer relies to approve or buy a home loan.
Mortgage fraud is the intentional misstatement, misrepresentation or omission of a material fact, relied on by a lender or investor to fund, purchase or insure a mortgage loan. It can be committed by borrowers, mortgage brokers, appraisers, title and settlement agents, loan officers or organised rings. It is commonly divided into fraud for housing, also known as fraud for property, and fraud for profit.
Losses fall on lenders, investors in mortgage-backed securities, insurers and sometimes the honest borrowers whose homes lose value. Weak verification of income and values contributed to the lending practices described in lending practices behind the subprime crisis. In the United States it is prosecuted under federal statutes including bank fraud and wire fraud.
Fraud for housing and fraud for profit
Fraud for housing is committed by a borrower who wants to buy or keep a home and misstates facts to qualify, for example by overstating income or employment, hiding debts or claiming a property as a primary residence when it is an investment property. The borrower usually intends to repay the loan.
Fraud for profit aims to extract money, and the borrower is often a pawn or a fictitious person. Its participants use inflated appraisals, straw buyers, false identities and forged documents to obtain loan proceeds that exceed the property's real value, with no intention to repay. Such schemes cause the larger losses and often involve professionals. Typical warning signs for lenders include a rapid resale at a sharply higher price, several loans closing in the same area on one day, appraisals that match the contract price exactly, and borrowers whose employment cannot be confirmed. The pattern was prominent in the housing boom that preceded the 2007 to 2008 financial crisis, when low documentation loans made false statements harder to catch and loans were quickly sold on to investors.
Common schemes
- Occupancy and income misrepresentation, in which a borrower overstates earnings, conceals liabilities or misstates intended use to obtain better terms.
- Inflated appraisals, where the value is overstated so that the loan exceeds the real collateral, as covered under property flipping and sale fraud schemes.
- Straw buyers and identity abuse, including synthetic identities and stolen identities used as borrowers.
- Silent second financing, where undisclosed extra borrowing covers the down payment, which is described in silent second.
- Foreclosure rescue schemes that target distressed owners, covered under foreclosure rescue scams.
Related cases include house title fraud, where a property is transferred or mortgaged through forged documents.
Mortgage industry fraud
Mortgage Industry Fraud (fraud Committed by Mortgage Professionals) is carried out by people employed in lending, such as brokers, loan officers, appraisers and settlement agents, who falsify documents, manipulate valuations or divert funds. It is often reported separately because insiders know the controls and can mislead several loans at once. The role of each professional matters: an appraiser who inflates a value, a broker who coaches a borrower on what to state, a settlement agent who diverts proceeds or a loan officer who accepts forged documents can each enable the scheme, and collusion between several of them is typical of the larger rings. Because the loans appear to be properly documented, the fraud often surfaces only after early payment defaults. Related misconduct appears under mortgage loan origination fraud schemes.
Reporting, penalties and lender controls
US banks report suspected mortgage fraud on a suspicious activity report to FinCEN, which maintains a specific category for it, and the Federal Bureau of Investigation investigates large cases with other agencies. Under 18 U.S.C. 1344, bank fraud carries a maximum sentence of 30 years and a fine of up to $1,000,000, and false statements to a financial institution are punishable under a separate provision.
Penalties are not limited to prison. Courts can order restitution to lenders, forfeiture of proceeds, and professional licences can be revoked, while lenders may be required to repurchase loans sold to investors if misrepresentations are found. Lenders control the risk through verification of employment and income, independent appraisal review, identity checks, automated data matching, post-closing quality control sampling and buyback demands from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac when loans prove defective, as part of ordinary underwriting.
Ref 1050000827