Mortgage loan origination fraud schemes are deceptions committed while a home loan is being applied for, underwritten and approved. Each relies on a specific lie that a lender would not accept if it were known: a borrower who does not exist, a property worth less than stated, funds that are really borrowed, a home that will not be lived in, a buyer who is not the real buyer, or a purchase that hides an intention to abandon another mortgage. Law-enforcement agencies in the United States often divide mortgage fraud into fraud for housing, where a borrower misstates facts to obtain a loan for a home, and fraud for profit, where industry insiders or organised groups extract loan proceeds.
The schemes involve borrowers, mortgage brokers, appraisers, loan officers, settlement agents and sometimes investors who buy the loans afterwards. They are usually charged as bank fraud or false statements to a lender, and lenders counter them with verification of identity, income, assets and valuations, and with post-closing quality-control reviews.
Air Loan
An air loan is a mortgage made to a borrower who does not exist, or on a property that does not exist or is not what it is claimed to be. It is normally arranged by a broker or other insider, who prepares an application with a fictitious or stolen identity, invented employment and income, a bogus appraisal and false supporting papers. If the lender or a warehouse funder releases the money, it goes to the closing agent or to accounts controlled by the perpetrators, and the loan may be sold on before the fraud is noticed.
Warning signs include no payment at all after closing, mail returned undeliverable, borrower details that cannot be verified, and closing funds sent to unusual accounts. The case is a close relative of a fraudulent loan application, but there is no real borrower to pursue, so the lender and later purchasers of the loan bear the whole loss.
Appraisal Fraud
Appraisal fraud is the deliberate inflation, or sometimes deflation, of a property valuation so that a loan can be larger than the property supports or a purchase can be concealed. An inflated figure lowers the apparent loan-to-value ratio, so the lender advances more than the collateral is worth. Pressure may come from a broker, agent or seller who is paid when the loan closes, or the appraiser may collude, which is common in property flipping schemes.
Red flags include a price far above recent comparable sales, a quick resale at a large gain and an appraisal report that ignores obvious defects. Rules aim to protect the independence of the appraiser: the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 added valuation-independence requirements to the Truth in Lending Act, implemented in Regulation Z, and appraisers work under professional standards and state licensing.
Gift Letter Fraud
Gift letter fraud occurs when a borrower presents borrowed money as a gift, usually from a relative, so that a debt is hidden in the down payment. Genuine gifts are allowed for many loans, but investors such as Fannie Mae expect a signed letter that names the donor and the amount, states that no repayment is required and comes from an acceptable donor, together with evidence that the funds were actually transferred.
In the fraudulent version the "donor" expects repayment, or the money is returned after closing, so the borrower carries more debt than reported and the down payment is not really the borrower's own. A related device is the undisclosed second lien known as a silent second. Lenders trace deposits through bank statements, check that the donor could afford the gift and follow the rules in gift funds and asset verification.
Occupancy Fraud
Occupancy fraud is a borrower's false claim about how a property will be used. Loans for a primary residence usually carry lower rates and smaller down payments than loans for a second home or an investment property, so a buyer may declare owner occupancy while planning to rent the home out. Reverse occupancy runs the other way: a borrower declares a property to be an investment but intends to live in it, for instance to use anticipated rent to qualify.
The standard security instrument used with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans requires the borrower to occupy the home within 60 days and to live there for at least a year, with limited exceptions. Lenders check tax returns, utility records and mailing addresses, and false occupancy statements can be prosecuted as false statements to a lender.
Straw Buyer
A straw buyer is a person who applies for a mortgage and signs the documents in their own name while the real buyer, who may not qualify or may want to stay hidden, controls the property. The straw buyer may be paid a fee, or deceived, and often has good credit that is used to support a loan which the true purchaser will not repay. Lenders spot the pattern when the stated buyer has no apparent link to the property, income is overstated, or a credit report shows many recent applications.
It differs from a legitimate nominee arrangement or a co-signer, because in those cases the lender is told who is involved and who will pay. Using a straw buyer to hide the true borrower is a federal crime, and bank fraud under 18 U.S.C. 1344 carries up to 30 years in prison.
Buy and Bail
Buy and bail describes a borrower who owes more than the home is worth, buys a second property with a new mortgage, then lets the first go into default. Simply buying another home is not fraud. The deception arises if the application hides the intention to abandon the old loan, understates debt, or claims to keep the first home as a rental when it will be left to foreclosure. The borrower in an underwater mortgage may also face a deficiency claim or the tax effects of the loss.
Lenders can often detect it from the credit file, the debt-to-income calculation, payment history on the first loan and the borrower's timing. Regulators treat deliberate misstatements as fraud, and the practice is distinct from a genuine short sale, where the lender agrees to the sale.
How the schemes compare
| Scheme | Main lie | Typical perpetrator |
|---|---|---|
| Air loan | Borrower or property does not exist | Broker or insider |
| Appraisal fraud | Property value is wrong | Appraiser, broker or seller |
| Gift letter fraud | Borrowed money is called a gift | Borrower |
| Occupancy fraud | Use of the home is misstated | Borrower |
| Straw buyer | Buyer's identity is not the real buyer | Real buyer with a nominee |
| Buy and bail | Intention to default is hidden | Borrower |
Ref 1140000229