A mutual evaluation, in the sense used by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), is a peer review of a country's system for combating money laundering, terrorist financing and proliferation financing. Assessors from other member countries and the secretariat examine the country's laws, institutions and results, and publish a report with ratings and recommended actions.
Mutual evaluations are the main way the FATF checks that its members, and the members of its regional partners, apply the FATF Recommendations. They are carried out by the FATF itself or by a FATF-style regional body (FSRB), and the IMF and World Bank also assess some countries using the same methodology. A poor result can lead to the country being placed on the FATF grey list.
What is assessed
Since the fourth round, which began in 2014, each evaluation has had two parts. The technical compliance assessment checks whether the legal and institutional framework meets each of the 40 Recommendations, covering areas such as criminalising money laundering, customer due diligence, record keeping, suspicious transaction reporting, transparency of beneficial ownership and international cooperation.
The effectiveness assessment asks whether the system actually works in practice. It is organised around 11 Immediate Outcomes, which cover matters such as understanding of risk, supervision of financial institutions and other businesses, use of financial intelligence, investigation and prosecution of money laundering, confiscation of criminal proceeds, and targeted financial sanctions for terrorism and proliferation. Effectiveness is judged from evidence such as statistics, case examples and interviews, not just from the text of laws.
Ratings
Each Recommendation receives a technical compliance rating, and each Immediate Outcome an effectiveness rating:
- Technical compliance. Compliant, largely compliant, partially compliant or non-compliant, with "not applicable" used rarely.
- Effectiveness. High, substantial, moderate or low level of effectiveness.
The two sets of ratings are reported side by side. A country can have strong laws yet low effectiveness if supervisors, the financial intelligence unit or prosecutors do not apply them, which is common in practice.
The evaluation process
An evaluation typically takes more than a year from start to adoption. The country first completes questionnaires on its framework and effectiveness and shares its national risk assessment. An assessment team then reviews the material and makes an on-site visit, usually lasting about two weeks, to meet government agencies, supervisors, law enforcement and the private sector. A draft report is discussed with the country, reviewed for quality and consistency, and debated and adopted at a plenary meeting of the FATF or the relevant FSRB. Reports are then published on the FATF or FSRB website, together with a list of priority actions for the country to address.
Assessors are experts drawn from other member countries, usually including specialists in law, financial supervision and law enforcement, and they are supported by the secretariat of the assessing body. Countries can comment on drafts and discuss contested ratings at the plenary.
The process draws heavily on the risk-based approach. Assessors expect a country to understand its own money laundering and terrorist financing risks and to focus resources where risk is highest, including allowing simplified due diligence where risks are proven to be low.
Follow-up and listing
After adoption, a country is placed in regular follow-up or, if the results are weak, enhanced follow-up with more frequent reporting. It can ask for re-ratings of technical compliance once it has fixed deficiencies. Countries with significant weaknesses may be referred to the FATF's International Cooperation Review Group, and those that agree an action plan are publicly listed as jurisdictions under increased monitoring, the grey list. Countries that do not engage, or have very serious deficiencies, can be named as high-risk jurisdictions subject to a call for action, often called the blacklist.
Listing matters for the wider economy. Banks abroad may apply enhanced due diligence to transactions linked to a listed country, and some withdraw from correspondent banking relationships, a pattern known as de-risking.
Rounds and financial inclusion
A new, fifth round of mutual evaluations began in 2024 under a revised methodology, with a stronger focus on risk, on effectiveness and on shorter, more frequent assessment cycles. The FATF has also stressed that overly strict rules can exclude people from the formal system, and it has amended its standards and guidance to encourage proportionate measures such as tiered KYC for low-value accounts. For this reason, mutual evaluation results are closely watched in financial inclusion policy, where unintended exclusion is treated as a risk in its own right.
External links
Ref 1050000699