What is Mail Fraud?
Definition: The federal crime of devising a scheme to obtain money or property by deception and using the mail, or a private or commercial interstate carrier, to carry it out.
Mail fraud is a United States federal crime defined in 18 U.S.C. 1341. It punishes anyone who devises or intends to devise a scheme to defraud, or to obtain money or property by false or fraudulent pretences, representations or promises, and who uses the postal service, or a private or commercial interstate carrier, to carry out the scheme. It is one of the oldest federal white-collar offences, tracing back to the Postal Act of 1872, and the main investigating agency is the United States Postal Inspection Service.
Because almost any fraud involves a letter, a parcel or an invoice at some stage, prosecutors have long used the statute against a wide range of conduct, from fake lotteries to corporate and public-corruption cases. The sister provision for electronic communications is wire fraud under 18 U.S.C. 1343, which is built on the same pattern, and the two are often charged together alongside bank fraud (18 U.S.C. 1344).
Elements of the offence
To convict, the government must generally prove three things beyond reasonable doubt. First, the defendant took part in a scheme to defraud, meaning a plan to deprive another of money or property by deception, using a material misrepresentation or concealment. Second, the defendant acted with specific intent to defraud. Third, the mail or a qualifying carrier was used in furtherance of the scheme, or caused to be used, which includes foreseeable use by others. The mailing need not itself contain a lie. In Schmuck v. United States (1989) the Supreme Court held that an ordinary mailing that is a step in the plan can suffice, and the scheme need not succeed, since the offence is complete when the mail is used for the purpose of executing it.
Each separate mailing can be charged as a count, which is why indictments can contain dozens of counts. The scheme must concern money or property: in McNally v. United States (1987) the Court rejected a broader theory, Congress responded in 1988 with 18 U.S.C. 1346, which covers the deprivation of the intangible right of honest services, and in Skilling v. United States (2010) the Court limited that provision to bribes and kickbacks. Later decisions have further narrowed or clarified the reach of the money-or-property requirement.
Penalties
The basic penalty is a fine and imprisonment of up to 20 years for each count. Where the offence affects a financial institution, or relates to a presidentially declared disaster or emergency, the maximum rises to 30 years and a larger fine. Courts also order restitution to victims and forfeiture of proceeds, and sentences under the federal guidelines depend largely on the loss caused, the number of victims and the defendant's role. Mail fraud is also a predicate act under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act, so a pattern of it can support a racketeering charge and civil damages.
Common schemes
- Advance-fee schemes, in which victims pay in advance for a prize, loan or job that does not exist, including lottery and sweepstakes letters.
- Investment fraud, including a Ponzi scheme that sends false account statements by mail, and chain letters that ask for money.
- Mortgage and insurance fraud, where false documents or claims are posted or sent by courier.
- Check fraud and charity or impersonation scams conducted through mailed solicitations.
- Fraud on public programmes, tax refunds and benefits, where forms are sent by post.
Detection and reporting
Victims and organisations can report suspected mail fraud to the Postal Inspection Service, which investigates and can seize mail and obtain mail-cover information, and to the Federal Trade Commission and state attorneys general. The Postal Service can also issue civil orders against fraudulent mailers under separate postal fraud statutes. Banks and money services businesses report related transactions through suspicious activity reports, and mail theft is itself a separate offence under 18 U.S.C. 1708, often connected to check washing and identity theft. Many other countries criminalise the same conduct through general fraud laws; in the United Kingdom, for example, the Fraud Act 2006 covers fraud however it is committed, and no separate mail offence is needed.
External links
Ref 1210000759