What is insurance fraud?
Definition: Knowingly lying to, or deceiving, an insurer to get cover, a lower premium or a claim payment that the facts would not support.
Insurance fraud is any intentional deception committed against an Insurer, or by an insurer or its agents against customers, to obtain a financial benefit. It can occur at any stage of the contract: when an applicant answers underwriting questions, when a Insured (Policyholder) pays or reports exposure, when a loss is claimed, and when a provider such as a clinic, repairer or lawyer bills for services. It exists in every class of cover, from Auto Insurance and property to health, workers' compensation and life policies.
The cost is borne widely. Insurers pass the money lost and the expense of investigation to honest customers through higher premiums, and the problem is a standard example of Moral Hazard, where cover changes a person's incentives. Offences are normally prosecuted under general fraud laws, such as the Fraud Act 2006 in the United Kingdom, or under specific insurance-fraud statutes in most US states, and insurers also use civil remedies such as voiding a policy.
Hard fraud and soft fraud
Practitioners separate two broad kinds. Hard fraud is a planned or invented loss: a staged vehicle collision, arson of an insured building, a faked theft, a fabricated injury, or the sinking of a vessel. Soft fraud, also called opportunistic fraud, is the exaggeration of a genuine claim, for example adding items to a household theft claim or inflating repair costs. Soft fraud is generally thought to be far more common than hard fraud, and many people who would never invent a loss tolerate padding, which is why insurers treat it as a matter of public attitude as well as investigation.
Who commits it
- Applicants and policyholders. Concealing previous claims, giving a false address or vehicle garaging location to lower the price, misdescribing the driver, or failing to disclose a health condition, a practice linked to Adverse Selection.
- Claimants. Inflating or inventing losses, or claiming for damage that existed before the policy began.
- Providers and professionals. Billing for services not delivered, falsifying medical records, or recommending unnecessary treatment, sometimes in organised rings that recruit people to stage accidents.
- Insiders and intermediaries. Agents who collect premiums and keep them, or employees who process fake claims, in a pattern close to Embezzlement.
- Insurers. Some cases involve the wrongful denial of valid claims or the misuse of customer money.
Effects on cost and trust
Industry bodies in several countries estimate that fraud adds a noticeable share to the cost of claims, although estimates differ by method and country and are not given here. The effect is not only financial. Investigators and loss adjusters must scrutinise genuine claims more closely, which slows payment for honest customers, and some insurers have exited or repriced classes of cover that attract organised abuse. Public campaigns therefore stress that exaggerating a claim is fraud, not a victimless shortcut.
Premium fraud covers misstatement of the exposure on which the price is based, such as an employer understating payroll or classifying staff in a safer job category to cut a workers' compensation bill. Organised schemes include ghost-broking, where a fake broker sells forged or non-existent policies, and the use of forged documents of the kind described under Forgery. In life insurance, faked deaths and false identities have been used to claim a death benefit, which links the offence to wider Financial Fraud.
Detection and consequences
Insurers use rules and analytics to score claims for risk, link networks of people, addresses and providers, and refer suspicious files to a special investigations unit. Many countries run industry bodies that share data about claims and investigate rings, and the sector's staff are often trained through bodies such as the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE). Insurers also review Claim (Insurance) patterns during Claims Administration, and reinsurers and regulators expect effective Fraud Detection and Fraud Prevention systems. Where an insurer suspects a crime, laws in many jurisdictions require or encourage a report to law enforcement or a fraud bureau. Penalties vary widely, from refusal of the claim and cancellation of cover to fines, restitution and imprisonment, and a conviction can follow a person into later insurance applications.
External links
Ref 1170000341