A material adverse change (MAC) clause is a contract provision that allows one party, usually a lender or an acquirer, to refuse to perform or to walk away if the other party's business, assets, financial condition or prospects deteriorate seriously before or during the life of the contract. In acquisition agreements the same idea is often called a material adverse effect (MAE) clause. The clause allocates the risk of a sharp, unexpected decline between the parties.
MAC clauses appear in loan agreements, bond documents, merger and share purchase agreements and some underwriting commitments. They are among the most heavily negotiated words in a deal, yet courts in the main common-law jurisdictions have rarely allowed a party to rely on one. Most of their value lies in the bargaining leverage they create rather than in successful litigation.
Where MAC clauses appear in loans
In a bank facility, a MAC concept can be used in several places at once:
- As a representation. The borrower states in its representations and warranties that no material adverse change has occurred since its last audited accounts, and repeats the statement on each drawdown or interest date.
- As a condition to drawing. Lenders may refuse a new advance, such as a draw on a revolving credit facility, if the repeated MAC representation is untrue, which works as a drawstop alongside the conditions precedent.
- As an event of default. Some agreements, more often in bilateral or smaller-company lending, list a MAC as an event of default, which lets lenders accelerate the loan.
Large investment-grade and leveraged borrowers usually negotiate the MAC default out or limit it to their ability to meet payment obligations. Lenders then rely on objective tests such as financial covenants, which are easier to prove.
MAC clauses in mergers and acquisitions
In mergers and acquisitions, the MAE clause matters in the gap between signing and closing, which can last months while regulatory approvals are obtained. The buyer typically has a closing condition that no material adverse effect on the target has occurred, and the target's representations are often measured against an MAE standard. If an MAE occurs, the buyer may terminate rather than close.
The financing behind a deal interacts with this. Under the UK takeover regime, a bidder making a cash offer must show that funding is in place, so acquisition finance for a takeover offer is provided on a "certain funds" basis, with very limited grounds for lenders to refuse to fund and usually no general MAC drawstop. In US leveraged buyouts, commitment papers often tie the lenders' MAC condition to the one in the acquisition agreement so that lenders cannot walk away when the buyer cannot. Both approaches are discussed further under leveraged buyout financing concepts.
Why a MAC is hard to invoke
Courts read MAC clauses narrowly. In Delaware, the leading US forum for merger disputes, the cases have required a change that is significant over a durationally meaningful period measured in years rather than months, viewed from the standpoint of a reasonable acquirer. In IBP v Tyson Foods (2001) and Hexion v Huntsman (2008), buyers failed to establish an MAE. The first clear finding that a buyer could terminate on that ground came in Akorn v Fresenius in 2018, where the target's results had collapsed and serious regulatory compliance failures had come to light.
English courts take a similarly cautious line. A party relying on the clause must usually prove the change was material, was not known or contemplated when the contract was made and was not temporary. The burden of proof falls on the party invoking it, and wrongly refusing to fund or close exposes a lender or buyer to damages and reputational harm. This is why lenders facing a deteriorating borrower more often rely on a covenant breach or a payment default than on a MAC.
Typical carve-outs
Acquisition-agreement MAE definitions usually exclude broad categories of risk that the buyer is expected to bear, often unless the target is hit disproportionately compared with its industry peers:
- General economic, financial market or political conditions, including changes in interest rates and exchange rates.
- Conditions affecting the target's industry as a whole.
- Changes in law or accounting standards after signing.
- War, terrorism, natural disasters and, since 2020, pandemics and epidemics.
- Effects of announcing the deal itself, and any failure to meet internal projections, though not the underlying causes of that failure.
The Covid-19 pandemic tested these terms. In AB Stable v MAPS Hotels (2020), a Delaware court found that the pandemic's effects fell within a carve-out for calamities, but allowed the buyer to walk away on a separate ground: the seller had breached its covenant to run the business in the ordinary course. Such outcomes have encouraged drafters to treat MAC language alongside related protections such as force majeure and ordinary-course covenants, rather than as a stand-alone exit.
Ref 1210000678