Die-related coin errors are minting faults caused by problems with the dies, the engraved steel tools that stamp the design onto a coin. Because a single die strikes many thousands of coins, a fault in it repeats on every coin it makes until it is replaced. That separates die errors from one-off striking faults, such as an off-centre strike, which affect a single coin.
The main types are doubled dies, clashed dies, die cracks, cuds and mules. They interest collectors, mint quality-control staff and anyone studying how coins are made, because each error shows a particular weakness in the coin minting process. Die errors are recorded and catalogued as part of numismatics, and the broader category is covered on the page Error Coin. Errors that come from the press or the metal disc rather than the die are described under Striking and Planchet Coin Errors. Error coins remain legal tender at face value.
Doubled Die
A doubled die is a die that has received two slightly misaligned impressions from the hub during its manufacture. Older die-making methods pressed the hub into the die more than once, and if the hub or die shifted or rotated between impressions, the die ended up carrying a doubled image. Every coin struck from that die then shows doubled lettering, dates or design elements.
The best-known example is the 1955 Lincoln cent from the Philadelphia Mint, whose date and inscriptions show strong doubling visible without magnification. A true doubled die differs from strike doubling, also called machine doubling, which is caused by a loose die bouncing during the strike. Strike doubling produces flat, shelf-like edges and is common; doubled-die images are rounded and raised, and the two are told apart by experts as part of coin grading, where error attributions are recorded alongside the grade; see also Coin Grades and Grading Terms. Modern single-impression hubbing has made new doubled dies uncommon.
Clashed Dies
Clashed dies are a pair of dies that have struck each other with no planchet between them, usually because the feed mechanism failed to place a blank. The force of the press transfers parts of each die's design into the other, leaving faint outlines. The fault is also called a die clash.
Every coin struck afterwards shows clash marks: ghostly traces of the opposite side's design, often reversed, appearing in the open field around the main design. A portrait outline might show faintly behind the lettering on the reverse, for example. Mints may polish the dies to remove the marks, which can erase fine details and leave a coin with a weakened design. Clash marks are fairly common on older coins and are mainly of interest for identifying which die pairs were used.
Die Crack
A die crack is a fracture in the steel of a die. Under the repeated force of striking, dies develop small cracks, often running between letters or through the date. During each strike, metal from the planchet flows into the crack, so the coin shows a thin raised line where the crack lies. The crack usually grows longer and wider over the die's working life.
Die cracks are among the most common die faults and, on their own, usually draw only a small premium from collectors. They can be used to trace the order in which coins from one die were struck, since a longer crack means a later coin. If a crack spreads until a piece of the die separates, the die produces a cud.
Cud (Die Break)
A cud is a raised, featureless lump of metal on a coin, caused when a piece of the die has broken away. It is a form of die break. Most cuds sit at the rim, where the edge of the die is weakest, and extend into the design. During the strike, coin metal flows into the gap left by the missing piece of steel, so that part of the design is replaced by a smooth blob.
A retained cud occurs when the broken piece has cracked loose but stays in place for a while, so the design is still visible but slightly raised or misaligned. A non-retained cud means the piece has fallen out. Cuds are the end of a progression that starts with die cracks, and a die showing a cud is normally soon removed from service. Their position is recorded with reference to the parts of a coin, such as the rim, field and legend.
Mule
A mule is a coin struck with an obverse and a reverse die that were never meant to be paired, such as the front of one denomination with the back of another, or a design from a different year. Mules arise when a wrong die is fitted into a press, usually at a mint producing several coin types at once.
The best-known modern example in the United States combines the obverse of a State quarter with the reverse of the Sacagawea dollar, struck on a dollar planchet around 2000. Mules are among the rarest die-related errors, because mints check die pairs carefully, and they are closely studied for authenticity, since a mule is also a tempting target for counterfeiters. Details of the US denominations involved are on the page United States Coin Denominations.
| Error | Cause | What appears on the coin |
|---|---|---|
| Doubled die | Misaligned hub impressions in die making | Doubled letters or design |
| Clashed dies | Dies strike each other without a planchet | Faint traces of the other side's design |
| Die crack | Fracture in the die steel | Thin raised line |
| Cud | Piece of die breaks away | Raised featureless lump, usually at the rim |
| Mule | Wrong pair of dies fitted | Mismatched obverse and reverse |
Ref 1150000112