Coin grades and grading terms are the standard vocabulary used to describe the physical condition of a coin. The core of the system is the 1–70 Sheldon scale, which pairs a number with a descriptive name such as Very Good, Very Fine or Mint State. Grades matter because two coins of the same type and date can differ greatly in value as collectibles depending on how much wear, damage or marking they show.
The terms are used by collectors, dealers, auction houses and independent grading services, and they form the practical side of coin grading. Circulated grades describe how far a coin has worn down in use; uncirculated grades describe coins with no wear at all. Third-party services then record their opinion of a coin's grade on a sealed holder, so the coin can change hands without being re-examined each time. The system grew up within numismatics in the United States and is now used worldwide, although British and European dealers also keep older adjectival grades.
Sheldon Scale
The Sheldon scale is a numerical grading system running from 1 to 70. It was introduced by William Sheldon in 1949 in a study of early United States large cents. Sheldon originally intended the numbers to track market value, so that a coin graded 70 would be worth seventy times one graded 1; that price link was soon abandoned, but the numbers survived as a shorthand for condition. Use of the scale is often called numerical grading.
The main bands are Poor (1), Fair (2), About Good (3), Good (4–6), Very Good (8–10), Fine (12–15), Very Fine (20–35), Extremely Fine (40–45), About Uncirculated (50–58) and Mint State (60–70). Not every number is used: grading services assign only set points within each band. Prefixes show the band, as in VF-30 or MS-64, while proof coins use PR or PF instead of MS. The scale was formalised for modern use by the American Numismatic Association and by commercial grading services from the 1980s onward.
Mint State (MS)
Mint State is the top band of the Sheldon scale, from MS-60 to MS-70, and covers coins made for circulation that show no wear at all. Within the band, grades are separated by the number and size of contact marks, the quality of the strike, the lustre of the surface and overall eye appeal, rather than by wear.
An MS-60 coin is technically uncirculated but may be heavily marked from contact with other coins in bags and counting machines, and may look dull. MS-63 is regarded as choice, and MS-65 is widely described as gem, meaning only minor marks and good lustre. MS-70 is a perfect coin with no post-production imperfections visible under modest magnification, a grade mostly seen on modern coins handled carefully from the press. Mint State is a grade of condition, not a manufacturing finish, so it describes the coin as it survives today rather than how the mint made it.
Uncirculated
Uncirculated, often shortened to Unc, describes a coin that has never been worn by use in circulation. In numerical terms it corresponds to the Mint State range, MS-60 to MS-70. An uncirculated coin can still carry bag marks, scratches from handling at the mint or toning from storage, because the term refers only to the absence of wear on the highest points of the design.
Two related terms are often confused with it. About Uncirculated (AU-50 to AU-58) describes a coin with only the slightest trace of wear, often visible as a loss of lustre on the highest points. Brilliant uncirculated, used by mints including the Royal Mint, names a production standard for collector coins struck with more care than ordinary coins but less than proofs; it describes how the coin was made rather than a grade. A proof, struck from polished dies for collectors, is a different finish again, covered under coin finishes, strikes and surfaces.
Very Fine (VF)
Very Fine is a mid-range circulated grade, covering VF-20 to VF-35 on the Sheldon scale. A Very Fine coin shows moderate wear on the high points of the design, such as hair, cheek or feathers, but all major details remain clear and most lettering is sharp. Some finer details, such as individual hair strands, may be partly worn away.
The grade sits between Fine, where wear is more obvious and much detail has merged, and Extremely Fine, where wear is light and limited to the very highest points. Graders judge it by checking specific diagnostic areas that differ by coin type: on one series the key may be a word on a headband, on another the feathers of an eagle's wing. For many older coins, Very Fine is a realistic grade for pieces that spent years in circulation, and the difference between VF-20 and VF-35 can still affect collector demand.
Very Good (VG)
Very Good is a low circulated grade, VG-8 to VG-10 on the Sheldon scale. Despite its name, a Very Good coin is heavily worn. The main design is outlined and recognisable, the date and lettering are readable, and the rim is mostly complete, but most interior detail has been worn flat.
The name reflects grading history rather than appearance. Early adjectival grades were ranked upward from Poor and Fair, so Good and Very Good sit near the bottom of the scale even though the words suggest otherwise. Below Very Good come Good (4–6), where the rim may merge with the lettering, and About Good, Fair and Poor, where the date or type may be hard to identify. Very Good is common for old, scarce coins that circulated for decades, and collectors of such series often accept it because higher-grade pieces are rare.
Encapsulated Coin (Slab)
An encapsulated coin is one that has been authenticated and graded by an independent grading service and sealed in a hard, tamper-evident plastic holder, commonly called a slab. The holder carries a label showing the coin's identification, its grade and a unique certification number that can be looked up in the service's database. Major commercial encapsulation began in the United States in the mid-1980s.
Slabs make trading easier because a buyer can rely on a recognised opinion of authenticity and grade without handling the coin, which also protects it from damage. They have limits. A grade is an expert opinion, and two services or two submissions can disagree; some owners break coins out of slabs and resubmit them hoping for a higher grade. Fake slabs containing counterfeit coins have also appeared, so the certification number and the holder itself need checking. Guarantees offered by grading services vary and are set by each service's own terms.
How the grades fit together
| Grade | Sheldon numbers | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| Very Good (VG) | 8–10 | Heavy wear, design outlined |
| Very Fine (VF) | 20–35 | Moderate wear, major details clear |
| About Uncirculated (AU) | 50–58 | Slight wear on high points |
| Mint State (MS) / Uncirculated | 60–70 | No wear; marks and lustre decide grade |
Grades describe condition only. They do not change a coin's face value or its status as money, and they are separate from the metal content that sets the melt value of a gold or silver piece.
Ref 1150000105