Coin grading is the practice of judging and recording the physical condition of a coin, using agreed terms or a numerical scale. A grade sums up how much wear a coin has suffered since it was struck, how well it was made, and how attractive its surfaces are. Collectors, dealers, auction houses and museums use grades to describe coins consistently, because two coins of the same date and type can differ greatly in condition.
Grading belongs to numismatics rather than to money in circulation. A worn coin and a perfect one of the same denomination have the same face value and remain equally good as legal tender. Grade matters only where coins are bought and sold as collectables. In the United States the dominant system is the numerical Sheldon scale, while British and European dealers more often use descriptive grades. The individual terms are collected on the page Coin Grades and Grading Terms.
What graders assess
A grader examines a coin under good light and magnification and weighs several factors together:
- Wear. Friction from handling flattens the highest points of the design first, such as hair, cheekbones and lettering. The amount of detail lost is the main basis of circulated grades.
- Strike. A weak strike leaves some details soft even on an unused coin, because the metal did not fill the die fully. Strike quality depends on the press and on how worn the dies were; see Coin Minting Process.
- Lustre. Freshly struck coins show a cartwheel-like reflection produced by the flow of metal. Cleaning, polishing or heavy handling destroys it.
- Marks. Contact marks, scratches, rim knocks and hairlines reduce the grade, more so when they sit in prominent areas such as the face of a portrait.
- Eye appeal. The overall look, including toning and colour, can move a coin up or down within a range.
Graders also note problems that make a grade unreliable, such as cleaning, tooling, corrosion or repairs. Many systems record such coins with a details description instead of a straight grade.
The Sheldon scale
The numerical scale used in the United States was introduced by the American numismatist William Sheldon in 1949, in a study of early large cents. It runs from 1 to 70. Sheldon designed the numbers to track the market prices of the cents he studied; that link no longer applies, but the scale survived as a standard vocabulary. The main bands are shown below.
| Number | Adjectival grade | Typical condition |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Poor | Type barely identifiable |
| 2 to 3 | Fair, About Good | Heavily worn, date may be partly legible |
| 4 to 10 | Good, Very Good | Main design outlined, rim mostly complete |
| 12 to 35 | Fine, Very Fine | Moderate even wear, major details clear |
| 40 to 58 | Extremely Fine, About Uncirculated | Light wear on high points only |
| 60 to 70 | Mint State | No wear; differences lie in marks, strike and lustre |
A coin graded 70 shows no flaws under five-times magnification. Proof coins, made with specially prepared dies and planchets, are graded on the same numbers with a separate prefix, because their surfaces differ from ordinary strikes; see Coin Finishes, Strikes and Surfaces.
Third-party grading
From the 1980s, commercial grading services in the United States began to grade coins for a fee as independent parties to a sale. A graded coin is sealed in a tamper-evident plastic holder, often called a slab, with a label showing the grade, the coin's identification and a certification number that can be checked against the service's database. Grading by several experts, followed by sealing, was intended to reduce disputes between buyers and sellers who might otherwise disagree about condition.
These services also authenticate coins, which helps to keep counterfeit and altered pieces out of the market, and they identify varieties and error coins. Grading remains a matter of expert opinion: the same coin can receive different grades from different services, or from the same service on resubmission.
British and European grading
In the United Kingdom and much of Europe, dealers usually describe condition in words rather than numbers. Common British terms, from best to worst, are FDC (from the French fleur de coin, a flawless coin), Uncirculated, Extremely Fine, Very Fine, Fine, Fair and Poor. British grading is often described as stricter than American practice, so a coin called Very Fine in London may match a higher American number. Other languages have their own terms, such as the German vorzüglich for Extremely Fine.
Grade and value
Grade has a large effect on the price collectors pay for a coin of a given type and date, because fewer coins survive in high grades. It has no effect on face value and little effect on the price of a bullion coin, which trades mainly on metal content and melt value. Grading also covers commemorative coins and paper money: banknotes are graded on a similar 1 to 70 scale in the United States, judged by folds, tears and paper quality. Descriptions of the parts of a coin on which grades are judged are on the page Parts of a Coin.
Ref 1150000106