Commercial real estate underwriting metrics are the figures lenders, rating agencies and investors use to judge whether a property's income can support a price and a loan. They start from net operating income (NOI) and turn it into measures of sustainable cash flow, value and return on equity. Hotels add their own operating measures because their income is reset every night rather than fixed by long leases.
The members of this family feed one another. Net cash flow refines NOI for lender sizing; the going-in cap rate converts first-year income into value; cash-on-cash return shows what the equity earns after debt service; and average daily rate and RevPAR explain the room revenue behind a hotel's NOI. Each is usually read together with the debt service coverage ratio (DSCR), the loan-to-value ratio (LTV) and debt yield.
Net Cash Flow (NCF)
Net cash flow (NCF) is a property's net operating income after deducting reserves for recurring capital items, tenant improvements and leasing commissions. It is the figure lenders and rating agencies prefer for sizing loans in commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS), because NOI ignores the cash an owner must keep spending to retain tenants and maintain the building. The formula is:
Here TI is the annualised cost of tenant improvement allowances and LC is leasing commissions. An office building with NOI of $2,000,000, capital reserves of $60,000 and TI and LC reserves of $140,000 has NCF of $1,800,000. With annual debt service of $1,400,000, the DSCR on an NCF basis is , lower than the 1.43 that NOI alone would show.
Going-In Cap Rate
The going-in cap rate is the capitalisation rate implied by a property's expected first-year net operating income and its purchase price:
A warehouse bought for $25,000,000 that is expected to produce NOI of $1,500,000 in its first year has a going-in cap rate of . Read the other way, the same formula is used to value a property: NOI divided by a market cap rate gives an estimate of value, and a lender's commercial property valuation often starts there.
The going-in rate is contrasted with the commercial property exit cap rate, the rate assumed when the property is sold at the end of the holding period. Underwriters usually assume an exit rate somewhat higher than the going-in rate to allow for an older building and market risk.
Cash-on-Cash Return
Cash-on-cash return is the annual pre-tax cash flow to the owner after debt service, divided by the cash equity invested. It is also called the equity dividend rate, and is sometimes loosely called the equity yield rate, although appraisers usually reserve that term for a full internal rate of return on equity. The formula is:
If the warehouse above is bought with $8,000,000 of equity and carries annual debt service of $1,000,000, pre-tax cash flow is and the cash-on-cash return is . Unlike a cap rate, the measure reflects financing; unlike the internal rate of return (IRR), it ignores sale proceeds and the timing of cash flows.
Average Daily Rate (ADR)
Average daily rate (ADR) is a hotel's room revenue divided by the number of rooms actually sold over a period. It shows the average price paid per occupied room and is not to be confused with the American depositary receipt, which shares the abbreviation.
A 200-room hotel that sells 4,500 room nights in a 30-day month and earns $810,000 of room revenue has an ADR of , or $180 per room night. Hotel lenders track ADR against competing hotels and over time. A rising ADR with falling occupancy can mean the hotel is pricing itself out of the market, which is why ADR is always read with occupancy and RevPAR.
Revenue per Available Room (RevPAR)
Revenue per available room (RevPAR) is room revenue divided by the number of rooms available, whether sold or not. Because it combines price and occupancy, it is the main top-line measure of hotel performance:
The hotel above has room nights available. RevPAR is , or $135, which matches occupancy of times the $180 ADR. Lenders compare RevPAR with a competitive set and stress it for a downturn, since hotel NOI falls much faster than RevPAR when costs are largely fixed. That operating leverage is one reason hotel loans are underwritten to higher debt yields than office or industrial loans. Seasonal hotels are usually judged on trailing twelve-month RevPAR rather than a single month.
Ref 1180001854