Coin finishes, strikes and surfaces are a family of terms that describe how a coin was made and how its surface looks. Mints use them to label the different standards they produce, from ordinary coins for everyday use to specially prepared pieces for collectors. Graders, dealers and museums use the same words to describe a coin's condition and origin.
The terms fall into two groups. The first describes the striking method: business strikes for circulation, proof coins struck with polished dies, brilliant uncirculated pieces made to an intermediate standard, and restrikes made later from old dies. The second describes the surface itself: prooflike reflectivity, the luster created by metal flow, and the toning that forms over time. All of them feed into coin grading, but none is a grade in itself.
Business Strike (Circulation Strike)
A business strike is a coin made in the normal way for everyday use as money. It is also called a circulation strike, regular strike or commercial strike. Business strikes are produced at high speed on automatic presses, each blank receiving a single blow from the dies, and are shipped in bulk to banks and cash centres for public use.
Because speed and cost matter more than appearance, business strikes may show weak details, small marks from contact with other coins in bags and counting machines, and minor variations. They are the coins that make up currency in circulation. The term separates them from proof and specimen coins of the same design and date, which are made more slowly for collectors. The process behind them is described in the coin minting process.
Proof Coin
A proof coin is a coin struck with specially prepared dies and polished blanks, usually more than once, to give the sharpest possible detail. The result typically has mirror-like flat areas (fields) and, on many modern proofs, frosted raised designs. This contrast is called cameo, and very strong contrast is called deep or ultra cameo.
Proof is a method of manufacture, not a grade: a proof coin can be damaged or poorly kept and still be a proof. Proofs were first made as presentation pieces and die trials, and today mints such as the Royal Mint and the United States Mint sell them individually or in annual proof sets. They are handled with gloves, packed in protective capsules and sold above face value, while remaining legal tender.
Prooflike (PL)
Prooflike (PL) describes a business-strike coin whose fields are reflective enough to resemble a proof. It happens when freshly prepared or polished dies strike the first coins of a run, before the die surfaces wear. A prooflike coin is still a circulation coin; it was simply struck at a moment when the dies gave an unusually mirrored finish.
Grading services judge reflectivity by how clearly an object can be seen in the fields at a set distance. A stronger form, deep mirror prooflike (DMPL), shows sharp reflections at a greater distance. The terms are especially common for United States Morgan silver dollars, which were struck in very large numbers and often show this effect. Prooflike status adds to a coin's description alongside its grade under the coin grades and grading terms.
Brilliant Uncirculated (BU)
Brilliant uncirculated, abbreviated BU, has two meanings. In mint usage, especially in the United Kingdom, it is a production standard above ordinary circulation coins but below proof. BU coins are struck on better-prepared blanks with more care, handled to avoid contact marks, and sold in packs or presentation folders. The Royal Mint, for example, sells many commemorative designs in both BU and proof versions.
In the wider trade, BU is a looser label for any coin that shows no wear and keeps its original mint brightness. Used this way it says nothing about how the coin was made and is less precise than a numerical grade. Readers of dealer listings therefore treat "BU" with care: a mint's brilliant uncirculated product is a defined standard, while the dealer label is a description of condition.
Restrike
A restrike is a coin struck later than its original issue, using the original dies or new dies copied from them, while keeping the original date. Restrikes may be official, made by the issuing mint, or private. The best-known example is the Maria Theresa thaler, a silver trade coin that has been restruck with the date 1780 for well over two centuries and used as money far from Austria.
Mints have made restrikes for trade, for collector demand and to replace worn stock. For collectors and historians, a restrike is not the same object as an original and is usually valued differently. Restrikes can often be told apart by small changes in the dies, the edge, the metal or the weight. Unofficial restrikes from genuine dies sit close to the line with counterfeiting.
Luster
Luster (spelled lustre in British English) is the way a coin's surface reflects light. It comes from the flow lines created when metal is forced into the die under pressure. On an unworn coin these microscopic lines scatter light in a rotating band, the "cartwheel" effect seen when a coin is turned under a lamp.
Luster is described as frosty, satin or, on early-die strikes, prooflike. It is one of the main factors in grading uncirculated coins. Wear removes it from the high points first, which is how graders spot slight circulation. Harsh cleaning, polishing or chemical dipping also damages or removes original luster, and a coin with its luster stripped is usually described as cleaned, which lowers its grade.
Toning
Toning is a thin coloured film that forms on a coin's surface as the metal reacts with oxygen, sulphur and other substances in the air or in storage materials. On silver it ranges from light gold to blue, purple and black; on copper the darkening is often called patina. Gold tones far less because it reacts so little.
Collectors distinguish attractive, even toning from dark or blotchy toning, and grading services may note it. Because toning can affect price, some people create it artificially with heat or chemicals, and others remove it by dipping in acid solutions. Both practices are treated with suspicion: artificial toning can lead a grading service to refuse to grade a coin, and over-dipping destroys luster. Natural toning, by contrast, is a sign that a coin has aged undisturbed.
How the terms relate
| Term | Type | Made for |
|---|---|---|
| Business strike | Striking method | Circulation |
| Brilliant uncirculated | Striking standard or condition label | Collectors and gifts |
| Proof | Striking method | Collectors |
| Restrike | Later striking | Trade or collectors |
| Prooflike, luster, toning | Surface quality | Not applicable |
Ref 1150000104