In commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS), advances and appraisal reductions are the mechanisms that decide how bondholders are paid when loans in the pool stop paying. The master servicer advances missed payments so that the bonds, usually issued through a real estate mortgage investment conduit (REMIC), receive a steady stream of interest, but that support is limited once a new appraisal shows the property is worth less than the debt. The rules are set in each deal's pooling and servicing agreement, so details vary between transactions.
The members of the family form a sequence. Servicing advances keep cash flowing; a non-recoverable advance determination stops them; prepayment interest shortfalls create small gaps of their own; an appraisal reduction cuts the amount of interest advanced; and the resulting appraisal subordinate entitlement reduction (ASER) lowers interest paid to the most junior classes. The roles involved are described under CMBS servicing roles and agreements.
Servicing Advance
A servicing advance in CMBS is money the master servicer, or a backup advancing party such as the trustee, pays on behalf of a delinquent borrower. Two kinds exist. Principal and interest (P&I) advances cover scheduled monthly payments the borrower has missed, so that interest continues to reach each bondholder through the cash flow waterfall. Property protection advances, often called servicing advances in the narrow sense, pay real estate taxes, insurance premiums, ground rent and costs of preserving the property. The servicer is reimbursed when the loan cures or the property is sold, and it earns interest on outstanding advances, usually at a prime-based rate, which is paid ahead of bondholders. Advancing is a liquidity device rather than credit support: it smooths timing but does not absorb losses. The duty to advance lasts only while the servicer judges the amounts recoverable from the loan.
Non-Recoverable Advance
A non-recoverable advance is an advance, made or proposed, that the master or special servicer determines in its good-faith business judgment will not ultimately be repaid from proceeds of the related loan or property. Once that determination is made, the servicer stops advancing on the loan and may reimburse itself for amounts already advanced, with interest, from general collections on the whole pool rather than from the defaulted loan alone. Because the servicer is repaid before certificateholders, a non-recoverable determination can cause sudden interest shortfalls on the lower classes, and sometimes the use of principal collections to reimburse the servicer. Deals typically let the servicer spread reimbursement over several periods to soften the effect. Determinations are often supported by a recent appraisal and can be challenged by the controlling class. They mark the point at which a delinquent loan's losses begin to reach investors.
Prepayment Interest Shortfall
A prepayment interest shortfall arises when a borrower repays its loan on a date other than the scheduled payment date and pays interest only up to the payoff date, while bondholders are entitled to a full month of interest. Most fixed-rate commercial mortgages restrict early repayment through lockouts, defeasance or yield maintenance, which limits the problem, but prepayments after defaults, casualty or condemnation still create it. The master servicer usually covers the gap with compensating interest, paid out of its own servicing fee for the period up to a cap set in the pooling agreement. Any remaining shortfall is allocated among the interest-bearing classes, typically pro rata to the interest they are owed, and recorded in an interest shortfall account that may or may not be repaid later.
Appraisal Reduction
An appraisal reduction is an amount calculated when a specially serviced loan suffers an appraisal reduction event, such as prolonged delinquency, a material modification, bankruptcy of the borrower or the appointment of a receiver. The special servicer obtains a new appraisal report, and a common formula in US deals is:
Here is the loan balance, accrued unpaid interest, unreimbursed advances and other amounts owed, and the new appraised value less senior liens, estimated using standard real estate valuation approaches. For a loan with a 50 million balance, 2 million of interest and advances and a 40 million appraisal, the reduction is million. The reduction lowers future P&I advances on the loan in proportion and, in many deals, reduces the deemed balance of junior classes when deciding who holds control.
Appraisal Subordinate Entitlement Reduction (ASER)
An appraisal subordinate entitlement reduction (ASER) is the amount by which interest advanced on a loan is cut because of an appraisal reduction. The servicer advances interest only on the part of the balance not covered by the reduction, so in the example above, with a 16 million reduction on a 50 million loan, interest advances fall by 32%. At a 6% interest rate the scheduled interest is 250,000 a month, and the ASER is a month. That reduction flows to the most junior outstanding class first, then upwards, so subordinate bondholders stop receiving interest on what is in effect an estimated loss, consistent with subordination. Some deals and data providers call related adjustments collateral valuation adjustments (CVA). ASERs reverse if the loan returns to performing status, and they become realised losses if the loan is liquidated, a stage covered under CMBS defaults, losses and maturity risks.
Ref 1180001847