Real estate valuation approaches are the methods appraisers use to estimate the market value of land and buildings. Professional practice recognises three: the sales comparison approach, which looks at what similar properties sold for; the income approach, which values the income a property produces; and the cost approach, which adds the value of the land to the cost of replacing the buildings, less depreciation. Lenders, investors, courts, tax assessors and insurers all rely on valuations built from these approaches.
An appraisal normally considers all three and then reconciles them into a single opinion of value, giving most weight to the approach with the best data for the property type. The cost approach deducts three forms of depreciation: physical deterioration, functional obsolescence and economic obsolescence. The two kinds of obsolescence are covered here alongside the approaches themselves. The standards appraisers follow, and the assumptions they state, are covered under commercial appraisal standards and assumptions.
Sales Comparison Approach
The sales comparison approach estimates value from the prices paid for similar properties that sold recently in the same market, known as comparables. The appraiser selects the closest sales, then adjusts each price for differences from the subject property, such as location, size, age, condition, quality and the terms or date of sale. If a comparable office sold for 4.0 million but is 10% larger than the subject, its price is adjusted down to reflect the smaller subject. The adjusted prices are then weighed to reach an indicated value. The approach reflects what buyers actually pay and is usually given the most weight for houses, small commercial buildings and land, where sales are frequent. It is weaker when few comparable sales exist, in falling or illiquid markets, and for unusual properties, where large adjustments make the result more a matter of judgement.
Income Approach
The income approach values a property by the income it is expected to produce. In direct capitalisation, one year's stabilised {a('/wiki/n/net-operating-income-noi','net operating income (NOI)')} is divided by a {a('/wiki/c/capitalisation-rate','capitalisation rate')} drawn from market sales:
A shopping centre with NOI of 650,000 and a market cap rate of 6.5% is valued at 650,000 ÷ 0.065 = 10.0 million. The second method, a discounted cash flow analysis, projects income and a sale price over a holding period of perhaps ten years and discounts them to the present, which suits properties with changing leases or rents. The income approach dominates for income-producing real estate such as offices, apartments and warehouses, because buyers price these mainly by their cash flow. Its results are sensitive to small changes in the cap rate or rent assumptions.
Cost Approach
The cost approach values a property as the value of the land, as if vacant, plus the current cost of building the improvements, minus accumulated depreciation:
With land worth 2.0 million, a replacement cost of 9.0 million and depreciation of 1.5 million, the indicated value is 9.5 million. Depreciation in appraisal is a loss in value, not the accounting charge, and is made up of physical deterioration, functional obsolescence and economic obsolescence. The approach is most reliable for new buildings, where depreciation is small, and for special-use properties such as schools, churches or industrial plants that rarely sell and do not produce rent. It is less reliable for older buildings, because estimating total depreciation becomes difficult, and it says nothing directly about what the market will pay.
Functional Obsolescence
Functional obsolescence is a loss in a property's value caused by features of the property itself that no longer meet market expectations. Examples include a poor floor plan, low ceilings in a warehouse built before modern racking, too few bathrooms, outdated heating and cooling systems, inadequate power or data cabling in an office, or, at the other extreme, costly features that buyers will not pay for, known as an over-improvement. Appraisers classify it as curable when the cost of fixing the problem is no more than the value it would add, and incurable when it is not. It differs from physical deterioration, which is wear and tear, and from economic obsolescence, which comes from outside the property. The wider idea of assets falling behind current standards is covered under obsolescence.
Economic Obsolescence (External Obsolescence)
Economic obsolescence, also called external obsolescence, is a loss in value caused by factors outside the property and beyond the owner's control. Common causes are a local economic decline or loss of a major employer, oversupply of similar space, new zoning or environmental rules, a nearby nuisance such as a landfill, airport noise or a highway that diverts traffic, and changes in demand for the property type. Because the owner cannot change the surroundings, economic obsolescence is almost always treated as incurable. Appraisers often measure it by comparing the rent or sale prices of affected properties with those of similar unaffected ones, or by capitalising the income loss. It can affect land as well as buildings, and the same idea applies to plant and equipment that loses value when the industry using it shrinks.
Reconciliation of the approaches
Reconciliation is the final step, in which the appraiser compares the values indicated by each approach and explains which is most reliable. For a leased warehouse indicated at 10.0 million by the income approach, 10.4 million by sales comparison and 9.5 million by cost, the appraiser might rely mostly on the income figure and conclude at about 10.0 million. Lenders review this step closely when using the valuation in collateral valuation for lending and in measures such as loan-to-value under commercial real estate underwriting metrics.
Ref 1180001867