Tier 1 capital is the highest-quality layer of a bank's regulatory capital: the resources that can absorb losses while the bank keeps operating, without it having to fail or be wound down. Under Basel III, the international standard agreed by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, Tier 1 capital consists of Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) plus Additional Tier 1 (AT1) capital.
Supervisors measure a bank's Tier 1 capital against its risk-weighted assets and against its total exposures. It sits above Tier 2 capital, which is mainly subordinated debt that absorbs losses only when a bank fails. Tier 1 and Tier 2 together form a bank's total capital, but the strictest requirements apply to Tier 1 and especially to its CET1 core.
What counts as Tier 1 capital
The two components differ in quality:
- Common Equity Tier 1. This is ordinary share capital, share premium and retained earnings, plus certain reserves. It is the purest form of loss absorption, because it has no fixed repayment date and no obligation to pay dividends.
- Additional Tier 1. These are perpetual instruments with fully discretionary coupons that the bank can cancel without causing a default. They must convert into shares or be written down if the bank's CET1 ratio falls below a trigger, which is why many are issued as contingent convertible bonds.
CET1 is calculated after regulatory deductions for items that may have little value in a crisis. The main ones are goodwill and other intangible assets, certain deferred tax assets, shortfalls in provisions against expected losses, and significant investments in other financial institutions.
Minimum requirements and buffers
Basel III sets minimum ratios as a share of risk-weighted assets: 4.5% for CET1, 6% for Tier 1 and 8% for total capital. On top of these minimums, banks must hold a capital conservation buffer of 2.5% in CET1, and national authorities can add a countercyclical capital buffer when credit grows quickly. Global systemically important banks carry an extra surcharge, and supervisors set further firm-specific requirements under Pillar 2.
A bank that falls into its buffers faces automatic limits on dividends, share buybacks, bonuses and AT1 coupons. In practice, large banks therefore hold Tier 1 capital well above the 6% minimum. In the European Union these standards are applied through the Capital Requirements Regulation, and other jurisdictions have their own implementing rules.
Formula and example
The Tier 1 capital ratio is:
CET1 and AT1 are measured after regulatory deductions, and risk-weighted assets are the bank's exposures adjusted for credit, market and operational risk. A bank with CET1 of 42 billion, AT1 of 8 billion and risk-weighted assets of 400 billion has Tier 1 capital of 50 billion and a Tier 1 ratio of . Its CET1 ratio is , comfortably above the 7% that the CET1 minimum plus the conservation buffer requires.
Tier 1 and the leverage ratio
Tier 1 capital is also the numerator of the leverage ratio, which compares capital with total exposures without risk weighting. Basel III sets a minimum of 3%, with an additional buffer for global systemically important banks. If the bank in the example has a total exposure measure of 1,250 billion, its leverage ratio is .
The leverage ratio acts as a backstop. Risk weights depend on models and assumptions, and banks before the 2007 to 2009 crisis were able to report healthy risk-based ratios while holding thin capital relative to their balance sheets. A simple Tier 1 leverage requirement limits how far this can go.
History and debate
The idea of tiered capital comes from the first Basel Accord of 1988, which separated core Tier 1 capital from supplementary capital and required total capital of 8% of risk-weighted assets. Before the crisis, Tier 1 could include hybrid instruments that did little to absorb losses in practice. Basel III, agreed in 2010 and phased in over the following decade, tightened the definition, raised the minimums and made common equity the dominant component.
Debate continues over the role of AT1. Its loss absorption was tested in March 2023, when Swiss authorities wrote down Credit Suisse's AT1 bonds in full as part of its rescue takeover, while shareholders received some value. The decision, permitted by the bonds' terms and Swiss law, unsettled investors who had expected equity to bear losses first, and it prompted regulators elsewhere to restate that in their regimes shareholders would absorb losses before AT1 holders.
External links
Ref 1030001021