A hybrid instrument is a financial instrument that combines the characteristics of two different types of instrument. In corporate finance the term usually means a security that sits between debt and equity: it may pay a fixed return like a bond but rank low in a liquidation, have no maturity date, allow payments to be skipped, or convert into shares. In US derivatives law it has a narrower meaning: a security or bank deposit whose payments are tied to the price of a commodity.
Companies issue hybrids to raise capital on terms that neither plain bonds nor ordinary shares would allow. Investors buy them for a yield higher than that on senior debt or for a share in the upside of the equity. Because the instruments blend features, their treatment by tax authorities, rating agencies, accounting standards and regulators is a central part of their design.
Main types of debt-equity hybrid
- Convertible securities. A convertible bond pays interest and can be exchanged for a fixed number of the issuer's shares. Convertible preferred stock works in the same way with dividends in place of interest.
- Preferred shares. Preferred stock pays a stated dividend ahead of ordinary shares and ranks above them, but below all debt, if the company is wound up.
- Subordinated and perpetual debt. Deeply subordinated notes, often with very long maturities or in the form of a perpetual bond, let the issuer defer interest without triggering default.
- Bank capital instruments. A contingent convertible bond is written down or converted into shares if the bank's capital falls below a trigger. Such bonds count as Additional Tier 1 capital under Basel III.
- Mezzanine finance. Loans with warrants or profit participation, described under mezzanine financing, are common in private company and buyout funding.
Conversion value and worked example
For a convertible, the equity element is measured by what the holder would receive on conversion:
- is the conversion ratio, the number of shares received for each bond.
- is the current share price.
- is the market price of the bond.
A bond with a face value of $1,000 that converts into 20 shares, when the share trades at $45, has a conversion value of dollars. If the bond trades at $1,020, the conversion premium is percent. The premium reflects the bond's interest payments and the protection its redemption value gives if the share price falls. As the share price rises, the bond behaves more like equity; as it falls, more like ordinary debt.
Why issuers use hybrids
The appeal for an issuer lies in obtaining some benefits of equity without all of its cost. Interest on a hybrid structured as debt is usually deductible for tax, unlike dividends. Rating agencies may treat part of a deeply subordinated, deferrable issue as equity when assessing leverage, which supports the company's credit rating without diluting shareholders. Banks and insurers use hybrids to meet regulatory capital requirements more cheaply than by issuing shares. A convertible lets a company borrow at a lower coupon in exchange for giving investors an option on its stock.
The rules that grant these benefits change, and a hybrid that loses its tax or capital treatment is often redeemed early under a clause written for that purpose.
Risks for investors
Hybrids carry risks that plain bonds do not. Payments can be deferred or cancelled, sometimes without any right to recover them later. The instruments rank near the bottom of the capital structure, so recoveries after a failure are low. Many have no fixed maturity and are priced on the assumption that the issuer will redeem at the first call date; if it chooses not to, the price can fall sharply. Loss-absorbing bank instruments may be wiped out by a regulator's decision. This happened in 2023, when the Additional Tier 1 bonds of Credit Suisse were written down to zero as part of its takeover by UBS, even though shareholders received some value.
Hybrid instruments in US commodity law
The Commodity Exchange Act uses the term for a security, such as a bond or preferred share, or a bank deposit, that has one or more payments indexed to the value or level of a commodity. A commodity-linked bond whose redemption amount depends on the price of gold or oil is an example. The question is whether such a product is a security or a futures or commodity option contract, since the latter would fall under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and might have to trade on a regulated futures exchange.
The Act excludes a hybrid instrument from that regime if it is predominantly a security. Broadly, the issuer must receive full payment at the outset, the holder must not be required to make further payments such as margin, and the instrument must not be marketed as a futures contract. Many structured products sold to investors rely on this exclusion.
Accounting treatment
Accounting standards use hybrid for a contract made up of a host, such as a loan, and an embedded derivative that alters its cash flows. Depending on the standard and the type of contract, the derivative may have to be separated and carried at fair value, or the whole instrument measured at fair value. An issuer of a convertible may likewise have to split it into a liability and an equity component. These rules affect reported profit and leverage and are a further consideration in designing a hybrid.