A global systemically important bank (G-SIB) is a bank whose size, connections and international reach are such that its distress or disorderly failure could cause serious damage to the global financial system and the wider economy. The Financial Stability Board (FSB), working with the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS), names these banks in a list published each November, and national authorities then apply stricter rules to them than to other banks.
The framework was a response to the financial crisis of 2007 to 2009, when governments rescued large banks because letting them fail looked more dangerous than the cost of support, the problem known as "too big to fail". The G20 endorsed the approach in 2011, and the first list, published that November, named 29 banks. The G-SIB regime sits alongside the national regimes for domestic systemically important banks (D-SIBs), and in the European Union the matching legal category is the global systemically important institution (G-SII).
How banks are assessed
The Basel Committee's indicator-based method measures the damage a bank's failure would do, not how likely it is to fail. Large banks, broadly those whose leverage ratio exposure measure exceeds €200 billion, together with any bank already designated, report data as at the end of each financial year. Their scores are built from five categories of equal weight, 20% each:
- Size. Total exposures, measured as for the leverage ratio.
- Interconnectedness. Claims on and liabilities to other financial institutions, and the securities the bank has outstanding.
- Substitutability. The bank's role in payments, in holding assets in custody and in underwriting debt and equity, which indicates how hard its services would be to replace.
- Complexity. Over-the-counter derivatives, trading and available-for-sale securities, and assets valued with unobservable inputs.
- Cross-jurisdictional activity. Claims on and liabilities to counterparties outside the home country.
Supervisors may also use judgement, backed by supplementary indicators, to adjust the result.
Scores and buckets
Each indicator is scored as the bank's share of the total for the whole sample, expressed in basis points:
Here the bank value is the bank's reported figure for one indicator and the sample total is the sum of that figure across all assessed banks. Indicator scores are averaged within each category, and the category scores are averaged to give the overall score. A bank holding €210 billion in custody, in a sample total of €14,000 billion, scores basis points on that indicator.
Banks whose overall score passes a cut-off of 130 basis points are designated and placed in one of five buckets, each 100 basis points wide. The bucket sets the higher loss absorbency (HLA) requirement, an extra layer of Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital expressed as a share of risk-weighted assets: 1% for bucket 1, 1.5% for bucket 2, 2% for bucket 3, 2.5% for bucket 4 and 3.5% for bucket 5. The top bucket has normally been left empty, and the larger step up to it is meant to discourage banks from becoming more systemic. A list published in November sets the requirement that applies from January of the year after next, which gives banks about fourteen months to adjust.
Further requirements
The capital surcharge is only one part of the regime. G-SIBs are also expected to:
- Meet the FSB standard for total loss-absorbing capacity (TLAC), agreed in November 2015, which for banks in advanced economies has required loss-absorbing capital and debt of at least 18% of risk-weighted assets and 6.75% of the leverage exposure measure since 2022.
- Hold a leverage ratio buffer equal to half of their risk-weighted HLA rate, under the final Basel III reforms.
- Maintain recovery plans and support resolution planning by home and host authorities, which meet in crisis management groups and assess each bank's resolvability.
- Follow the Basel Committee's principles for risk data aggregation and risk reporting, known as BCBS 239, and accept more intensive supervision.
National implementation
The FSB list and the Basel method are not law in themselves; each jurisdiction writes them into its own rules as part of Basel III. In the United States the Federal Reserve calculates a surcharge under two methods, one close to the Basel approach and one that replaces substitutability with reliance on short-term wholesale funding, and applies the higher result, which often exceeds the Basel figure. In the European Union the Capital Requirements Directive (CRD) sets a G-SII buffer, and in the euro area the ECB, through the Single Supervisory Mechanism, can apply stricter buffers than national authorities set.
Composition and criticism
The list has usually named around 30 banks, mostly headquartered in the United States, the euro area, the United Kingdom, Japan, China, Canada and Switzerland. Membership changes slowly: some banks have left after shrinking or restructuring, the large Chinese state-owned banks were added during the 2010s, and Credit Suisse was removed after its takeover by UBS in 2023.
Supporters argue that the regime has made the largest banks hold far more capital and loss-absorbing debt and has made their resolution more credible, reducing systemic risk. Critics point out that scores are relative shares of a sample, so they move with exchange rates and with other banks' growth; that banks can shrink balance sheets around the year-end reporting date to lower their scores; and that the rescue of Credit Suisse through a merger rather than a resolution showed the limits of planning for a G-SIB failure.