Tax-loss harvesting is an investment technique in which an investor sells a holding that has fallen below its purchase price in order to realise a capital loss, uses that loss to reduce tax on gains made elsewhere, and reinvests the proceeds in a comparable asset. The portfolio keeps roughly the same market exposure, but the investor’s tax bill for the year falls. It is used by individual investors, financial advisers, robo-advisors and managers of separately managed accounts.
The technique only applies in taxable accounts; losses inside tax-advantaged retirement accounts usually bring no benefit. It is shaped by national tax law. In the United States, the main rules come from the Internal Revenue Code and are administered by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), and the most important constraint is the wash-sale rule. Other countries have their own anti-avoidance rules, such as the UK’s 30-day share-matching rule for capital gains tax.
How tax-loss harvesting works
A capital loss arises only when an investment is sold for less than its cost basis. A fall in price on its own is an unrealised loss and has no tax effect. Once realised, the loss is netted against realised gains in the same tax year. Under US rules, short-term losses first offset short-term gains and long-term losses first offset long-term gains, after which any remaining net loss in one category offsets net gains in the other.
If losses exceed gains, US taxpayers can deduct up to $3,000 of net capital loss a year against ordinary income ($1,500 for a married person filing separately). Any loss beyond that is carried forward to later years without a time limit, as a tax loss carryforward. Because short-term capital gains are taxed at ordinary income rates, which are generally higher than the rates on long-term capital gains, a loss used against short-term gains usually saves the most tax.
Estimating the tax saving
The immediate saving from a harvested loss can be estimated as:
Here is the realised loss used to offset gains or income, and is the investor’s tax rate on the gains or income it offsets, written as a decimal. For example, an investor who has $10,000 of short-term gains taxed at 24% and harvests a $10,000 loss saves:
That is a saving of $2,400 in the current year. The saving is often a deferral rather than a permanent gain: the replacement holding is bought at a lower price, so its cost basis is lower and a larger gain may be taxed when it is eventually sold. The benefit is greatest when the deferred gain is later taxed at a lower rate, is never realised, or receives a step-up in basis at death under US rules.
The wash-sale rule
The US wash-sale rule, in Section 1091 of the Internal Revenue Code, disallows a loss if the investor buys a substantially identical security within 30 days before or after the sale, a 61-day window in total. The disallowed loss is not lost for ever: it is added to the cost basis of the replacement shares and its holding period carries over. Purchases in a spouse’s account or in the investor’s own retirement account can also trigger the rule, and in the retirement-account case the loss may be lost permanently.
The IRS has not published a precise test for what is substantially identical. Shares of the same company clearly are. Two funds tracking different indices are generally treated as not substantially identical, which is why harvesters often switch between exchange-traded funds that follow similar but distinct benchmarks. Funds tracking the same index from different managers sit in a grey area.
Tools and practice
Harvesting has become more systematic as software has made it cheaper to monitor positions daily. Common approaches include:
- Fund swaps. Selling one broad-market ETF at a loss and buying another with a similar but different index keeps market exposure close to unchanged.
- Direct indexing. Holding the individual shares of an index, through direct indexing, creates many separate positions, so some can be sold at a loss even in a year when the index as a whole rises.
- Year-round monitoring. Automated platforms check for losses after market falls rather than waiting for the end of the year, when many investors traditionally review their portfolios.
Losses and gains are reported to US taxpayers by brokers on Form 1099-B, which also flags wash sales the broker can see in the same account.
Limitations and risks
Tax-loss harvesting has costs. Each switch incurs trading costs and a bid-ask spread, and the replacement holding may perform differently from the one sold, creating tracking error against the intended portfolio. Repeated harvesting steadily lowers cost basis, building up deferred gains that may limit flexibility later. Wash sales across several accounts are easy to trigger by accident, for example through automatic dividend reinvestment. Finally, the value of the technique depends on the investor’s current and future tax rates, which are uncertain and set by legislation that can change.
External links
Ref 1010001374